Nosferatu Reminds Us Hollywood Still Hasn’t Nailed Bram Stoker’s Dracula

by

As a seasoned connoisseur of cinematic lore and a devoted admirer of Bram Stoker’s timeless masterpiece, Dracula, I must confess that the constant reinterpretations of this Gothic classic leave me longing for a faithful adaptation. Time and again, we see the essence of Stoker’s novel lost in translation as filmmakers strive to reinvent the wheel.

The long-awaited theater release of Robert Eggers’ modernized version of the 1922 classic Nosferatu is now available, offering a unique perspective on the renowned German silent film initially released in 1922. This nationwide debut on Christmas Day has been met with widespread praise for its acting, stunning visuals, and authentic set design reflecting the era.

Eggers’ film version of Dracula, though it receives praise, fails to fully capture Bram Stoker’s original 1897 Gothic horror story. Many adaptations before it have followed a similar pattern, straying from the novel and reinterpreting significant characters and motifs in ways that distort the core of the source material.

The process of modifying Stoker’s narrative started with initial adaptations for both books and films. For instance, F. W. Murnau’s Nosferatu (1922) was an unauthorized adaptation of Dracula, where character names were altered to dodge copyright complications. The Count Dracula character was transformed into Count Orlok, and the story’s location shifted from England to Germany.

In a similar fashion, the 1924 play by Hamilton Deane, later revised by John L. Balderston in 1927, combined characters and streamlined the storyline. This stage production had a significant impact on Tod Browning’s 1931 movie Dracula, featuring Bela Lugosi. This film introduced several common misconceptions about vampires that persist today.

For example, the concept that sunlight can destroy vampires first appeared in the movie Nosferatu, contrasting with Stoker’s Dracula who could move during daylight though weakened. Moreover, the 1924 play transformed Dracula into an appealing nobleman, while in the book, he initially appears as a grotesque figure that only becomes less frightening but never attractive over time.

Moreover, Professor Van Helsing, often depicted as an experienced vampire slayer in adaptations, was actually discovering the world of vampires for the very first time in the original story.

In Stoker’s Dracula, we find an impressive group of characters, with Mina Harker frequently recognized as the main character. Throughout the story, Mina is portrayed as clever, practical, and pivotal in vanquishing Count Dracula.

She compiles the documents that form the book’s narrative, provides critical insights, and even uses her psychic connection with Dracula to locate him. Yet, adaptations consistently undermine her role.

In the 1992 adaptation of Dracula by Francis Ford Coppola, Mina is depicted as a reborn manifestation of Dracula’s long-lost lover, transforming her from a strong and resilient figure into a willing victim instead. This distortion overlooks her intellectual and emotional fortitude, much like Lucy Westenra, another significant character, who experiences the same treatment in the film.

The novel depicts Lucy as virtuous and kind, and her tragic vampiric transformation shows her purity. However, Coppola’s film reduces her to a flirtatious character whose fate feels like a punishment for her sexuality.

In this modern retelling by Eggers, titled Nosferatu, Lily-Rose Depp plays Ellen Hutter – a character similar to Mina from the original story. Bill Skarsgård takes on the role of Count Orlok. The movie is heavily influenced by the 1922 version, but it introduces changes in Ellen’s character. Unlike the unwavering loyalty shown by Mina in the book, Ellen is portrayed as being torn between her husband and Count Orlok, creating a more complex dynamic in the narrative.

The movie concludes as Ellen perishes by revealing Orlok to daylight, a common yet questionable belief about vampire vulnerability. Unfortunately, the storyline doesn’t explain how Ellen and others became aware of this weakness, leaving the climax seemingly unfounded.

Read More

2024-12-26 10:22