Pizza, Predictions, and a Mild Sense of Panic

by

I’ve always found the whole concept of prediction markets… unsettling. It’s like outsourcing your gut feelings to a room full of people who probably spend too much time staring at charts. But I admit, I’ve been dabbling. Mostly because my brother-in-law, Dale, keeps bragging about his “edge.” Dale thinks he can predict anything, from the weather to which casserole will be most popular at the church potluck. This time, it was Domino’s Pizza. He was convinced they’d beat earnings. And, naturally, he wanted me to put some money on it.

The idea is simple enough. You bet on whether a company will exceed (or fall short of) its projected earnings. Polymarket, apparently, is where these bets are made. As of Sunday, Dale was practically vibrating with confidence, informing me that 64% of the “yes” contracts were held by people who, like him, believed in the power of pepperoni and a strong quarterly report. The magic number, he explained, was $5.39 a share. Anything over that, and we were golden. Anything less, and I’d be hearing about it for the next decade.

Of course, Domino’s missed. By a measly four cents. Four cents! Dale, predictably, blamed the “market forces” and the “unexpected surge in anchovy demand.” I just pictured a room full of people, equally smug and equally wrong, nursing their losses. The “no” contracts paid off, which felt… anticlimactic. Like winning a raffle for a slightly used toaster. Still, I suppose it’s better than being Dale, who is now researching the correlation between pizza toppings and economic downturns.

Prediction Markets: A Hedge Against Bad Decisions (and Dale)

These markets are supposed to be more than just a gamble. They’re touted as a way to “hedge” your investments. If you own Domino’s stock, you can buy a “no” contract to offset potential losses. If you don’t own the stock, you can still participate in the upside. It’s all very sophisticated. Or it would be, if I weren’t picturing a bunch of day traders in sweatpants, fueled by caffeine and regret. I considered it, briefly. A little insurance against my brother-in-law’s relentless optimism. But frankly, the paperwork seemed… exhausting.

The interesting thing is, even though Domino’s missed the earnings target, the stock actually rose. Apparently, their guidance for 2026 was better than expected. Which meant those “no” contract holders, like some anonymous, slightly smug stranger, were able to cash out and then immediately buy shares. It’s a system designed to reward both pessimism and a quick trigger finger. I’m starting to suspect it’s less about predicting the future and more about exploiting the present.

Loading widget...

For someone like me, who generally avoids risk, the appeal of these markets is… limited. Shorting a stock feels dishonest. Buying a “no” contract feels like admitting defeat before the battle even begins. But a “no” contract on an earnings report? That feels… reasonable. Like a pre-emptive apology for the inevitable disappointment.

Mixed Signals and Berkshire Hathaway’s Appetite

The fundamental outlook on Domino’s is… confusing. Analysts are predicting a boost from lower payroll taxes and generous tips. Morgan Stanley, however, recently downgraded the stock, citing a “challenging narrative.” It’s always something. A challenging narrative. As if running a pizza chain isn’t challenging enough. The whole thing feels precarious, like balancing a stack of pizza boxes on a unicycle.

But then there’s Berkshire Hathaway. Warren Buffett’s company actually increased its stake in Domino’s last quarter. Which is… odd. Buffett is famously cautious. He usually invests in things that are boring and predictable. Pizza doesn’t exactly scream “long-term value.” Unless, of course, he’s anticipating a global pepperoni shortage. Or maybe he just likes the smell of garlic bread. It’s a mystery.

I still haven’t decided whether to participate in these prediction markets. Dale is already planning our next venture: predicting the winner of the annual chili cook-off. I’m considering faking a sudden illness. Or maybe just investing in earplugs.

Read More

2026-02-25 06:52