Three Clouds Over Constellation and a Glimmer of Hope

by

Constellation Brands (STZ), that jolly purveyor of mirth in bottles, once stood as steadfast as a butler at a garden party. Yet its shares have taken a tumble, sliding 30% while the S&P 500 waltzed upward 17%. Let us examine the three pesky rainclouds hovering above its picnic, and the solitary sunbeam that might yet rescue the day.

The First Cloud: The Youthful Teetotal Tempest

Constellation’s crown jewels-Corona, Modelo, and Pacifico-arrive via Mexico but find thirsty patrons almost entirely in the U.S. Alas, Gallup’s 2024 poll reveals a shocking trend: young Americans’ thirst for ambrosia has waned from 72% to 59% in two decades. NielsenIQ adds that 45% of Gen Z adults abstain entirely! One might as well sell ice to a penguin colony.

This tempest stirs visions of Altria’s (MO) woes-cost-cutting, price hikes, and share buybacks to prop up EPS like a tipsy gent at a polo match. Constellation’s counter? Hard seltzers and non-alcoholic brews, a dash of modernity served with a wink. Yet whether these quench Gen Z’s indifference remains as uncertain as a debutante’s first waltz.

Loading widget...

The Second Cloud: The Hispano Spending Snag

Hispanic consumers, comprising half Constellation’s beer sales, now tighten purse strings amid immigration kerfuffles and Trump’s tariff tantrums. CEO Bill Newlands frets they’re spending less on frivolities-a double whammy, given beer’s brisk growth outpaces stodgy wine and spirits divisions. The fiscal 2026 forecast? Sales flatter than a pancake at a cricket match.

The Third Cloud: Trump’s Tariff Tsunami

Those mischievous tariffs on Mexican aluminum cans-raised to 50%!-threaten margins like a rogue hedgehog at a croquet game. Though Constellation might bottle more brews, 39% of shipments cling stubbornly to cans. EPS could shrink 6-9%, leaving shares at $176 seeming a trifle forlorn-a mere 14x forecast earnings. But if profits keep shrinking, even that price might prove too dear, like a bespoke suit with holes in the pockets.

The Sunbeam: Strategic Slimming à la Jeeves

Yet hope flickers! Constellation’s culling of lesser wine and spirit brands-Svedka Vodka’s December exit chief among them-smacks of Bertie Wooster’s rare moments of fiscal wisdom. This “premiumization” strategy, swapping dime-store plonk for top-shelf nectar, courts affluent sippers and juicier margins. It’s the sort of pruning that’d make a City banker blush with delight, even as he tut-tuts over near-term doldrums.

But Don’t Book the Champagne Tower Just Yet

Constellation’s not exactly sinking, but recommending its shares feels akin to betting on a horse with a sprained ankle. Until tariffs lift, youth embrace their inner Bacchus, and Hispanic wallets replenish, patience is the watchword. For now, one might prefer steadier blue chips-stocks that don’t require a crystal ball and a prayer to St. Vincent de Paul. 🍷

Read More

2025-08-31 13:01