How IMF’s $1.4B Deal With El Salvador, If Approved, Could Jeopardize Bitcoin’s Role as Legal Tender

by

As a seasoned crypto investor with over a decade of experience under my belt, I’ve witnessed the highs and lows of this ever-evolving market. The recent IMF agreement with El Salvador has certainly piqued my interest, particularly given its implications for Bitcoin as legal tender.

On December 18, 2024, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) declared they had achieved a preliminary agreement with El Salvador for a $1.4 billion loan through their Extended Fund Facility (EFF), as reported.

At present, the agreement is being discussed among staff members of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and needs to be endorsed by the IMF’s Executive Board, which is anticipated around early February 2025. The approval process depends on El Salvador making good on previously agreed-upon actions like fiscal adjustments, strengthening governance, and setting boundaries for Bitcoin’s influence in their economy. Upon receiving approval, this program would grant El Salvador access to approximately $1.4 billion from the IMF and might spur over $3.5 billion in additional financial support from other international financing institutions.

The accord lays out a comprehensive strategy for enhancing El Salvador’s financial and economic resilience, aimed at strengthening its stability.

  • Fiscal policy: The program aims to improve the primary fiscal balance by approximately 3.5 percent of GDP over three years. This includes measures already incorporated into the 2025 budget, such as reducing the wage bill, cutting spending on goods and services, and lowering transfers to municipalities. The reforms also target pension system sustainability and revenue mobilization to ensure public debt, which is projected to peak at 85 percent of GDP in 2024, begins to decline.
  • Transparency and governance: The government will strengthen fiscal transparency by enhancing the reporting of debt, pension costs, state-owned enterprises, and procurement contracts. Anti-corruption measures will also be prioritized, with improvements to anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing standards.
  • Reserves and financial buffers: Banks’ required liquidity buffers will increase from 11.5 percent of deposits to 15 percent by June 2026. The program also aims to enhance the central bank’s foreign reserve levels to better address economic shocks.
  • Climate adaptation and business environment: Efforts to modernize infrastructure, reduce red tape, and implement climate adaptation strategies will continue, supported by development partners.

Under the terms of the IMF agreement, potential risks associated with Bitcoin are specifically addressed, suggesting substantial modifications to Bitcoin’s influence within El Salvador’s economic structure.

  • Voluntary adoption by businesses: Bitcoin will remain legal tender, but businesses will no longer be required to accept it. This move eliminates the mandatory acceptance provision in the original Bitcoin Law, making Bitcoin adoption entirely optional for the private sector.
  • Limited public sector involvement: The government will gradually reduce its participation in Bitcoin-related activities. This includes phasing out the state-managed Chivo wallet and limiting its engagement in Bitcoin transactions and holdings. Taxes will only be payable in U.S. dollars, further diminishing Bitcoin’s role in public finances.
  • Enhanced regulation and transparency: The government will implement stricter regulatory measures for Bitcoin and other digital assets to safeguard financial stability and protect consumers. Transparency and oversight will be strengthened to align with international best practices, addressing concerns about the cryptocurrency’s volatility and speculative nature.

In essence, though Bitcoin is still considered a valid currency, the proposed modifications make it less practical to use in everyday transactions, be it within private or public sectors. The mandate for businesses to acknowledge Bitcoin as a form of payment is being lifted, and the government’s influence will decrease.

These changes imply that Bitcoin’s role as a legal tender might primarily serve a symbolic purpose, given its optional use and limited integration within public finances. Critics contend this weakens the initial goal of establishing Bitcoin as a foundational element of El Salvador’s economy, whereas supporters view it as a strategic move to reconcile innovation with financial security.

President Bukele has essentially reached an understanding with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that Bitcoin will not be considered legal currency, implying creditors are no longer obligated to accept it. In this manner, El Salvador becomes the world’s first country to cease recognizing Bitcoin as legal tender. Making Headlines.

— ricardovalp on @bluesky (@ricardovalp) December 18, 2024

El Salvador has agreed to a $3.5 billion financial aid package from the IMF, which comes with conditions requiring them to abandon Bitcoin as legal tender, repeal related laws, and shut down their Chivo Bitcoin wallet system. Despite some advocates’ claims that traditional currencies are worthless, it seems President Bukele is yielding to globalist pressures.

— Jacob King (@JacobKinge) December 18, 2024

The agreement goes beyond just Bitcoin; its goal is to strengthen El Salvador’s economy and rebuild trust among investors. Plans to decrease public debt, boost financial transparency, and establish economic resilience are anticipated to draw in extra international funding. The IMF predicts that these changes will keep El Salvador’s economy growing steadily, a growth that has been sustained by strong remittances and tourism, even amidst temporary weather-related issues. Inflation rates are decreasing, and the fiscal situation is gradually stabilizing, thanks to financial management operations that have reduced immediate financing requirements.

Read More

2024-12-19 08:15