The Amusing Arithmetic of American Express: A Financial Farce?

American Express, that venerable purveyor of platinum privileges and charge-account pomposity, has long held court in the credit-card realm, its brand as polished as a Louis XIV sunbeam. With a closed-loop system that binds cardholders in a web of mutual dependence, it plays the role of both host and guest at its own feast. And who could forget Berkshire Hathaway, that elephant in the room, owning 21.8% of its shares with the nonchalance of a nobleman tipping his hat to a servant?

Yet lo! The question arises: Might a humble $10,000 stake in this establishment swell to $50,000 by 2030? Let us don our powdered wigs and dissect this financial farce, scene by scene.

Act I: The Illusion of Exponential Growth

To imagine American Express shares quintupling in five years is to dream of a harvest reaped in a single season. Such a feat would demand a 38% annualized return, a crescendo of profit that would leave the S&P 500 gasping in its velvet-lined wake. But let us temper our fantasies, dear readers. In the past quinquennium, this venerable house has yielded a modest 237% total return-a sum respectable, yet far from the 400% mirage.

Why? Because Amex, for all its finery, is no spring chicken. Its earnings per share, like a courtier in its prime, may strut forward at a “mid-teens” pace, but it lacks the vigor of youth. To demand more is to ask a marquise of advanced years to perform the can-can.

Loading widget...

Act II: The Temptation of Time

Yet hope persists, like a jester clinging to the coattails of a king. If five years prove too brief a stage for Amex’s grandeur, let us extend the curtain to 15 or 20. A 400% return over such a span? Why, it might yet happen-though the odds are as certain as a playwright’s need for a deus ex machina.

But mark this: The stock’s price-to-earnings ratio, a bloated 21.6, hangs over the investor like a guillotine. To purchase Amex at such a price is to don a costume too rich for its own sake, risking both purse and pride. One must ask: Is this a crown jewel or a gilded bauble?

And yet, let us not dismiss the enterprise outright. American Express, for all its flaws, remains a master of its domain. Its brand, its network, its Buffett-backed pedigree-these are not trifles. It deserves a place on the watch list, if only as a cautionary tale for those who mistake patience for prudence. 🎭

Read More

2025-08-24 17:07