The Two Vladimirs: A Contrarian’s Guide to Chasing Growth

by

In the grand theater of finance, where the devil himself might sip tea with a tech CEO, two Vladimirs-VOOG and VUG-stand before the curtain. They are both growth-obsessed acolytes of Vanguard, yet their dispositions differ like a sonnet and a bureaucratic edict. The first charges a steep toll to enter a narrower theater, while the second coaxes cheap admission into a broader one. But let us not be swayed by the superficial costumes of fees and yields. The true drama lies elsewhere: in the bloodless pulse of beta, the hollow victories of diversification, and whether the stock market’s mistress, Technology, truly demands her tribute-or merely toys with us.

Metric Desecration

Chalice VOOG VUG
Issuer Vanguard Vanguard
Expense Ratio 0.07% 0.04%
1-yr Return (12/9/2025) 19.28% 16.47%
Dividend Yield 0.48% 0.42%
AUM $21.7 billion $353.0 billion
Beta (5Y) 1.10 1.23

VUG’s cheaper admission-0.04%-is a seduction for the ascetic. Yet its one-year returns, like a dinner invitation from a minor prince, feel paltry compared to VOOG’s slightly gaudier feast. But what is value in a world where a 0.03% edge on fees feels noble, while a dern penny less in yield begets scorn? The market, that fickle court jester, offers no clear verdict.

Performance & the Metaphysical Maelstrom

Oracle VOOG VUG
Max Drawdown (5Y) -32.74% -35.61%
Growth of $1,000 (5Y) $1,979 $1,984

VOOG’s sails, though torn (a 32.74% loss), have fared better in the storm than VUG’s, which buckled like parchment in a hothouse. Yet both arrived at nearly identical destinations. A trite observation, perhaps, but when five years vanish into a puddle of $5 difference, one wonders: is this a triumph of strategy, or proof that the gods of finance are laughing at our tally sticks?

Anatomy of a Beast

VUG is a leviathan-53% of its body consumed by Technology, a sector with the temperament of Prometheus. Its top holdings, Nvidia, Apple, and Microsoft, are giants but also captives of the same algorithmic storm. VOOG, meanwhile, spreads its 217 holdings like a priest scattering ashes, allocating technology a slimmer 44%. The difference is not merely in numbers but in spirit: one is a court painter, the other a renegade who dares to dilute the emperor’s portrait.

But let not the 44% of VOOG fool you. The stock market’s ‘growth’ criteria are as phony as a flirting schemes in Minsk. Both funds are populated by the same elite, dressed in different robes. The emperor has no clothes. But oh, what a costly illusion!

For more guidance on ETF investing, check out the full guide at this link.

What This Means for the Contrarian

To follow VUG is to join the mob that chants for more Tech-for now. Its higher beta and steeper drawdowns are the badge of a reckless courtesan, dancing with the fates. VOOG, in contrast, offers a slightly narrower path, its fortress walls built upon the S&P 500’s back. But both are but instruments in the hands of a system that rewards the bold and bookmarks the cautious for nostalgia.

Advertisement

And what of the investor? They must ask themselves: do they wish to play Loki, fooling the gods with a stock’s whims, or do they crave the comfort of a narrow, more expensive alleyway? The devil himself might not know. But one truth remains: when the market’s pendulum swings, all roads end at zero, and the only difference worth noting is the joy in the ride-or the horror in the fall.

Glossary of Sorcery

Expense Ratio: The silent tax levied by the fund’s court scribes to balance the books.
AUM: The sum of all fears and hopes, tied up in a haversack.
ETF: A conjured beast that eats and divides your coins.
Index: A phantom king who claims no crown but demands obedience.
Sector Tilt: The weight of a nation’s labor, slung unevenly across a few shoulders.
Dividend Yield: The golden beggar’s promise: “Your crumbs are real.”
Beta: A mirror held up to chaos, reflecting the market’s fickle gaze.
Total Return: The alchemist’s lie: lead turned to gold, but only if you credit the potion’s foam.
Max Drawdown: The abyss that stares back when the market’s clock ticks too loudly.
Growth Stock: A unicorn in a chart, promised to run faster than wind but tethered to the moon.
Holdings: The bones of companies, rearranged like letters in a spell.

Read More

2025-12-10 04:57