The Weight of Value: A Costco Meditation

by

I confess, a certain admiration grips me when I consider Costco Wholesale. A temple of consumption, perhaps, but one built on the curious foundation of offering…value. Not mere cheapness, mind you, but a calculated offering, a bargain struck with the modern soul. The annual membership, a paltry sum in the grand scheme, unlocks a universe of goods, a promise of…sufficiency. It has even, remarkably, navigated the treacherous currents of international commerce with a degree of grace that eludes its brethren, those lumbering giants like Walmart and Home Depot, lost in translation and cultural missteps.

Yet, despite this…success, this almost unsettling competence, I find myself unable to partake. Not from disapproval, but from a…hesitation. A moral accounting, if you will. The stock itself, you see, represents not merely a share in a business, but a participation in a…dream. And dreams, as we all know, come at a price.

The Valuation: A Spectre Haunting the Portfolio

The matter, distilled to its essence, is this: valuation. A cold, hard number that speaks volumes about the collective psyche. As of this moment, Costco trades at a multiple of earnings that…disturbs. Fifty-four times earnings! It is a figure that demands contemplation, a silent accusation leveled at the eager investor. Compare it to Walmart, at a comparatively modest forty-five, or even Amazon, at twenty-eight. One might dismiss such metrics for a company in furious growth, a rocket ship ascending to the heavens. But Costco…is not that. It is a steady ship, a reliable vessel, but not one charting a course for the stars.

Loading widget...

The recent quarter, while respectable – revenue up eight percent, net income eleven – offers no salvation. It is growth, certainly, but…measured. A comfortable progression, not a surge. It is enough to sustain, to endure, but not to justify such a premium. The market, it seems, has already priced in the next decade of stability, leaving little room for surprise, for genuine reward. One feels a certain…pity for the latecomer, the investor drawn in by the siren song of consistency, only to find the feast already consumed.

And there is a further torment: the unlikelihood of a correction. Costco has cultivated a reputation for competence, for unwavering execution. It avoids the blunders that plague its competitors, the missteps that offer opportunities for the discerning investor. This is not necessarily a virtue, mind you. It creates a fortress, impenetrable to reason, resistant to the natural cycles of the market. A downturn might arrive, of course, a broad market sell-off sweeping all before it. But even then, Costco would likely emerge…scathed, but not broken. And other, more deserving investments would fall alongside it, obscuring the true bargains.

One could wait, of course. Wait for a moment of weakness, a flicker of vulnerability. But the history suggests a long vigil. The P/E ratio has not dipped below thirty since 2019, and before that, not below twenty since 2010. It is a stock that demands patience, an almost monastic dedication. And in the meantime, other opportunities will arise, other companies will offer a more equitable exchange.

A Reluctant Exclusion

Thus, Costco remains…off my list. A high-quality company, undeniably, but one priced as if it were a revelation. It is the most successful of its brick-and-mortar peers, particularly when one considers its international performance. But that success is already…reflected in the price. It is a paradox, a cruel irony: the very qualities that make Costco desirable also make it…unattainable.

Let those who have already embarked upon this path continue, of course. Let them savor the fruits of their long-term investment. But for those of us seeking a fairer valuation, a more reasonable exchange, there are other avenues to explore. Other companies, less celebrated, perhaps, but offering a greater potential for reward. The market, after all, is a vast and unpredictable landscape. And sometimes, the greatest treasures are hidden not in plain sight, but in the shadows.

Read More

2026-02-22 12:32