Four MTV Unplugged albums that failed to meet expectations

by

As a longtime fan of MTV Unplugged and alternative music, I was really looking forward to Lauryn Hill’s unplugged album after her groundbreaking debut “The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill.” However, my experience listening to it left me feeling disappointed.

Some MTV Unplugged albums from the esteemed series don’t meet expectations despite numerous excellent unplugged releases, which have collectively sold over 80 million copies. Notable artists included in this concept have produced major hits. However, even the best can fail to deliver if the performance doesn’t go as planned on the day.

In the beginning of the unplugged performances, there might have been a reason for some rough edges. Musicians were still adjusting to the new format and figuring out how to adapt their songs to fit. However, it’s surprising that even late in the show’s run, several artists struggled with their approach.

Some people struggled to adapt to the unplugged method, disregarding the guidelines to a great extent. Others might not have been adequately prepared or fully committed to it. And for some musicians, this approach simply didn’t suit their style of music.

Four MTV Unplugged albums that don’t connect

People’s individual preferences play a role in this as well. Some fans may have had difficulty adjusting to the artists’ new interpretations of their beloved songs and felt disappointed. Conversely, others enthusiastically embraced the fresh arrangements. Lastly, there are those who prefer to steer clear of live albums altogether.

As a passionate gamer and music enthusiast, I’ve come across varied reactions when it comes to the MTV Unplugged series among music lovers. Despite Eric Clapton and Nirvana selling nearly 40 million albums together for their respective MTV Unplugged albums, these releases are often cited as disappointments within the community. Keeping this in perspective, I’d like to share my take on four MTV Unplugged albums that have left many fans struggling to find a connection.

Continued on next slide

Bruce Springsteen – In Concert/MTV Plugged

The title of the album hints at one of its issues – it’s not at all like a “plugged-out” or unplugged session. Initially, Bruce Springsteen planned an acoustic performance based on MTV’s request. However, after hearing how his acoustic versions sounded, he decided against it and asked for an electric show instead. MTV wanted to showcase the singer-songwriter side of Springsteen, with him sharing stories and performing excellent tunes in a cozy setting. Yet, they ultimately agreed to his switch.

I, Springsteen, took a different approach during my 1992-3 world tour. Instead of performing with my usual E Street Band, I chose to take a break and promote my new albums, “Human Touch” and “Lucky Town,” on my own. I felt it was time for a change in my music and band setup for this TV show and upcoming album project. An unplugged set would have been great, but unfortunately, that wasn’t the plan.

Springsteen mixed up his performance by omitting some classic hits and playing more tracks from his recent releases instead. This selection included eight tunes from those albums, as well as three others. Among them were “Darkness On The Edge Of Town” with a minimal arrangement, a unique bluegrass-inspired rendition of “Thunder Road,” and an unusual take on “Atlantic City.”

Fans were disappointed that the E Street Band was missing during the tour, this acoustic performance, and recording session. At the time, it appeared that the band was hesitant and uncertain as they tried to fill the large shoes left by their absence. Consequently, the performance was underwhelming, with some parts feeling drab and lacking in energy, deviating significantly from Bruce Springsteen’s signature high-energy rock shows.

Based on my personal experience as a long-time Bruce Springsteen fan, I’d say this album has its moments but doesn’t quite live up to his exceptional body of work. Springsteen shines through in certain tracks with his signature energy and skill, but overall it falls short of his usual brilliance. With an impressive discography spanning decades, there are countless other live albums and performances by him that I would prioritize over this one. As someone who has followed Springsteen’s career closely, I believe there are better representations of his artistry to explore first.

Continued on next slide

Katy Perry – MTV Unplugged

Around the end of the 2000s decade, MTV made an effort to draw in a younger demographic by introducing fresh acts to their lineup. One such artist added to their roster for this purpose was Katy Perry. In July 2009, she recorded her MTV Unplugged performance in New York City. Her EP, featuring eight songs from this session, followed suit and was made available for purchase in November of the same year.

Some people argue that Perry, known as a pop artist for her upbeat and catchy hits, may not be the best choice despite her natural talent. Her vocal abilities aren’t exceptional, but her pop songs are well-produced, making her imperfections less noticeable. However, if we remove all the studio enhancements and replace her fun pop style with a more raw, acoustic approach, success isn’t guaranteed.

When she made the EP “Perry,” she had recently put out her first album, “One For The Boys,” a year prior. This album contributed the majority of the seven songs in this acoustic version. Notably, her popular hits from that time took center stage, with “I Kissed A Girl” being a standout. Additionally, she added a song exclusive to this release titled “Brick By Brick.” She also included a rendition of “Hackensack” originally by Fountains Of Wayne.

It’s clear that some individuals may enjoy or be indifferent to Katy Perry’s latest EP. However, from my perspective, I yearn for greater depth and showcasing of her musical abilities in her unplugged albums. Instead of posing challenges, these records should accentuate her talent. Unfortunately, this recent release fails to meet my expectations.

Continued on next slide

Lauryn Hill – MTV Unplugged No. 2.0

As a huge fan, I must confess that Lauryn Hill’s “MTV Unplugged” album leaves me feeling quite disappointed. Compared to other “Unplugged” releases, this one doesn’t have much going for it in my opinion. While every fan may have their own preferences, sadly, Hill’s acoustic performance falls short in delivering the expected magic.

In 2001, after the success of my first solo album, “The Miseducation Of Lauryn Hill,” I was supposed to release an album full of relaxed and live performances. However, creating this album turned out to be a challenging experience for me. It felt like the soundtrack to some personal upheavals that I went through at times. On stage, I tried to be open with my audience, but there were moments when I shared too much. I had long, vague rants about various topics while playing my songs.

Instead of “And when it comes to the song list, everyone anticipated hearing selections from her initial album, but Hill completely disregarded this. New tunes were supposedly in store, yet some of the ones she performed appeared less than polished. Moreover, Hill’s vocal performance was not up to par, and she expressed regret for her hoarse voice following a late-night engagement.”

It seems unusual for someone preparing for a major TV show with that attitude. Her acoustic guitar performance raised some doubts. Doesn’t look like she’s off to a strong start compared to her debut album, right?

As a devoted fan, I’ve noticed how time and some critics have shown Hill more compassion in their evaluations. Reflecting on her album has brought about a newfound appreciation for its unique qualities. Additionally, her rendition of “Mystery Of Iniquity” earned a Grammy nomination, adding to the recognition she deserved. Kanye West is among several artists who have drawn inspiration from Hill’s work, incorporating a piece of it into one of his songs. While this may provide some relief, it doesn’t fully redeem an album that remains an odd and unsettling listening experience for many.

Continued on next slide

Korn – MTV Unplugged: Korn

Around the end of 2006, Korn as a musical group were seeking fresh ideas to reinvigorate both their audience and perhaps themselves. Their 2005 album, titled “See You On The Other Side“, introduced some stylistic shifts with elements of funk and rap, while maintaining the fundamental essence of metal music. With these modifications in place, they pondered what direction to take next.

Maybe Korn’s participation in MTV Unplugged appeared natural, considering the achievements of other artists on the show. Although the program’s prime time was during the 1990s, it continued to produce excellent music. Yet, was this opportunity thoroughly considered for Korn?

As a gamer, I’ve attended my fair share of music festivals and was taken aback by some unexpected acts in the metal and grunge genres. But let me tell you, without the deafening noise of amplified guitars cranked up to the maximum volume or the electric charge of the crowd, something felt off about Korn’s performance. With only a small audience of around 50 people gathered for the TV show and album recording, Korn was about to discover if they could still deliver their signature raw energy.

From a dedicated fan’s perspective, it seems that the solution might be hidden in the artist’s album sales and chart performance. The debut at number nine on the Billboard 200 with approximately 50,000 copies sold upon its March 2007 release was an impressive start. However, a 50% decrease in week two sales gave me some cause for concern. Sadly, the album disappeared from the chart after only seven weeks.

The sound fell flat for me. Jonathan Davis’s vocals shone brightly in powered-up tracks, but they seemed weak, thin, and whiny during this performance. It’s possible that the songs didn’t fit well with the format, or maybe more attention should have been given to the arrangements.

Although intended to vary, the modifications fell short of creating an appealing sound in my opinion. The required Korn distortion levels are crucial for achieving the desired effect. Unfortunately, no matter how fantastic Robert Smith’s appearance might be on a song, it won’t be enough to save this for me.

Read More

2024-07-15 13:31