Superman’s Rotten Tomatoes Score Blasts Past Expectations—Shocks Even the Harshest Critics

Now, the review restrictions have been removed, revealing the Rotten Tomatoes score for the latest interpretation of Superman by James Gunn.

Initially, the early leaked feedback and initial responses showed a split opinion, but surprisingly, the Rotten Tomatoes rating is exceptionally high at the moment.

What is the Superman Rotten Tomatoes Score?

In the initial 55 reviews, the Rotten Tomatoes rating for Superman stands at an impressive 91%. The audience score will be revealed over the weekend. Additionally, today marks the start of early screenings on Amazon, so we’ll soon hear fan reactions throughout the evening. Feel free to explore the reviews below for more insights.

Rotten Tomatoes Scores Compared

Here’s how Gunn’s Superman stacks up against the other Superman movies:

Superman 1978: 86% critic score / 86% fan score
Superman II: 88% / 76%
Superman III: 32% / 23%
Superman IV: 14% / 16%
Superman Returns: 73% / 60%
Man of Steel: 57% / 75%
Batman vs Superman: 28% / 63%

And Gunn’s Marvel movies:

Guardians of the Galaxy: 92% / 92%
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2: 85% / 87%
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 3: 82% / 94%

What do the reviews say?

The negative

Critics who didn’t enjoy Superman often highlight its inconsistent mood and crowded plot as issues, even going so far as to liken it to a jumbled mess. Some argue that the film leans too heavily towards parody rather than a genuine reboot, undercutting serious emotional scenes with inappropriate humor. Furthermore, they contend that the characters of Superman and Lois Lane lack depth, suggesting that the movie places more emphasis on visual flair and grandeur instead of developing its characters. Despite moments of potential brilliance, these critics believe the film ultimately falls short, leaving Superman’s narrative feeling scattered and unfocused.

As a film enthusiast, I find myself consistently annoyed by the fact that Superman’s genuine nature often undermines its dramatic and emotional scenes with humor. While it isn’t as dire as the last Thor movie, there are times when it seems like they don’t fully grasp the gravity of their own story’s consequences.

Superman is quite chaotic yet vibrant. Some might argue it’s a disappointing superhero film, while others may see it as a decent satire – the choice is yours.”

Or, more colloquially:
“Superman’s a bit of a mess, but it’s a colorful one. It could be a lackluster superhero movie or an amusing parody, you decide!

This portrayal of Superman seems overly humorous, campy, and almost caricature-like. It appears to veer towards satire rather than delivering a strong, fresh take on the character.

The Positive

Praise for the movie “Superman” abounds due to its uplifting atmosphere and innovative perspective, with critics lauding James Gunn for reintroducing optimism and sentimentality to the character. The film is commended for staying true to its comic book origins, providing a lively and eccentric, yet sincere, superhero adventure that sets it apart from more recent gritty adaptations. David Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman is hailed as a fitting heir to Christopher Reeve, with the film boasting energetic action, humor, and emotional nuance. Although some critics find it overly packed, many acknowledge it as an enjoyable, bold beginning for Gunn’s new DC Universe.

Superman’s film stands out as an impressive solo production and a compelling introduction to its series. While some die-hard fans may still hope for the return of the Snyderverse, most will appreciate this new interpretation of the legendary character.

James Gunn’s version of SUPERMAN is a remarkable and healing creation, respectfully building upon previous interpretations in comics and films while blazing its own trail. Full of life, color, emotion, and wit, this film truly takes flight.

Superman represents a groundbreaking superhero film that sets an impressive tone for the DC Universe. Director James Gunn infuses this Superman movie with sincerity, modesty, and optimism, delivering a cinematic experience I’ve long anticipated. The future of DC cinema appears promising.

As a passionate film enthusiast, I find this movie strikes a chord with our contemporary society while still holding onto the enduring charm of the Superman emblem. It’s a timeless tale that delves into themes of purpose, emotion, and a hero who serves as an inspiration.

A thrilling comic book experience! The most authentic live-action portrayal yet of the renowned character and his universe. Gunn offers a refreshingly optimistic modern take on Superman inspired by the comics. It’s packed with warmth, charm, zaniness, and magic.” – CineXpress

Release info

On Tuesday, the screenings of James Gunn’s Superman begin on Amazon. Global theater showings commence on July 9th, with a wider release in theaters happening on July 11th.

The movie features David Corenswet playing both Superman and Clark Kent, with Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane and Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor in the leading roles. The rest of the cast includes Edi Gathegi, Anthony Carrigan, Nathan Fillion, Isabela Merced, Skyler Gisondo, Sara Sampaio, María Gabriela de Faría, Wendell Pierce, Alan Tudyk, Pruitt Taylor Vince, and Neva Howell in supporting roles.

2025-07-08 22:32