TV Shows That Are Way Better Than Their Ratings Suggest

Throughout TV history, plenty of shows haven’t become instant hits, and some even received poor reviews when they first aired. Often, these programs featured ambitious storylines, groundbreaking production styles, or ideas that were simply too new for audiences and critics at the time. Interestingly, many of these overlooked shows have since gained dedicated fans who believe they were unfairly judged. This list showcases fifty television series that deserve another chance, highlighting their creative strengths and lasting quality.

‘The River’ (2012)

This scary series follows a research team venturing into the Amazon rainforest to search for a lost TV explorer. Presented as found footage, the show builds a uniquely tense and unsettling mood. The story draws on local legends and strange creatures that constantly threaten the team. Though it didn’t last long, the show is well-remembered for its suspense and creative premise.

‘The Shannara Chronicles’ (2016–2017)

This fantasy series is an adaptation of Terry Brooks’ beloved books, taking place in a world recovering from an apocalypse where magic has reappeared. It follows a battle between elves, humans, and trolls to safeguard the ancient Ellcrys tree. Though it began as a show aimed at younger audiences, it quickly delves into complex topics like sacrifice and political maneuvering within the land of the Four Lands. The series is visually stunning, boasting impressive special effects and a richly imagined world.

‘Dollface’ (2019–2022)

Okay, so this show really grabbed me. It centers on Jules, who’s reeling from a breakup and suddenly has to lean on the female friendships she’s kind of taken for granted. What’s brilliant is how the show shows us what she’s feeling, not just tells us. They do this through some wonderfully weird visuals – seriously, the bus driver is a literal ‘cat lady,’ and it totally works as a metaphor for Jules’ inner life. It’s funny, but it’s not just fluff. It’s a really smart, refreshing take on the sitcom format, blending absurd humor with surprisingly honest observations about how we connect – or don’t – with each other these days. It’s a genuinely imaginative show that offers a new perspective on modern relationships.

‘Defiance’ (2013–2015)

Defiance is set on a dramatically changed Earth where humans live alongside various alien species. The town of Defiance represents a delicate attempt at peace. The show blends science fiction with the feel of a western, following lawman Joshua Nolan and his alien daughter as they deal with local issues and dangers from outside. What made Defiance unique was its connection to a large online game of the same name, and the show built a detailed world with interesting and diverse alien cultures, which often went unnoticed.

‘Cracking Up’ (2004)

Created by Mike White, this darkly funny show centers on a psychology student who rents a guest house from a very strange and troubled family in Beverly Hills. Instead of following typical sitcom formulas, the show features eccentric characters with hidden emotional issues. Each episode shows the awkward and unusual interactions between the student and the family as he observes them for his research. With its clever writing and unique humor, it’s a memorable example of the experimental comedies that emerged in the early 2000s.

‘Ghosted’ (2017–2018)

This funny, otherworldly series follows a former detective who doesn’t believe in the paranormal and his enthusiastic, supernatural-loving partner as they investigate strange happenings in Los Angeles. The chemistry between actors Adam Scott and Craig Robinson drives the show’s heart, reminiscent of the iconic duo from ‘The X-Files’. It cleverly mixes workplace comedy with real sci-fi mysteries and standalone adventures. Though some saw it as just a spoof, the show ultimately stood out with its smart writing and well-developed characters.

‘Powerless’ (2017)

This comedy is set in the world of DC Comics and follows the everyday employees of Wayne Security, the company that creates safety products for when superheroes fight crime. The show humorously explores what it’s like to live in a city constantly damaged by these battles. Vanessa Hudgens stars as a cheerful new employee who tries to lift the spirits of her more cynical colleagues. It’s a funny, realistic take on a universe usually known for its grand adventures and famous heroes.

‘Galavant’ (2015–2016)

This funny musical series centers around a charming knight trying to win back his happy ending from a wicked king. With original music by the famous Alan Menken, the show playfully acknowledges and comments on classic fairy tale conventions. It’s a unique mix of silly physical comedy, witty dialogue, and big musical performances, making it stand out from typical TV shows. The energetic cast and special guest stars contribute to the show’s lively, stage-like atmosphere in every episode.

‘Haters Back Off’ (2016–2017)

I’ve been watching this series that tells the story of how Miranda Sings, the internet personality, came to be. It’s hilarious and a little sad to see how much she believes in herself, even though she’s… well, not a very good singer! The show really dives into her strange family and what it takes for her to keep thinking she’s destined for stardom. It’s definitely awkward at times, but there are also moments where you actually feel bad for her, because her dreams just keep getting crushed. It’s a really unique style of comedy, and it’s not for everyone, but those of us who love it really love it. It fully commits to being totally absurd, and I appreciate that.

‘The Neighbors’ (2012–2014)

A seemingly normal family moves into a new housing development, only to find out their neighbors are aliens from the planet Zabvron! These aliens, who all pretend to be famous athletes, try to fit in by observing human behavior – and they all get around in the same golf carts. Despite the funny setup, the show is surprisingly well-written, offering thoughtful looks at family life and relationships. It cleverly uses its science fiction premise to poke fun at everyday social expectations.

‘Diagnosis: Murder’ (1993–2002)

Dick Van Dyke plays Dr. Mark Sloan, a doctor who also helps the police solve crimes. He often works with his detective son, using his medical knowledge and sharp eye for detail to crack difficult murder cases. The show is known for being reliably entertaining, with a comfortable and familiar style, and Dick Van Dyke’s charming performance. Though popular in its time, the show’s smart mysteries aren’t always remembered when discussing great crime dramas.

‘Diff’rent Strokes’ (1978–1986)

This beloved sitcom centers around two brothers from Harlem who are adopted by a rich man after their mother passes away. While famous for Gary Coleman’s memorable catchphrase, the show also bravely addressed important topics like racism, drug use, and kidnapping. It skillfully combined funny, family-friendly moments with episodes meant to teach valuable lessons to young viewers. The strong connection between the actors was a key reason the show stayed popular for so many years.

‘Just Shoot Me!’ (1997–2003)

As a comedy fan, I always enjoyed ‘Just Shoot Me!’. It revolved around the quirky staff at ‘Blush’ magazine, and the cast – especially David Spade and Wendie Malick – were brilliantly sarcastic. A lot of the humor came from the clash between Maya, who actually wanted to do serious journalism, and her coworkers who were, let’s just say, more focused on appearances. The show was super quick-witted, and it really poked fun at the fashion world in a smart way. Honestly, it’s one of those late 90s workplace comedies that still feels fresh and funny today.

‘V’ (2009–2011)

This new take on the classic 1980s series begins with a huge fleet of alien ships appearing over cities around the world, seemingly offering peace. Morena Baccarin plays the captivating leader of these Visitors, who hide a dangerous plan for humanity beneath a friendly exterior. The show dives into topics like how governments and the media can be controlled, and the growth of a group fighting back against the aliens. With its intense storyline and focus on a worldwide conspiracy, it’s a gripping science fiction thriller.

‘Alcatraz’ (2012)

This mystery series, from J.J. Abrams, centers around a detective and an Alcatraz expert who are investigating the baffling return of prisoners who disappeared years ago. Each week, they hunt down a new, dangerous criminal—one who hasn’t aged a day since 1963. While solving these cases, they also uncover the long-held secrets of Alcatraz and what caused the prisoners to vanish in the first place. The show blends classic crime-solving with a larger, intriguing story that keeps audiences hooked.

‘No Ordinary Family’ (2010–2011)

When the Powell family’s plane goes down in the Amazon rainforest, they unexpectedly gain incredible superpowers, like super strength and telepathy. The show centers on their efforts to navigate these newfound abilities while still dealing with everyday family life in the suburbs. Starring Michael Chiklis and Julie Benz, the series follows the parents as they try to keep their children safe and figure out where their powers came from. It’s a unique blend of superhero action and relatable family drama, creating a warm and engaging story.

‘The Event’ (2010–2011)

This thrilling series starts with a search for a missing woman, quickly uncovering a government conspiracy linked to aliens. The story jumps between different time periods and viewpoints, gradually revealing a huge plot that puts the President in danger. It’s built to be a real page-turner, with constant surprises and dramatic twists. The show is known for its large scope and intricate storytelling.

‘Heist’ (2006)

This show follows a team of skilled thieves as they carefully plan to rob three Beverly Hills jewelry stores at the same time. The story explores their preparations, the disagreements within the group, and the detectives trying to catch them. Known for its realistic, movie-like feel and detailed look at the mechanics of a major heist, the series was cancelled after only a few episodes but remains popular for its fast-paced action and compelling acting.

‘Standoff’ (2006–2007)

I just finished watching this new series, and it’s really compelling. It focuses on an FBI couple – both top crisis negotiators – and how their romance both helps and hinders them when they’re dealing with incredibly high-stakes hostage situations all over Los Angeles. What really makes it work is the chemistry between Ron Livingston and Rosemarie DeWitt; they feel so real and believable, which adds a lot to what could have been a pretty standard procedural show. Each episode really dives into the psychology of these conflicts and how they try to resolve them without anyone getting hurt, and it’s fascinating to watch.

‘Flashforward’ (2009–2010)

Inspired by Robert J. Sawyer’s novel, the series starts with a strange event: everyone on Earth simultaneously falls unconscious for just over two minutes. While unconscious, people experience vivid visions of what their lives will be like six months from then. This causes widespread panic and a major FBI investigation. The show centers on the characters as they grapple with these premonitions, trying to make the futures they saw either come true or avoid them altogether. Its ambitious scope and thought-provoking themes about free will and fate made it stand out in the science fiction world.

‘Intelligence’ (2014)

Okay, so I just finished watching this new series, and Josh Holloway is fantastic as a super-spy with a seriously cool upgrade – a microchip in his brain that gives him access to all the information. The premise is that he’s paired with a Secret Service agent to protect him while they tackle these really intense missions for the government. What I found most interesting was how the show plays with the idea of relying on technology versus trusting your gut instinct. It’s a spy show, sure, but it feels very current, with a lot of slick, futuristic tech and a breakneck pace that keeps you hooked. It’s basically a fresh take on the classic spy formula.

‘Grosse Pointe’ (2000–2001)

This funny show, created by Darren Star, gives you a peek behind the curtain of a teen TV drama. It playfully mocks the real-life conflicts and big personalities often found on shows like ‘Beverly Hills, 90210’. The characters navigate issues like actors leaving, network meddling, and the constant need to manage their public personas. Critics loved its clever humor and insightful take on the entertainment world.

‘Possessed’ (2019)

This South Korean thriller centers around a determined detective and a psychic who work together to investigate crimes with a supernatural element. The stakes get higher when they have to stop the vengeful spirit of a serial killer from continuing to cause trouble. The show mixes intense crime scenes with humor and a budding romance between the two main characters. Critics have praised it for being emotionally resonant and successfully combining different genres.

‘Franklin & Bash’ (2011–2014)

This comedy follows two fun-loving, street-smart lawyers hired by a big, established firm to shake things up. Breckin Meyer and Mark-Paul Gosselaar play the leads, a close-knit duo whose playful personalities and love of partying don’t quite fit the firm’s serious environment. The show became known for its funny ‘bro-legal’ style and inventive courtroom tactics, often featuring over-the-top presentations, offering a more lighthearted take on legal dramas.

‘Under the Dome’ (2013–2015)

Based on Stephen King’s novel, the series follows the people of a small town suddenly cut off from the world by an enormous, impenetrable dome. As supplies run low and conflicts erupt, the residents struggle to survive and discover where the dome came from. The show examines how a community falls apart under intense pressure and isolation, and its mix of science fiction, mystery, and compelling characters kept audiences watching for multiple seasons.

‘Revolution’ (2012–2014)

After a worldwide catastrophe knocked out all electricity fifteen years ago, society has collapsed and reverted to a time before modern technology, now controlled by local warlords. The series centers on a young woman’s perilous journey to save her brother and uncover a solution to bring power back to the world. Expect intense sword fights and thrilling survival sequences, all set within the ruins of reclaimed cities. The show explores the complex struggles for control and the sacrifices required to rebuild a fallen civilization.

‘Terra Nova’ (2011)

Earth is becoming uninhabitable due to pollution, so one family is chosen for an extraordinary mission: traveling back to the time of dinosaurs to establish a new settlement. They face the dangers of prehistoric life, including attacks from dinosaurs, and conflict with a group of humans who have their own plans for this new world. This visually stunning series, with Steven Spielberg as an executive producer, blends heartwarming family stories with epic science fiction and incredible special effects.

‘Falling Skies’ (2011–2015)

After a massive alien attack nearly destroys humankind, a former history professor takes charge of a small band of survivors called the 2nd Massachusetts. The show follows their fight against the technologically advanced aliens, focusing on clever, unconventional warfare. It’s a story about how people come together and the importance of family when facing impossible odds. Over five seasons, the series grew from a simple story of survival into a large-scale war spanning the galaxy.

‘The 100’ (2014–2020)

Almost a century after a nuclear disaster, a group of one hundred young criminals are sent from a space station to Earth to check if it’s safe to live on. They quickly realize they aren’t the only ones there, and have to deal with dangerous conflicts between groups and difficult choices to stay alive. The show is famous for unexpectedly killing off important characters and its realistic, often harsh, portrayal of power and leadership. Over time, it evolved from a simple story about surviving into a much larger and more intricate science fiction story.

‘Z Nation’ (2014–2018)

Following a nationwide zombie outbreak, a group of ordinary people embarks on a cross-country mission: getting a person who’s been bitten by a zombie from New York to California. The show is known for being fun, fast-paced, and inventive with its zombie concepts – think zombie tornadoes and plant-zombie combinations! Though it’s often funny, it also features genuinely touching stories about its characters. It offered a more upbeat and action-packed experience compared to other serious zombie shows.

‘Insatiable’ (2018–2019)

This darkly comedic show follows a teenager who was once bullied. She reinvents herself and enters the cutthroat world of beauty pageants, determined to get revenge on those who hurt her. With the help of a washed-up lawyer turned pageant coach, she navigates a world full of intense competition and hidden scandals. The show is known for its outrageous storylines, exaggerated characters, and willingness to push boundaries, which has earned it a devoted fanbase.

‘Disjointed’ (2017–2018)

Kathy Bates plays the owner of a Los Angeles dispensary where medical marijuana is legal, and she helps her patients explore its benefits. The show, filmed in a traditional multi-camera sitcom style, follows a varied group of employees and customers. It often uses colorful animated sequences to show what the products feel like. With a humorous approach, the series tackles important topics like fighting for change, starting a business, and dealing with the effects of trauma. The show’s combination of classic sitcom jokes and current issues made it stand out.

‘The Ranch’ (2016–2020)

This series, set on a Colorado ranch, centers around a former football player who comes home to help his father and brother with the family’s cattle business. Starring Ashton Kutcher and Sam Elliott, the show blends familiar sitcom elements with realistic and emotionally powerful stories about life in rural America. It’s unique for using a traditional multicamera setup to explore tough topics like money troubles and addiction, and it particularly connects with viewers who rarely see their lives reflected on television. The show focuses on the everyday struggles and bonds of a working-class family.

‘Fuller House’ (2016–2020)

‘Fuller House’ is a follow-up to the popular 90s show ‘Full House.’ It centers on D.J. Tanner-Fuller, a mother raising three sons with the support of her sister and best friend. The show frequently brings back familiar faces from the original series, tapping into viewers’ nostalgia, while also introducing new characters. It keeps the heartwarming feel and focus on family that made ‘Full House’ so beloved, but with a more contemporary sense of humor. The series was very successful for its streaming service, demonstrating the enduring popularity of the Tanner family.

‘Marvel’s Iron Fist’ (2017–2018)

After disappearing for fifteen years, Danny Rand comes back to New York City to take back his family’s business and embrace his fate as the Iron Fist, a hero with extraordinary powers. The show centers on his efforts to manage the company while secretly battling a dangerous criminal group. Although the first season received a varied response, the second season was highly regarded for its better fight scenes and more compelling characters. It presented a realistic take on the magical elements within the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

‘Supergirl’ (2015–2021)

Kara Danvers, Superman’s cousin, steps into her own as a superhero, becoming the hero she was destined to be. The show follows her life in National City, where she balances a job at a media company with secret work alongside a government agency to defend Earth. It’s known for being hopeful and for its powerful messages about women and fairness. Featuring famous DC characters and big team-up events, the series became a major part of the superhero TV landscape.

‘DC’s Legends of Tomorrow’ (2016–2022)

A mismatched team of heroes and villains is brought together by a time traveler who’s gone off course. Their mission: fix mistakes in the past to protect the future. What started as a dramatic series quickly became a hilarious and unpredictable comedy, leaning into its own strangeness. The team, called the Legends, constantly faces ridiculous challenges – from battling oversized stuffed animals to appearing on reality TV. Its quirky style and self-deprecating humor have earned it a dedicated fanbase.

‘Scream: The TV Series’ (2015–2019)

Inspired by the famous movie series, this show centers on a group of teenagers in Lakewood who are terrorized by a masked killer connected to the town’s troubling history. Like the films, it playfully comments on common horror movie clichés and the slasher genre itself. Each season presents a new mystery filled with deaths and misleading clues, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats. Later seasons revamped the show with a new format, allowing for a fresh take on the slasher story.

‘Chilling Adventures of Sabrina’ (2018–2020)

As a movie and TV lover, I was really drawn to this take on the ‘Sabrina the Teenage Witch’ story. It’s much darker and more serious than the original! It follows Sabrina as she tries to balance being a normal teenager with her witch side. The show is set in this creepy, atmospheric town called Greendale, and it dives deep into horror and witchcraft. It’s got a really cool, gothic look and feel, but it’s also about growing up and figuring things out – just with a supernatural twist. What I loved most is that it wasn’t afraid to be completely different from the lighthearted comedy most people remember. It really created its own unique and captivating vibe.

‘Locke & Key’ (2020–2022)

When three siblings lose their father, they inherit their family’s old house and uncover a set of magical keys. These keys give each of them unique and powerful abilities. However, they quickly learn that a dangerous demon is also hunting for the keys, with sinister plans of its own. Inspired by a popular comic book, the show combines family struggles with fantasy and horror, using the keys’ powers to explore themes of loss and remembrance.

‘Avenue 5’ (2020–2022)

This funny sci-fi show, created by Armando Iannucci, centers on a luxury space cruise that goes terribly wrong when it’s thrown off course, stretching a short vacation into an eight-year ordeal. The series follows the ship’s hapless crew and spoiled passengers as they struggle with constant malfunctions and growing social chaos. Hugh Laurie plays the ship’s captain, who’s secretly not as qualified as he seems. With its biting wit and sharp commentary on corporate failings, the show offers a darkly humorous take on what space travel might actually be like.

‘Space Force’ (2020–2022)

Steve Carell plays a four-star general in charge of the newest branch of the U.S. military. The show centers on the difficulties of building a military base on the moon, navigating red tape, and dealing with competition from other countries. It’s a funny and critical look at today’s military and political leaders, combined with Carell’s heartwarming comedic style. The show also features a supporting cast of scientists and soldiers who bring the secret moon base to life as a unique workplace.

‘Extant’ (2014–2015)

Halle Berry stars as an astronaut who comes back to Earth after spending over a year alone in space, only to find out she’s pregnant – and no one can explain how. The show centers around the mystery of her pregnancy and how it connects to a larger, worldwide secret involving artificial intelligence and the possibility of alien life. It’s visually impressive and dives into the moral questions raised by powerful new technologies. The story unfolds slowly, focusing on thought-provoking ideas about what it means to be human.

‘Helix’ (2014–2015)

When a possible disease breaks out in a remote, high-tech Arctic research station, a team from the CDC is sent to investigate. They quickly become trapped in a desperate fight for survival against a strange and fast-changing virus. The show is thrilling and unsettling, filled with shocking twists, gruesome visuals, and a growing sense of fear as the scientists uncover the dark secrets of the facility’s research.

‘Wayward Pines’ (2015–2016)

This thriller series, produced by M. Night Shyamalan, follows a Secret Service agent sent to a beautiful town in Idaho to find two missing colleagues. He quickly learns the town is enclosed by an electric fence and that residents aren’t allowed to leave. A significant plot twist halfway through the season dramatically alters how viewers see the story. The show’s unsettling mood and unique mystery made it a compelling watch.

‘Limitless’ (2015–2016)

Picking up where the 2011 movie left off, the series centers on Brian Finch, who gains incredible intelligence from the drug NZT-48 and is then forced to work with the FBI. However, the show is much more playful and inventive than the film, using lots of visual humor and trying out different ways to tell stories. The strong connection between the main actors, combined with the show’s clever portrayal of Brian’s enhanced abilities, made it stand out from typical crime shows. It successfully created a detailed and interesting world while still keeping things light and entertaining.

‘Battle Creek’ (2015)

Created by David Shore and Vince Gilligan, Battle Creek centers around two very different detectives: a seasoned, world-weary local investigator and an upbeat, by-the-book FBI agent. Set in Battle Creek, Michigan, the show highlights the clashes in their approaches as they investigate crimes in a city that’s short on funding. Known for its clever writing and focus on the people involved, the series emphasizes the human side of police work rather than dramatic action. The strong on-screen connection between stars Josh Duhamel and Dean Winters was key to the show’s appeal.

‘The Grinder’ (2015–2016)

Rob Lowe plays a TV actor who, after his popular legal show finishes, decides he can practice law at his family’s firm. The comedy playfully pokes fun at typical legal dramas while also focusing on the actor’s complicated relationship with his brother, who is a real lawyer. Critics loved the show’s smart writing and its ability to make fun of itself. It often used clips from the fictional show within the show to emphasize how ridiculous the main character’s beliefs are.

‘Grandfathered’ (2015–2016)

John Stamos stars as a wealthy and carefree bachelor who owns a restaurant. His life is turned upside down when he unexpectedly learns he has a son and a granddaughter. The show follows his journey as he adjusts from being a self-centered playboy to a loving father and grandfather. It’s a funny and touching series that highlights the ups and downs of becoming a family, and Stamos’s personality really makes it shine among other comedies.

‘My Lady Jane’ (2024)

This fantasy series offers a new take on the story of Lady Jane Grey, the queen who reigned for only nine days. It imagines her life in a world of shapeshifters, giving her a chance to avoid her tragic end. Known for its clever, contemporary-sounding conversations and willingness to bend the truth of history, the show is a fast-paced, exciting adventure filled with romance, political scheming, and supernatural twists. It presents a fresh, feminist view of the Tudor period.

2026-01-29 19:28