Palantir: A Valuation in Infinite Regression

by

The matter of Palantir Technologies (PLTR 1.90%) presents itself not as a simple calculation of potential, but as a cartographic problem. One might envision the stock’s recent ascent – a multiplication exceeding twenty-fivefold in the last three years, a more modest but still considerable 130% in the last twelve months – as the charting of an undiscovered continent. Yet, the consensus of Wall Street, a body not unlike a guild of meticulous, if unimaginative, mapmakers, remains cautiously optimistic. Their projections, a mere eleven percent potential upside, suggest a belief that the coastline has already been fully delineated, the interior largely unexplored.

This discrepancy, between the stock’s vertiginous climb and the analysts’ tempered expectations, is not a paradox, but a symptom. A symptom of a valuation – a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 172.4, a price-to-sales ratio approaching 112 – that hangs suspended, a fragile theorem in need of rigorous proof. One is reminded of the Library of Babel, Borges’ imagined universe of infinite books, where the vast majority contain only gibberish, yet within them, the potential for all conceivable truths resides. Palantir, in this analogy, is a single volume, its pages filled with a compelling, yet unverified, narrative.

The Illusion of Solidity

There are those, of course, who dismiss concerns regarding valuation as the anxieties of those unable to perceive the unfolding future. These investors, primarily those operating outside the established cartographic guilds, continue to accumulate shares with a fervor bordering on the theological. Their conviction, a belief in perpetual ascent, suggests a disregard for the laws of gravity, or perhaps, a faith in a higher, unseen force.

Alex Karp, Palantir’s founder and CEO, expresses a similar sentiment. In a missive to shareholders – a text that reads more like a philosophical treatise than a quarterly report – he notes the difficulty outsiders have in appraising the company, “either its significance in shaping our current geopolitics or its value in the vulgar, financial sense.” He posits that Palantir’s success has confounded conventional analysis, a company growing at a rate that defies the established frameworks. This assertion, while audacious, contains a kernel of truth. To understand Palantir, one must acknowledge the possibility that the rules of the game are, in fact, changing.

The Recursive Calculation

But growth, however impressive, is not a self-sustaining enchantment. The past, as always, offers only imperfect clues to the future. To determine whether Palantir’s valuation is justified, we must engage in a form of reverse discounted cash flow analysis – a calculation not unlike attempting to trace a labyrinthine path back to its origin.

Assuming a discount rate of ten percent – a concession to the inherent risk of investing in a high-growth technology company – Palantir would need to sustain a compound annual growth rate of approximately forty percent for the next decade to justify its current market capitalization of roughly $400 billion. Alternatively, if we envision a future price-to-sales ratio of ten – a premium, but not unreasonable, given the company’s potential – Palantir would need to achieve a CAGR of thirty to forty percent over the next six to eight and a half years. These calculations, while imprecise, provide a rough order of magnitude. They suggest that Palantir’s growth must not merely continue, but accelerate, to justify the expectations currently embedded in its stock price.

The Fragility of Trajectories

Unfortunately, sustained high growth is a rare phenomenon. Few companies, if any, can maintain a CAGR of thirty to forty percent over the long term. Palantir, therefore, faces a daunting challenge. Even slight variations in the assumptions used in our calculations could significantly increase the growth rate required to justify its valuation.

One is reminded of a complex clockwork mechanism, each gear meticulously calibrated to ensure the smooth operation of the whole. A single, imperceptible flaw, a minute misalignment, could disrupt the entire system. Palantir, in this analogy, is that clockwork mechanism. Its success depends not only on maintaining its current trajectory but on anticipating and mitigating any unforeseen disruptions. The company, it seems, must not merely grow, but achieve a state of perpetual, frictionless motion – a feat that borders on the impossible.

Loading widget...

Read More

2026-01-22 11:52