Is Upstart Stock a Millionaire Maker?

by

Dear reader, permit me to introduce you to a rather intriguing character in the investing world: Upstart (UPST), a company boasting a market cap that sits modestly at a diminutive $5 billion. You might think that such a tiny figure would leave it basking in obscurity, far from the limelight of investment discussions. Ah, but don’t let its unassuming size fool you! This enterprising establishment is on a gallant quest to broaden the horizon of credit access to a delightful array of borrowers, a truly noble endeavor, I daresay. This venture is infused with a sprinkle of pizzazz, as it has chosen to employ the art of artificial intelligence (AI) in its mission.

Now, let’s talk of price fluctuations, which are enough to leave the untrained investor in a bit of a tizzy. Shares have had a rather rollercoaster-like trajectory, soaring to a notable 93% height over the last two years (as of October 3) yet, at present, they frolic at a dizzying 87% below their glorious all-time zenith. It’s enough to make one ponder profoundly on whether Upstart deserves a cozy spot in one’s portfolio.

The burning question looms large: could this fintech gem be the secret that unburdens one of that million-dollar aspiration? To answer such a prickly inquiry, one must weigh both the resplendent arguments and the murky counterpoints.

Theoretical Prospects: A Treasure Map to Upside

Since its inception in 2012, Upstart has orchestrated a rather impressive $48 billion worth of loans-admittedly just a foretaste of the larger lending buffet. With partnerships that number over 100 banks and credit unions, Upstart finds itself in the business of personal loans, auto refinances, and home equity lines of credit. These three bustling areas boast a combined annual origination volume that dances in the trillions of dollars. Oh, the vast total addressable market ripe for the plucking!

Utilizing the avant-garde charms of AI, Upstart has set its sights on the venerable FICO scoring model, swapping it out for a rather sophisticated scheme that evaluates a delightful 2,500 assorted variables pertaining to prospective borrowers. The true charm of this system lies in its ability to better gauge creditworthiness while deftly keeping defaults at bay. Consequently, this allows for a greater number of loans to pass the proverbial gatekeeper, leading to a merry increase in revenue potential. And as time unfolds, the AI model should, in theory, grow more astute.

In a spectacular show of success, Upstart celebrated a 102% year-over-year revenue surge in the second quarter (culminating on June 30), thanks to a staggering 159% increase in transaction volumes. Should the Federal Reserve decide to be generous and lower interest rates, we might just witness a blossoming demand for loans, resulting in further busyness on Upstart’s vibrant platform.

And really, one mustn’t ignore the rather attractive valuation at play here. Investors can indeed nab shares at a price-to-sales ratio of 5.8, which is akin to picking up a fine vintage at a clearance sale. Since the company’s preposterously splendid initial public offering back in December 2020, the average multiple floated at a resplendent 11.2. While perhaps not the bargain of a lifetime, the valuation holds promise should the company continue to dazzle with robust financial performances.

Loading widget...

A Whiff of Risk: The Uncertainty Paradox

Now, while it might seem that Upstart struts at the cutting edge of AI and machine learning, one must confess that its financial outcomes have been more unpredictable than a cat in a room full of rocking chairs. Rather than flourishing like a member of the tech elite with an unwavering growth pattern, Upstart performs rather like a traditional bank susceptible to the whims of macroeconomic forces.

In the matter of fluctuating interest rates, a substantial impact is at play. To lend an air of clarity: in 2021, Upstart’s revenue soared an astonishing 264% year-over-year, with the company enjoying a princely net income of $135 million under generally accepted accounting principles. Cut to 2024, and we beheld a rather sobering 25% drop in revenue, accompanied by a net loss of $129 million. Yet, as the sun casts its rays on us again, signs of improvement are afoot, as mentioned earlier, evidenced by a splendid uptick in Q2. The leadership seems rather optimistic for the current year’s profitability, albeit not by leaps and bounds.

But I digress! One cannot predict how Upstart shall navigate the entire credit cycle, and therein lies the rub-a rather substantial amount of uncertainty surrounds its long-term prospects. Should this floundering vessel find its sea legs, registering steady growth and consistent earnings, casual investors might find themselves thriving in a veritable ocean of confidence.

However, the specter of recession looms ominously! Even a year like 2022, which stubbornly clung to a lack of economic downturn, saw Upstart faced with pressures akin to a muffin under a teapot as credit markets tightened. And so stepping back, we realize that as a mid-cap company dabbling in lending products across rather hefty markets, the stock might lead to delightful winds of fortune should Upstart execute its strategy without a hitch and if the winds of external circumstances favour it. Alas, this outcome is hardly a certitude, and eager investors might do well to temper their expectations. Upstart is indeed an exhilarating company, but let us not kid ourselves-ownership of its stock is unlikely to catapult you into millionaire status.

😊

Read More

2025-10-11 15:38