Overrated Crime Movies Everyone Seems To Like

Crime movies frequently reflect the prevailing mood of a culture by highlighting the conflict between order and chaos. Many quickly become classics and define the genre itself. Sometimes, these films receive a lot of attention that doesn’t quite match their storytelling. By looking closely at these popular movies, we can better understand why certain stories stick with audiences for years.

‘The Godfather Part II’ (1974)

The Godfather Part II tells the stories of Vito Corleone in his youth and his son Michael as they both deal with the challenges of being in the Mafia. Many consider it a cinematic achievement because of its broad scope and the way it weaves together two different timelines. While some viewers find it a bit slow-paced, especially given its nearly four-hour length, the film powerfully continues the Corleone family saga and examines themes of treachery and moral compromise.

‘Scarface’ (1983)

Tony Montana’s story follows a Cuban immigrant who creates a powerful drug trafficking business in Miami during the 1980s. The film is well-known for its intense violence and Al Pacino’s iconic acting. While some viewers find it too long and focused on flashy visuals rather than a strong plot, it has gained a dedicated following as a cult classic, celebrated for its depiction of an antihero’s dramatic ascent and downfall.

‘Pulp Fiction’ (1994)

Quentin Tarantino’s film weaves together multiple stories about hitmen and criminals, but not in a traditional order. It had a big impact on independent filmmaking thanks to its distinctive dialogue and use of pop culture. Although many people love it, some find the jumping around in time and long conversations hard to follow. Despite this, the movie is still considered a classic of the crime genre, known for its unique style and unforgettable characters.

‘The Departed’ (2006)

This film follows an undercover detective and a police informant, both working to expose an Irish mob in Boston, as they try to figure out each other’s true identities. Directed by Martin Scorsese, it’s a remake of a well-known Hong Kong movie and was a big hit with audiences. While praised for its energetic acting and suspenseful mood, some critics have noted the story depends a bit too much on chance occurrences and abrupt changes in character behavior. Despite this, the film received numerous awards.

‘American Gangster’ (2007)

The movie follows a detective’s attempt to dismantle the heroin operation run by Frank Lucas, who smuggled drugs into the US during the Vietnam War. Denzel Washington and Russell Crowe deliver powerful performances. While some find the story to be a typical crime biography without groundbreaking new ideas, it offers a slick and detailed portrayal of New York City’s historical criminal scene.

‘Heat’ (1995)

This thrilling movie follows a skilled thief and an experienced detective as they relentlessly pursue each other throughout Los Angeles. It’s famous for being the first time Al Pacino and Robert De Niro appeared together on screen. Critics often praise the movie’s believable robbery scenes and its exploration of the characters’ personal struggles. However, some viewers feel the movie is too long and that the detective’s family issues don’t add much to the central story.

‘Goodfellas’ (1990)

This film follows the life of Henry Hill, from his entry into a powerful criminal organization to his eventual downfall. It’s famous for its quick cuts and use of popular songs to tell the story. While the movie ends with a brutal depiction of gangster life, some viewers feel it glamorizes the criminal world. Nevertheless, it’s considered a highly influential crime film, largely due to its innovative style.

‘Casino’ (1995)

This movie follows a gambling whiz sent to Las Vegas to run a big casino on behalf of the mob. It dives deep into how organized crime controlled the city during its glamorous but corrupt heyday. While it’s a visually striking film with powerful acting, many reviewers have pointed out its resemblance to ‘Goodfellas,’ noting similar themes and actors. It offers a gritty and vibrant look at the darker side of Las Vegas.

‘The Irishman’ (2019)

This movie tells the story of a truck driver who gets involved in organized crime with the Bufalino family and the mysterious disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa. It uses special effects to make the actors appear younger in flashbacks. While compelling, some viewers found the film overly long and the ending felt slow-paced. Ultimately, it’s a dark and thoughtful look at a life of crime and the price someone pays for their decisions.

‘Snatch’ (2000)

A stolen diamond sets off a chase involving several criminal gangs, all operating within the gritty world of underground boxing. The movie is recognizable for its quick cuts and the unusual way some characters speak. While entertaining, some viewers find the jokes and unpredictable story a bit too familiar compared to other films like it. Despite this, it was a breakthrough for director Guy Ritchie, establishing his signature style in British crime movies.

‘The Usual Suspects’ (1995)

This movie follows five criminals who cross paths during a police lineup and team up for a daring robbery, which unexpectedly leads them to a shadowy figure running a criminal empire. It’s well-known for its complex story and a twist ending that’s become legendary. Some critics feel the film depends too much on this surprise, making it less enjoyable when watched again. It received significant accolades for its writing and Kevin Spacey’s performance.

‘Training Day’ (2001)

The movie follows a new police officer on his first day, partnered with a seasoned narcotics officer who’s bending the rules, as they patrol some of the roughest parts of Los Angeles. It’s a gripping look at the characters and how easily the line between being a police officer and a criminal can blur. While many enjoy it, some feel the ending is a bit over the top. Denzel Washington’s powerful performance as the complex veteran officer won him an Academy Award.

‘Reservoir Dogs’ (1992)

Quentin Tarantino’s first film follows a group of criminals struggling to deal with the fallout from a disastrous diamond robbery. Known for its clever and snappy conversations and simple locations, the movie has become a key work in independent cinema and inspired countless filmmakers. However, some viewers feel the film’s intense violence isn’t essential to the plot.

‘The Boondock Saints’ (1999)

After defending themselves against the Russian mafia, two brothers take the law into their own hands, becoming vigilantes. Though it didn’t do well in theaters, the movie developed a large and dedicated fan base thanks to home video. While some critics feel the action and religious elements are unoriginal and lack depth, the film delves into the idea of justice being carried out by people outside the official legal system.

‘The Town’ (2010)

As a movie fan, I really got drawn into this film about a crew of bank robbers from Charlestown. It follows their last big job, but it’s not just about the heist itself – you also see all the drama and tension within the group, and the pressure from the cops closing in. Ben Affleck did a fantastic job directing and starring – he really captured the feel of this specific Boston neighborhood and its criminal underbelly. Honestly, I thought the romantic storyline felt a little unnecessary and pulled me out of the excitement of the robberies. But overall, the action felt incredibly real, and the cast was just phenomenal. It’s a gripping watch!

‘Ocean’s Eleven’ (2001)

This movie follows a captivating criminal who assembles a skilled team to pull off a daring heist, targeting three Las Vegas casinos at the same time. It’s a fresh take on a beloved heist film, boasting a star-studded cast. While some reviewers feel the movie relies too much on the appeal of its actors, it continues to be a favorite among those who enjoy fun, visually appealing heist stories.

‘Baby Driver’ (2017)

The movie centers on a skilled driver who uses music to expertly navigate high-speed escapes, but gets tangled up in a heist gone wrong. It’s particularly praised for seamlessly blending its action with the music. While some viewers feel the characters and story are familiar tropes, the film delivers a distinctive and immersive visual and sound experience that sets it apart from other movies in its genre.

‘Drive’ (2011)

The film centers on a skilled but enigmatic stuntman and getaway driver who gets pulled into a risky scheme to assist his neighbor. It’s visually striking, with a distinctive neon look and a soundtrack heavily influenced by 1980s music. While praised by many critics and known for establishing director Nicolas Winding Refn’s unique style, some viewers find its minimal dialogue and deliberate pace slow or affected.

‘The Untouchables’ (1987)

During Chicago’s Prohibition, a federal agent assembles a team to take down the notorious Al Capone. The film is famous for its striking visuals and unforgettable music by Ennio Morricone. While some argue it prioritizes entertainment over strict historical truth, it remains a compelling tale of good versus evil, showcasing a battle against widespread corruption.

‘Natural Born Killers’ (1994)

The film tells the story of two people with deeply troubled pasts who fall in love and become notorious killers, and how the media turned them into figures of fascination. It uses a visually striking and often unsettling style to critique society’s obsession with violence. While some viewers find it disturbing and pessimistic, the film remains a provocative work that generated significant discussion when it was first released.

‘Se7en’ (1995)

Okay, so I just finished watching this thriller, and wow, it really sticks with you. It follows two detectives on the trail of a truly disturbing serial killer – one who bases his murders on the seven deadly sins. The whole film is incredibly dark and atmospheric, and let me tell you, the ending is a real shocker. Now, it’s not exactly a light watch; some might find the constant bleakness a bit much. But if you’re into intense, psychological thrillers, this is a must-see. It’s consistently ranked among the best in the genre, and for good reason – the story is gripping and will definitely keep you on the edge of your seat.

‘Public Enemies’ (2009)

This film depicts the FBI’s pursuit of famous bank robbers John Dillinger and Baby Face Nelson. Director Michael Mann chose to film it using modern digital video, aiming for a contemporary feel. However, some viewers found this style clashed with the film’s historical setting. Ultimately, it provides a close examination of the final days of America’s outlaw period.

‘Gangster Squad’ (2013)

Set in postwar Los Angeles, the film follows a covert police squad determined to dismantle the operation of a brutal mob boss. While boasting a well-known cast and visually striking action, many critics view it as a superficial take on classic film noir. It prioritizes flashy visuals and violence over compelling characters and a strong story.

‘A Bronx Tale’ (1993)

Set in 1960s Bronx, this film follows a young man caught between the expectations of his dedicated father and the allure of a captivating mob boss. It’s a story about loyalty and the difficult decisions that shape who we become. While based on a popular play and marking Robert De Niro’s first time directing, some viewers feel it leans towards being overly emotional compared to other crime films.

‘Carlito’s Way’ (1993)

The movie follows a former prisoner attempting to rebuild his life and avoid returning to crime, but old ties pull him back in. Al Pacino delivers a compelling performance as a man searching for forgiveness in a harsh world. While some viewers may find the storyline predictable, relying on common crime themes, the film is praised for its gripping action and heartfelt emotional depth.

‘Donnie Brasco’ (1997)

This film tells the true story of an FBI agent who goes undercover and develops a surprising friendship with a small-time mobster, who ends up guiding him. The movie delves into the mental strain of leading a double life. While some reviewers find the movie’s pace slow and lacking the thrills of typical gangster films, the on-screen connection between Johnny Depp and Al Pacino is widely praised.

‘Black Mass’ (2015)

Johnny Depp plays Whitey Bulger, a famous gangster from Boston, in a movie about his unlikely deal with the FBI. The film shows how Bulger grew his criminal power, aided by the protection of law enforcement. While the movie offers a stark and unsettling portrayal of a troubling time in American history, some viewers felt the actor’s makeup was noticeable and took away from the performance.

‘Legend’ (2015)

I was completely blown away by Tom Hardy’s performance as both of the Kray twins! It’s incredible how he portrayed them – they were notorious gangsters in London back in the sixties. The movie really centers on their complicated relationship and how they built their criminal empire. A lot of critics agree his acting is phenomenal, but some feel the story itself doesn’t really go deep enough. It definitely looks like the sixties, and it captures the atmosphere, but I wish it had offered more of an understanding of who the Kray twins really were.

‘L.A. Confidential’ (1997)

I was completely captivated by this film! It follows three detectives – each a very different character – as they try to solve a string of murders in 1950s Los Angeles. It’s a really intricate mystery, and it doesn’t shy away from showing the dark side of things, like corruption in the police and city hall. Honestly, it’s a bit of a puzzle and I had to pay close attention, but it’s so worth it. What really stood out to me was the incredible writing and how perfectly it recreated the mood of those classic film noir stories.

‘The Gentlemen’ (2019)

The movie follows an American living in London who attempts to sell his large marijuana business, leading to a web of plots and backstabbing. It’s a return to the quick-witted British crime comedy style the director is known for, though some viewers feel the dialogue isn’t always natural and the story is overly complicated. Despite this, the film boasts a charming cast and plenty of the director’s trademark humor.

‘Blow’ (2001)

This movie tells the true story of George Jung and his rise to prominence in the American cocaine trade. Starring Johnny Depp, the film spans several decades and explores the world of drugs. While it tries to show the human side of Jung and the damage caused by his choices, many critics feel it doesn’t quite reach the level of other classic crime films.

‘True Romance’ (1993)

The movie follows a fan of comic books and a sex worker who mistakenly grab a suitcase full of drugs and decide to sell it in California. Written by Quentin Tarantino, the film boasts a strong supporting cast. While some find the love story unbelievable and the violence over-the-top, it’s gained a dedicated following thanks to its fast pace and unforgettable moments.

‘New Jack City’ (1991)

This movie tells the story of a drug kingpin’s ascent during the height of the crack epidemic in 1990s New York City, and the relentless police officers trying to stop him. It’s a raw and realistic portrayal of the social problems of that era. While some viewers find it feels a bit old-fashioned now, it’s remembered for its fast pace and Wesley Snipes’ captivating performance.

‘Boyz n the Hood’ (1991)

This film tells the story of three young men coming of age in South Central Los Angeles, navigating the challenges of gangs and crime. It’s a compelling drama that examines how a person’s surroundings can influence their decisions. While some viewers feel the film’s message is sometimes overstated, it’s still a significant and influential work that helped launch the careers of several well-known actors.

‘Menace II Society’ (1993)

This movie follows a young man struggling to escape a life of violence and crime in his neighborhood. It’s known for its brutally honest and realistic portrayal of street life, which some viewers may find intensely bleak. Many compare it to other hard-hitting urban dramas from the same period, praising its raw power and authenticity.

‘Joker’ (2019)

This movie follows a comedian whose career falls apart, leading him down a path of mental instability and ultimately transforming him into a figurehead for a growing criminal movement in a rundown city. It’s a deep dive into one man’s psyche, reminiscent of classic seventies crime films. While some critics believe it offers insightful commentary on society, others see it as derivative. Despite the divided opinions, the film was a huge box office hit and has generated a lot of conversation about mental health and its connection to societal issues.

‘Focus’ (2015)

The movie centers around an experienced swindler who mentors a young woman, showing her how to become a con artist herself. The story’s success depends heavily on the connection between the actors Will Smith and Margot Robbie. While visually appealing and polished, some audiences might find the plot twists obvious and the overall story doesn’t feel particularly urgent or dangerous. It prioritizes a romantic angle over a realistic or gritty portrayal of the con artist lifestyle.

‘Now You See Me’ (2013)

A group of illusionists commits bank robberies as part of their shows, distributing the stolen money to the audience. The movie uses impressive special effects and a quick tempo to hold viewers’ attention. However, many critics find the plot twists don’t make sense and the conclusion feels forced. Despite these criticisms, the film performed well enough to launch a series of sequels exploring similar magical concepts.

‘Sicario’ (2015)

This movie follows an optimistic agent who joins a team to dismantle a major drug cartel operating along the U.S.-Mexico border. It’s famous for its gripping, intense mood and beautiful visuals, captured by cinematographer Roger Deakins. While some viewers find the characters detached and the story pessimistic, the film offers a stark and realistic portrayal of the challenges of today’s drug war.

‘American Hustle’ (2013)

A pair of swindlers team up with a volatile FBI agent for a secret operation targeting crooked politicians. The film is known for its energetic cast and over-the-top seventies fashion. While some reviewers feel it prioritizes flashy visuals and strong acting over a clear storyline, it has earned numerous award nominations and continues to spark debate among crime movie enthusiasts.

‘The Wolf of Wall Street’ (2013)

The movie tells the story of a stockbroker who creates a huge, successful business through dishonest practices and lives a wildly extravagant lifestyle. It’s a fast-paced comedy that looks at the worlds of corporate crime and excessive greed. While some viewers find it too long and the characters unlikeable, it’s been highly praised for Leonardo DiCaprio’s acting and Martin Scorsese’s energetic directing style.

‘Catch Me If You Can’ (2002)

This film tells the story of a clever young con artist and the FBI agent determined to catch him. Based on real events, it’s a surprisingly upbeat take on a crime story. While some viewers think it glosses over the serious impact of the protagonist’s crimes, it’s still a beloved and enjoyable movie for both the actors and the director involved.

‘Layer Cake’ (2004)

The movie follows a cocaine dealer attempting to leave the criminal life, but he’s pulled back in for two last jobs that don’t go as planned. It’s known for its sleek visuals and is credited with helping Daniel Craig land the role of James Bond. While some viewers feel the story relies on familiar British gangster clichés, it offers a stylish glimpse into the world of organized crime and its power structure.

‘Savages’ (2012)

This action movie follows two marijuana farmers who must battle a powerful Mexican cartel after they kidnap the woman they both love. While visually striking and featuring a large cast, the film is often criticized for its thin plot and disappointing conclusion. It’s a fast-paced, colorful, and violent experience, but lacks substantial depth.

‘Pain & Gain’ (2013)

Based on a true story, this film follows three Florida bodybuilders who get caught up in a kidnapping and extortion scheme that quickly spirals out of control. While aiming for dark humor, the movie’s over-the-top violence and cartoonish depiction of criminals turned off some viewers. It’s a story about the pursuit of the American dream, but shows its seedy underbelly and the dangers of excess.

‘The Fast and the Furious’ (2001)

A police officer goes undercover to stop a dangerous group of car hijackers who race illegally on the streets. The movie became incredibly popular and spawned a long-running series, though it later shifted away from its original crime focus. While some critics found the performances and storyline uninspired and derivative, the film is still remembered for its significant impact on both car enthusiasts and action movies.

‘Bad Boys’ (1995)

This action-comedy follows two detectives as they guard a witness and investigate a heroin theft that occurred right in their own police station. The movie is known for launching the successful on-screen partnership between Will Smith and Martin Lawrence. While a big commercial success and the start of a franchise, some reviewers felt its flashy action and simple storyline were typical of director Michael Bay’s often-polarizing approach.

‘The Fugitive’ (1993)

This thrilling movie follows a doctor who becomes the prime suspect in his wife’s murder. While police pursue him, he races to uncover the true killer. Though some find the plot familiar, the film is highly praised for the captivating performances of Harrison Ford and Tommy Lee Jones, and it keeps you on the edge of your seat with constant suspense.

Please share your own thoughts about which crime movies you find overrated in the comments.

2026-01-01 10:54