Some Fans Think that ‘Deadpool & Wolverine’ Is Just a Copy of ‘She-Hulk’: “Everything Deadpool & Wolverine Did, She-Hulk Did Better!”

by

As a seasoned Marvel fan who has witnessed the rise and fall of countless superheroes, I must say that Richard Fink’s perspective on Deadpool & Wolverine vs She-Hulk is as intriguing as it is controversial. It’s not every day we get to see such a fresh take on our beloved movies.

At last, the highly anticipated film featuring Deadpool and Wolverine, starring Ryan Reynolds as Deadpool and Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, has arrived, and it’s receiving rave reviews! Fans have been eagerly waiting to witness these legendary characters together, and their wish has finally come true on the big screen. It’s about time!

As a die-hard fan, I must express that this Marvel movie is truly soaring in popularity. Theaters are packed, ticket sales are pouring in, and it’s no secret that Deadpool and Wolverine have become one of the most acclaimed films in the Marvel universe. However, as always, there are diverse opinions, some of which may not sit well with the majority. And now, I want to present a less conventional viewpoint regarding this film.

As a passionate fan, I’d like to draw your attention to an intriguing perspective shared by my fellow MovieWeb colleague, Richard Fink. In his compelling opinion piece, he posits that if Deadpool and Wolverine were to follow the blueprint of She-Hulk, they would surpass their existing feats. Essentially, Richard invites us to imagine a reimagined movie universe where Deadpool and Wolverine employ the same tactics as She-Hulk, but with even more flair! To fully grasp his argument, I encourage you to dive into the captivating article that he has so thoughtfully crafted.

The central argument put forth in the linked article is that the Deadpool & Wolverine series isn’t particularly innovative, instead drawing heavily from the same template as She-Hulk. Moreover, it suggests that She-Hulk excelled in this particular area.

“The team-up of Deadpool and Wolverine seems to cover familiar territory, and much of the positive feedback appears to overlook that the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) previously tackled a similar tone and style, albeit more effectively. In fact, this was evident in ‘She-Hulk: Attorney at Law’, which aired in 2022, despite receiving mixed reviews from critics and viewers. Ironically, She-Hulk, both the character and the series, faced many of the same criticisms that Deadpool and Wolverine are currently receiving, yet garnered praise from some high-profile fans. Is it just a matter of Deadpool and Wolverine doing it slightly better, or is there something else going on in this comparison?”

According to Fink’s assessment, Deadpool and She-Hulk performed identical actions in the show. However, while Deadpool received applause, She-Hulk faced criticism, creating a divide among fans.

The way She-Hulk’s talent to shatter the boundary between audience and characters, notably in the series finale where she alters the ending, has been criticized as disrupting the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) and being illogical. This criticism sparked disagreement among fans. Interestingly, this doesn’t seem to be a concern when it comes to Deadpool breaking the fourth wall within the MCU. Similarly, Deadpool’s disregard for the fourth wall in the Fox X-Men universe didn’t cause controversy; instead, the film and character were celebrated for their ability to bend the reality of those films.

Regarding their sexual orientation, it’s consistent that they’re both outspoken. However, Deadpool maintains a humorous, quirky demeanor, while She-Hulk has faced ridicule and shame. This apparent disparity suggests a clear double standard.

As a passionate fan, I’ve noticed that both Deadpool and She-Hulk share an openness about their sexuality in the Marvel Universe. Deadpool, with his charming, flirtatious nature, doesn’t shy away from expressing his feelings towards characters like Wolverine and others. On the other hand, She-Hulk: Attorney at Law portrays Jennifer Walters, who navigates the complexities of dating in the series. Unfortunately, a small group has criticized her relationships, resorting to slut-shaming. Interestingly, the show seems to address this issue head-on by making these critics the antagonists, while Deadpool continues to be celebrated as an eccentric, humorous hero. It’s hard not to feel that Deadpool receives more leniency compared to She-Hulk in terms of character portrayal.

In the show “She-Hulk: Attorney at Law,” she satirized the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) format and offered a fresh twist on endings, whereas Deadpool & Wolverine merely commented on MCU conventions and seemed to believe that doing so justified their continued use of familiar tropes. However, She-Hulk’s humor was not highly regarded, while Deadpool is widely considered a comic genius.

Eventually, Fink offers insights on the dance sequences in both productions. One of the most debated moments from She-Hulk’s series is its dance scene, which has been met with criticism by viewers, and now serves as a meme symbolizing the show’s flaws. In stark contrast, Deadpool’s dance sequence is widely appreciated and celebrated as a standout moment in the work.

In the end, Fink’s argument suggests that the dance sequences in both ‘She-Hulk’ and ‘Deadpool & Wolverine’ are essentially identical. However, the criticism directed towards ‘She-Hulk’ stems from its focus on a female protagonist, whereas ‘Deadpool & Wolverine’ is commended due to its male lead character.

As a longtime fan of Marvel comics and films, I’ve always appreciated the unique and humorous personalities of characters like Deadpool and Wolverine. Their quirky humor and action-packed fights have kept me entertained for years. But recently, I’ve found myself drawn to She-Hulk: Attorney at Law, a new show that explores the character’s life in a more comedic light.

Read More

2024-08-02 15:20