LendingClub: A Valuation in the Shadow of Progress

by

The recent disquiet surrounding LendingClub [LC], a contraction of nearly sixteen percent following the pronouncements of its fourth quarter, is not merely a market correction. It is, rather, a symptom – a fleeting exposure of the anxieties that cling to any institution attempting genuine reformation. The share price, briefly inflated by the hopes of facile gain, has retreated, revealing the bedrock of underlying value – a value often obscured by the fog of quarterly pronouncements and the clamor for immediate return.

The company, having emerged from a period of enforced austerity – a “Liberation Day,” as some have termed it – had, indeed, doubled its valuation. This ascent, however, bred a certain expectation, a demand for perpetual motion. When the pronouncements did not meet this artificial standard, the market reacted with predictable haste. It is a familiar pattern: the swift condemnation of any entity daring to deviate from the prescribed trajectory of unbridled growth.

The earnings, it is true, exceeded expectation, though by a margin insufficient to quell the restless spirit of speculation. Revenue rose, profits swelled, yet the market focused upon the projected earnings per share for the coming quarter – a figure deemed, in the eyes of some, insufficiently ambitious. This myopia, this insistence upon immediate gratification, is a disease that afflicts the body financial.

The present contraction, therefore, is not a cause for alarm, but an opportunity. A chance to acquire a stake in a company undergoing a fundamental transformation – a transition from the precarious realm of speculative lending to the solid ground of institutional acceptance. It is a transition fraught with complexity, but one that promises a more sustainable – and ultimately, more rewarding – future.

The Illusion of Disappointment

The fourth quarter revealed a revenue increase of 22.7 percent, reaching $266.5 million, and a profit surge of 338 percent, achieving $0.35 per share. These figures, while surpassing expectation, were deemed insufficient by those accustomed to the illusion of limitless growth. Loan originations, reaching $2.59 billion, were at the upper end of management’s projections – a foundation upon which future expansion will be built.

The current quarter’s guidance, projecting flat originations growth at $2.6 billion and modest earnings per share growth, appears to have triggered the recent contraction. Yet, this guidance fails to account for the inherent seasonality of the business – the ebb and flow of lending activity throughout the year. The first and fourth quarters are traditionally slower, while the spring and summer months witness a surge in demand.

Full-year guidance, projecting originations between $11.6 billion and $12.6 billion and earnings per share between $1.65 and $1.80, reveals a more nuanced picture. While representing a deceleration from the previous year’s extraordinary growth, these projections still indicate a 26 percent increase in originations and a 48 percent increase in earnings per share. This is not stagnation, but a recalibration – a shift towards sustainable expansion.

The Weight of Transition

The market’s disappointment stems, in part, from a misplaced expectation of immediate gratification. Investors, accustomed to the rapid ascent of the share price, anticipated an even more dramatic surge in earnings. This expectation, however, fails to account for the fundamental transformation underway at LendingClub – a transition to a new accounting method for all loans originated beginning in 2026.

Under the previous CECL method, LendingClub was forced to estimate all future losses for each loan and deduct these losses upfront. This imposed a significant burden upon the company, suppressing earnings as it expanded. The new Fair Value method, embraced by most of LendingClub’s peers, will record positive earnings immediately, albeit at a slower rate over the life of the loan.

This transition, while beneficial in the long term, will initially temper earnings growth. Investors, however, seem to have overlooked this crucial detail, demanding an immediate return that is simply not sustainable. This is a symptom of the broader malaise afflicting the financial markets – a relentless pursuit of short-term gains at the expense of long-term value.

A Moment for Prudence

The recent contraction, therefore, is not a cause for alarm, but an opportunity. A chance to acquire a stake in a company undergoing a fundamental transformation – a transition from the precarious realm of speculative lending to the solid ground of institutional acceptance. The guidance, while not extravagant, reveals no hidden costs or unexpected credit losses.

Management, recognizing the need for sustained growth, is reinvesting in marketing – a process that began last year. After a period of retrenchment, LendingClub is once again expanding its reach, targeting new markets and forging new partnerships. This requires a period of adjustment, a recalibration of the marketing engine. The initial ramp-up will be less efficient, as the company tests new strategies and refines its approach.

The CEO, Scott Sanborn, has explained that the company is nearing completion of its tuning of partner marketing channels. Other new channels, however, require further refinement. This process, while time-consuming, is essential for building a sustainable marketing engine. The company is also investing in new initiatives, such as home-improvement lending and partnerships with furniture retailers. These initiatives will not yield immediate results, but they will contribute to long-term growth.

The company is also pursuing a rebranding, reflecting its evolution from a peer-to-peer lender to a new-age bank. This process, while costly in the short term, will enhance the company’s image and attract new customers. The ramp-up of these growth investments, combined with the seasonal slowdown in the first quarter, likely explains the modest guidance for the current quarter.

A Valuation in the Shadow of Progress

Following the recent contraction, shares trade around $16.50, representing just 10 times the lower end of the 2026 guidance. This valuation seems absurdly cheap, given LendingClub’s history of conservative guidance. Even if one assumes that the 48 percent earnings growth target is unsustainable, the company still forecasts a 26 percent increase in originations. Absent the favorable accounting change, earnings should still grow at least in line with originations going forward.

By the end of this year, LendingClub’s marketing machine should be fully tuned and operating at peak efficiency. This will moderate marketing costs relative to revenue, sustaining earnings growth even as the accounting change benefit fades. The company’s commitment to long-term value, combined with its undervalued share price, makes it an attractive investment opportunity.

A forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 10 results in a price-to-earnings-to-growth (PEG) ratio of 0.5. Any PEG ratio under 1 is considered quite cheap. If management achieves the high end of 30 percent EPS growth over the medium term, the PEG ratio would fall to 0.33 – a ridiculously low valuation, even in the relatively conservative financial sector.

Read More

2026-02-01 15:52