TJX Stock: A Value Investor’s Comedy of Errors

TJX Companies-the retail giant behind TJ Maxx, Marshalls, and HomeGoods-decided to throw a little party for itself on Wednesday morning. Shares popped 6.6% by 9:45 a.m. ET after the company beat Wall Street’s expectations for fiscal Q2 2026 earnings. But before you grab your confetti cannons, dear reader, let’s take a closer look at this financial fiesta.

Analysts had penciled in $1.01 per share on sales shy of $14.2 billion, but TJX strutted out with $1.10 per share and $14.4 billion in revenue. Impressive? Sure. Groundbreaking? Not exactly. It’s like showing up to a costume contest dressed as Abraham Lincoln when everyone else came as George Washington-it’s better, sure, but is it *worth it*?

A Tale of Two Quarters

Same-store sales grew 4%, which sounds respectable until you factor in new stores that pushed total sales growth to 7%. Earnings leapt ahead even faster, soaring 15% year over year. And between Q1 and Q2, both sales and earnings picked up the pace. Year-to-date (H1), though, sales are only up 6%, while earnings have risen just 7%. So much for “acceleration.” If this were a horse race, we’d be watching a nag trot past the finish line.

CEO Ernie Herrman declared himself “extremely pleased” with these numbers, citing strong sales, profit margins, and earnings-all growing “above our plan.” Naturally, management raised guidance faster than I raise an eyebrow at a suspiciously cheap suit. But hold onto your monocles, folks, because there’s more to unpack here.

To Buy or Not to Buy? That Is the Question

Now, not everything smells like roses-or discounted designer handbags-at TJX HQ. While Herrman claims Q3 is off to a “strong start,” the company is guiding for same-store sales growth of just 2% to 3%. Earnings are expected to land around $1.18 per share-a mere 3.5% increase year over year and well below analysts’ forecast of $1.22. Ouch. That’s less exciting than finding a hole in your favorite bargain bin sweater.

On the bright side, TJX expects full-year earnings to grow 6% to 7%, reaching $4.52 to $4.57 per share thanks to those plump profit margins. This beats Wall Street’s projection of $4.51 and improves previous guidance by as much as $0.18. Bravo! Or should I say… bravo-ish?

But here’s where my value investor hat starts pinching. Can 3% sales growth or even 7% profit growth justify TJX’s lofty valuation of 31 times earnings? Absolutely not. It’s like paying top dollar for a matinee ticket to see a silent film festival. Sure, some people might enjoy it, but is it really worth the premium?

In conclusion, TJX may be putting on a good show, but as any savvy shopper knows, shiny packaging doesn’t always mean quality goods inside. Keep your wits about you, dear investor, lest you end up buying a pig in a poke-or, in this case, overpriced shares 😏.

2025-08-20 18:45

A Tale of Two Quarters

To Buy or Not to Buy? That Is the Question

Read More