VTI vs SPY: The Lesser Evil?

by

Right. So, everyone’s going on about ETFs. Exchange Traded Funds. Apparently, it’s the sensible thing to do. Diversification, they call it. As if spreading your money around makes the inevitable market crash any less… distressing. Anyway, I’ve been looking at these two: the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) and the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI). Honestly, it’s like choosing between two shades of grey. But apparently, people care. So, here’s my log.

SPY, the slightly more popular one, focuses on the big boys – the S&P 500. Feels…safe. Predictable. Like dating someone who already has a mortgage. VTI, on the other hand, is the slightly rebellious younger sibling, holding thousands of stocks. All of them. Even the tiny, obscure ones. Which sounds terrifying, frankly. Like letting your money wander off into a crowded marketplace.

Here’s a little table, because apparently, humans need data to justify their emotional decisions:

Metric SPY VTI
Issuer SPDR Vanguard
Expense ratio 0.09% 0.03%
1-yr return (as of Feb. 5, 2026) 13.13% 12.43%
Dividend yield 1.05% 1.10%
Beta (5Y monthly) 1.00 1.04
AUM $709 billion $571 billion

Okay, so VTI is cheaper. Significantly. Which is good. Because every penny counts when you’re bracing for economic armageddon. It also has a slightly better dividend yield. Which is… nice. But let’s be real, we’re not talking about life-changing amounts of money here. It’s more like the price of a decent latte. Still, I appreciate the effort. I mean, if I’m going to lose money, I’d prefer to lose slightly less of it.

Performance-wise, SPY has edged ahead, but not by much. It’s like choosing between a slightly less soggy biscuit. VTI has been a bit more volatile, which, honestly, is what you’d expect from something that owns everything. It’s like trying to herd cats. But here’s the thing: in the long run, does it really matter? We’re all just passengers on a sinking ship, aren’t we?

Inside VTI, you’ve got Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft… the usual suspects. It’s a broad church, covering all sectors. SPY is similar, but a bit more focused on the big tech giants. Which, let’s face it, are probably propping up the entire market anyway. It feels a bit… precarious. Like building a house of cards on top of a volcano.

Units of Cryptocurrency Lost: 12. Hours Spent Watching Charts: 9. Number of Panicked Texts to Friends: 24. And yet, here I am, still trying to figure out which ETF is the least terrible option. It’s exhausting.

So, what does it all mean? Well, SPY is the safe, predictable choice. It’s like marrying for stability. VTI is the slightly riskier, more diversified option. It’s like… backpacking across Europe with a questionable map and a limited budget. Both will probably get you where you need to go, eventually. But one will likely involve more grey hairs and a higher chance of getting lost.

Honestly, I think I’m leaning towards VTI. Not because it’s necessarily better, but because it feels… more honest. It’s a chaotic mess, just like my life. And sometimes, embracing the chaos is the only sane thing to do. Besides, a slightly lower expense ratio never hurt anyone.

Disclaimer: I am not a financial advisor. I am just a slightly neurotic investor trying to make sense of a senseless world. Please don’t blame me if your portfolio crashes and burns.

Read More

2026-02-07 21:23