RSPS, in its construction, mimics the very fabric of the American consumer market – a seemingly egalitarian distribution of weight amongst the purveyors of daily needs. It is a reflection, perhaps, of a certain democratic ideal – a belief that the aggregate wisdom of the market, when equally distributed, will yield a stable, if not spectacular, return. PBJ, however, operates under a different principle. It is a curated selection, a deliberate choosing of those companies deemed most likely to thrive, guided by a rules-based system that seeks to discern future success from the present conditions. It is a gamble, of sorts, a wager that the architects of this index possess a superior understanding of the forces at play. The question, then, is not simply which performs better, but which embodies a more sustainable and ultimately, more reasonable strategy.