Marty Supreme First Reactions: Timothée Chalamet Eyes Oscar Buzz With Powerful Performance at Secret NYFF Screening

by

Timothée Chalamet’s new film, *Marty Supreme*, is generating significant buzz. He plays Marty Mauser, a notorious table tennis player, and the movie boasts a stellar supporting cast including Gwyneth Paltrow, Odessa A’zion, Kevin O’Leary, Tyler Okonma, Abel Ferrara, and Fran Drescher. Following a private screening at the New York Film Festival, Chalamet received a powerful standing ovation, and early reactions online have been overwhelmingly positive, with many calling it a potential frontrunner for the best film of the year. The excitement surrounding the film isn’t about whether Chalamet can deliver a good performance – it’s about showcasing his talent to a wider audience.

The world reacts to Marty Supreme

Josh Safdie’s latest film, “Marty Supreme,” is receiving rave reviews. Film critic Rendy Jones, posting on X, described the premiere at the New York Film Festival as bringing the house down, with the loudest applause of the festival so far. Another viewer, known as MKUltraMoney, praised the film as another Safdie masterpiece, even more stressful than “Uncut Gems.” They also highlighted Timothée Chalamet’s performance, stating he truly shines when given strong material, and called it both the funniest and best film of the year.

Oh my gosh, you guys, Brandon Lewis *gets it*! He totally understands how amazing “Marty Supreme” is. He said it’s just a pure joy to watch, and Josh Safdie is a genius for creating this wild, sprawling story about a ping-pong player who’s, well, a bit of a jerk, but in the *best* way. Seriously, the way Safdie unravels this guy’s ego is just brilliant. And Lewis basically said that if anyone still questioned whether Timothée Chalamet is a full-blown movie star, this movie absolutely *destroys* that doubt. I knew it! Timothée is perfect!

Dancin’ Dan really enjoyed the film’s music and atmosphere, despite finding one character unlikeable. He especially praised the performances of MARTY SUPREME and Timothée Chalamet, describing the movie as a vibrant, 80s-influenced sports film set in the 50s, with a fantastic electronic score by Daniel Lopatin and a strong cast. While he thought it was a little lengthy, he felt the ending was satisfying and created a thrilling climax. He ended with a rhetorical question, asking if viewers were ready for a race.

Critics are calling “Marty Supreme” the Safdie brothers’ best film to date, praising its originality. One review described it as a fast-paced and wild ride, similar to films like “Catch Me If You Can” and “Uncut Gems.” Timothée Chalamet’s performance is being hailed as career-defining and the film itself as a truly impressive and captivating cinematic achievement.

Andrew T. was surprisingly positive about the film *Marty Supreme*, shown at the #NYFF63 festival, finding it ‘merely decent’ despite the negative reaction from others in the audience. He described it as starting like a parody of *Rocky*, then shifting towards the chaotic energy of films like *Uncut Gems* and *Good Time*, before returning to a slower pace. He also felt the film suffered from significant editing, suggesting key scenes were removed.

The Honey Row recently watched #MARTYSUPREME and was very disappointed, calling it a lazy and boring film that seems to be aiming for awards. They felt the movie lacked depth in both its characters and storyline, resulting in a confusing and unsatisfying experience. They had higher expectations and left feeling let down.

A recent review from user ‘uns*xuaIIy’ criticized the movie ‘Marty Supreme,’ calling it a disappointing and unnecessary cash grab by A24, particularly after the failure of ‘Flop Machine.’ The reviewer almost left the theater, but praised Kevin O’ Leary’s performance, suggesting the film isn’t worth watching otherwise.

Marty Supreme is all set to release this Christmas in cinemas!

Read More

2025-10-07 10:07