The Labyrinth of Valuation: A Nabokovian Lens on the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF

by

Exchange-traded funds, or ETFs-those peculiar financial chimeras that blend the liquidity of stocks with the diversification of mutual funds-offer a beguilingly simple path to market exposure. Among them, the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO), with its $1.5 trillion in assets, reigns supreme, overshadowing even its illustrious rivals, the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF and the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust. It is, one might say, the monarch butterfly of index funds, fluttering gaily atop the flower of American capitalism.

And yet, dear reader, here we find ourselves at an all-time high-a phrase that trips off the tongue like a champagne cork popping in slow motion. The Vanguard S&P 500 ETF has ascended 8.5% year-to-date and a dizzying 66.4% since the start of 2023. But earnings? Ah, those plodding tortoises of corporate performance, they have not kept pace, leaving valuations stretched thin as the silk threads of a spider’s web under moonlight. Is this ascent, then, a bubble waiting to burst, or merely the natural evolution of markets?

Let us delve into the matter with the precision of a lepidopterist dissecting a rare specimen, for beneath the surface lies a curious interplay of numbers, narratives, and perhaps a touch of folly.

The Kaleidoscope of Valuation

To measure the S&P 500’s valuation is akin to attempting to capture the essence of a sunset with a net made of shadows. One crude yet serviceable method involves comparing price appreciation to changes in operating earnings per share (EPS). Operating earnings, you see, are the unadorned truth of a company’s performance, stripped of the frippery of one-time charges or gains-an austere beauty, if you will.

Consider the table below, where the S&P 500 pirouettes across time intervals, its levels rising faster than its operating EPS:

S&P 500 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years 20 Years
Level 10.7% 77.9% 89.7% 232.3% 382.4%
Operating EPS 3.5% 21.6% 61.5% 140.6% 268.3%

Aha! The discrepancy between price and earnings becomes glaringly apparent, like a misplaced comma in a sonnet. The businesses composing the S&P 500 appear relatively expensive-a banquet priced beyond the means of its ingredients.

But wait, there is another lens through which to view this enigma: forward earnings projections. The forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio divides today’s price by analyst consensus estimates for future earnings. As of August 1, FactSet informs us that the S&P 500’s forward P/E stands at 22.2, a princely sum compared to its five-year average of 19.9 and ten-year average of 18.5. Surely, this suggests overvaluation? Not so fast, my skeptical friend. For just as civilizations advance, so too do companies refine their operations, becoming sleeker, sharper, more efficient beasts.

In Defense of Expanding Horizons

The internet, that great leveller of hierarchies, has transformed commerce into a symphony of efficiency. Consider the humble email, which dispatches messages across continents in milliseconds-a feat once reserved for carrier pigeons and impatient telegrams. Or reflect upon the smartphone, that Swiss Army knife of modernity, consolidating countless devices into a single pocket-sized oracle.

And lo, artificial intelligence beckons on the horizon, promising to amplify productivity as never before. Companies, ever eager to embrace innovation, shall reap the rewards, their valuations swelling like sails caught in a favorable breeze. Growth-focused firms, reinvesting profits rather than doling out dividends, deserve higher valuations, for their seeds may bloom into mighty oaks.

The Pendulum Swings Both Ways

To declare the S&P 500 overvalued without considering these nuances would be as foolish as mistaking a mirage for an oasis. Yet, neither should one ignore the perils of a growth-oriented market. Tech-heavy indexes are prone to volatility, their moods as mercurial as April showers. A downturn in tech investment could send ripples-or waves-through the index.

All told, the S&P 500 merits a loftier valuation than history might suggest, rendering its tracking ETFs less expensive than they appear. But tread carefully, gentle investor, for sharp swings lie ahead, as inevitable as the turning of seasons. 🦋

Read More

2025-08-14 23:00