VCIT vs. FBND: A Tale of Two Bond ETFs

The Vanguard Intermediate-Term Corporate Bond ETF (VCIT) and Fidelity Total Bond ETF (FBND) are two financial creatures that, despite their shared purpose, seem to live in parallel universes. One is a frugal scholar, the other a velvet-gloved spendthrift. Both aim to provide steady income, but their methods are as distinct as a teacup and a fire hydrant.

VCIT, with its 0.03% expense ratio, is the kind of fund that makes you wonder why anyone would pay 12 times more for a similar product. It’s like choosing a bicycle over a luxury car-both get you to the same place, but one leaves you with more money in your pocket. FBND, meanwhile, offers a slightly higher yield and a smoother ride, though its 0.36% fee feels less like an investment and more like a toll on the highway of financial wisdom.

Snapshot (cost & size)

Metric VCIT FBND
Issuer Vanguard Fidelity
Expense ratio 0.03% 0.36%
1-yr return (as of 2026-01-13) 11.18% 8.98%
Dividend yield 4.62% 4.71%
Beta 1.10 0.97
AUM $61.8 billion $23.4 billion

Imagine two siblings: one is a penny-pincher who never spends more than necessary, the other a spendthrift who believes that higher prices equate to higher quality. VCIT’s low cost is impressive, but FBND’s slightly higher yield feels like a consolation prize for those who’ve already surrendered to the siren song of convenience.

Performance & risk comparison

Metric VCIT FBND
Max drawdown (5 y) -20.56% -17.23%
Growth of $1,000 over 5 years $874 $862

VCIT’s volatility is like a rollercoaster with a safety harness, while FBND’s smoother ride feels more like a leisurely hot-air balloon journey. Yet both leave you wondering if the thrill of the climb is worth the price of admission.

What’s inside

FBND is the financial equivalent of a well-stocked library, with over 2,700 bonds spanning every corner of the fixed-income universe. Its diversification is so thorough, you’d think it’s trying to outdo a Swiss bank vault. VCIT, by contrast, is the focused scholar of corporate bonds, concentrating on intermediate-term investments with the precision of a librarian who’s never misplaced a book.

Both are diversified, but where FBND spreads its bets like a gambler at a casino, VCIT plays it safe, sticking to the familiar terrain of investment-grade corporate debt. It’s like choosing between a well-worn map and a GPS with uncharted routes.

What this means for investors

For those who crave predictability, VCIT is the steadfast companion that never surprises you-its returns are as reliable as a grandfather clock. FBND, however, is the unpredictable friend who might take you on an adventure, but at the cost of a higher price tag and less clarity on what’s driving the results.

Investors must ask themselves: Do they want a bond fund that behaves like a well-rehearsed play, or one that adapts to the whims of the market like a jazz musician? VCIT’s simplicity is its strength, while FBND’s flexibility is its charm-though both come with their own set of trade-offs.

Advertisement

In the end, the choice between VCIT and FBND is less about which offers a better return and more about what kind of financial companion you prefer. One is a reliable old friend, the other a charming but expensive acquaintance. Either way, the market remains a mystery as vast as the ocean, and no fund can guarantee a smooth sail.

Glossary

ETF (Exchange-traded fund): A group project where everyone contributes, but you can buy a share.
Expense ratio: The price of convenience, paid annually.
Dividend yield: The income a fund gives you, like a monthly allowance.
Beta: A measure of how much a fund’s price dances to the market’s tune.
AUM (Assets under management): The size of the financial party.
Max drawdown: The largest drop in a fund’s fortunes, like a financial heart attack.
Investment-grade corporate bonds: Bonds from companies so solid, they’re practically unbreakable.
Intermediate-term bonds: Bonds that wait just long enough to test your patience.
Yield: The income a bond promises, like a promise of cake at a party.
Portfolio concentration: How focused a fund is, like a detective with a single clue.
Holdings: The securities a fund owns, like a treasure chest.
Total return: The full story of a fund’s performance, including all the small details.

📉

Read More

2026-01-15 07:12