Nickelback tops the poll: The ultimate dad rock band of today?

by

Well now, let me tell ya something about my old man’s music tastes! As a kid growing up in the 90s and early 2000s, I thought my dad was stuck in a time warp with his love for bands like Bon Jovi, Guns N’ Roses, and the Red Hot Chili Peppers. But boy, did those boys know how to rock!

We’ve been curious about the music people enjoy while they work, so now let me ask: What kind of music does your father prefer? In a recent study by Merchoid, an attempt was made to determine which band embodies “dad rock” in today’s era. After questioning 3,000 Americans, the data unveiled some unexpected and perhaps uncomfortable truths (a similar survey was conducted in the UK regarding perceptions of “dad rock”).

With approximately 26% of the votes, it’s Nickelback who leads the way. A band that sparks both admiration and criticism, they have a dedicated fan base. Formed back in 1995 in Hanna, Alberta, Canada, this group is renowned for their post-grunge music and has sold more than 50 million albums globally. Songs like “How You Remind Me” and “Photograph” cemented them as a mainstay of early 2000s rock. However, their musical style, which some deem formulaic, has been a subject of criticism, even by those who appreciate “boomer” rock.

The findings from the survey indicate a wide variety of bands representing multiple time periods and rock genre offshoots, implying that “dad rock” is less about a particular sound and more about reminiscing or feeling connected to the past.

Sharing the runner-up spot with 12% each are Van Halen, known for their groundbreaking impact on hard rock during the late ’70s and ’80s (with Eddie Van Halen’s legendary guitar work and signature ’80s synth sound in “Jump”), and Blink-182, the popular pop-punk band from Southern California who were closely associated with the late ’90s and early 2000s. Van Halen’s debut album, simply titled “Van Halen,” dropped in 1978, while Blink-182 achieved widespread recognition with their album “Enema of the State” in 1999—two decades separating them, yet now finding themselves labeled as “dad rock.”

As a devout fan, I can’t help but admit that Van Halen’s rendition of “You Really Got Me” exudes an undeniable “dad rock” vibe, with Eddie’s unrestrained lead work seemingly detached from the song itself – setting the stage for the era of extravagant guitar performances. This style, in turn, ignited a strong reaction against lengthy guitar solos and perhaps even rock guitar as a whole, sparking a significant rebellion within the genre. However, the remaining bands on the top 10 list are a diverse collection that has shaped the face of rock music for various generations.

Nirvana vs. the Red Hot Chili Peppers: A tie!

In the ’90s, two bands from the West Coast, The Red Hot Chili Peppers and Nirvana, earned 10% of the votes each. Despite having distinct styles – funky rock with a touch of moodiness for RHCP versus grunge for Nirvana – they both significantly influenced the music scene. Established in Los Angeles in 1983, The Red Hot Chili Pepers gained recognition for their dynamic performances and unique blend of rock, funk, and punk. Their album “Blood Sugar Sex Magik” showcases a more carefree sound than “Scar Tissue”.

Nirvana, spearheaded by Kurt Cobain, not only catapulted grunge music into the limelight but also served as the voice of their generation with their 1991 album, Nevermind. While labeling “Polly” as “dad rock” may be somewhat inaccurate.

As a child of the ’90s who grew up listening to alternative music, I can’t help but feel a sense of nostalgia when thinking about Linkin Park and Guns N’ Roses. These two bands were staples in my teenage years, and their impact on the music industry is undeniable. Despite my personal preferences, it’s hard to argue that they didn’t deserve 8% of the votes for being influential figures in rock music.

Coldplay vs. Bon Jovi: Another dang tie!

Coldplay and Bon Jovi, each capturing around 6% of the vote, embody distinct aspects of rock music. The melodic, alternative style of Coldplay, formed in London in 1996, is evident in hits such as “Yellow” and “Clocks”. On the other hand, Bon Jovi, hailing from New Jersey since the ’80s, has become a staple in rock with anthemic ballads like “Livin’ on a Prayer.”

Where does Limp Bizkit stand? At the bottom of the “dad rock” pile!

To complete the lineup is Limp Bizkit, garnering 2% of the votes. This band, emblematic of the nu-metal genre in the late ’90s and early 2000s, was characterized by their intense sound and the confrontational style of their frontman, Fred Durst. Their albums, such as “Significant Other” (1999) and “Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water” (2000), are either viewed as iconic relics of that time or embarrassing artifacts, depending on who you talk to.

More scientific findings about dad rock

As a lifelong music enthusiast, I found the results of this study particularly intriguing. It seems that dad rock has managed to maintain its popularity among listeners, with 89% of respondents reporting that they listen to it. This finding highlights the enduring appeal of classic tunes and reminds me of my own experiences growing up listening to the same music as my parents.

The survey provided information about regional tastes in classic rock for dads, with Nickelback leading the pack in 17 states such as Georgia, New York, and Texas (although “How You Remind Me” might not be your cup of tea at first, give it a chance and you might find yourself appreciating it more).

In six different states, both Van Halen and Blink-182 took the lead position. Meanwhile, Nirvana, Guns N’ Roses, and the Red Hot Chili Peppers all garnered significant popularity in various regions. The Red Hot Chili Peppers found favor particularly in California and Texas, while states such as Alaska, Montana (and surprisingly Nebraska), leaned more towards Nirvana. It’s interesting to note that despite the Red Hot Chili Peppers singing “My name is Nebraska,” the preference here seems to be for Bon Jovi instead.

In essence, this survey reveals how the progression of time changes our opinions about what’s trendy in music. Bands that were once considered cutting-edge and youthful are now regarded as timeless classics within rock, appreciated by a generation that is passing them down to the next. It’s said that time slips away when we’re enjoying ourselves, and our musical preferences are among the things that make life worth living.

Read More

2024-08-07 15:01