Could ‘Agatha All Along’ Suffer the Same Fate as ‘The Acolyte’?

by

As a seasoned gamer and avid follower of all things Marvel, I can’t help but feel a mix of excitement and apprehension as Agatha All Along makes its grand debut on Disney+. Kathryn Hahn’s return as Agatha is something I’ve been eagerly anticipating since her captivating performance in WandaVision.

It appears that the title Agatha All Along has settled on its fitting name, with its premiere taking place today, September 18, 2024, on Disney+. The series will release two episodes initially and will air one new episode each week until November 6, wrapping up the season. Notably, Kathryn Hahn, who played a significant role in WandaVision, will be back to star as the main character in her solo show for this series.

Although the early responses have been largely favorable, with many pointing out a significant concern, certain enthusiasts are expressing anxiety that the show could encounter a similar predicament as The Acolyte, given its content and comments made by the team prior to its debut.

In this analysis, we’ll be examining the potential similarities between the fates of “Agatha All Along” and “The Acolyte,” given that both series have now started their much-anticipated streaming releases.

Regarding “The Acolyte”, the narrative unfolds as follows: Initially conceived as a substantial prequel, Lucasfilm poured significant resources into the series and its promotions, banking on its success alongside hits like “The Mandalorian” or “Ahsoka”. However, before the show even premiered, some toxic fans criticized it due to its diverse cast and female leads. This negativity was exacerbated by statements from the cast and crew, some of whom intentionally stirred up these fans. This led to an unprecedented wave of hate and negative reviews, although it didn’t directly determine the show’s outcome. Unfortunately, “The Acolyte” faced more issues than just fan backlash, and the writers ultimately failed to create a truly outstanding series, resulting in its cancellation.

Regarding “Agatha All Along”, it appears that the series doesn’t seem to be plagued by the systemic problems present in “The Acolyte”. However, some viewers are still apprehensive due to the cast and crew repeatedly referring to the show as “Marvel’s most gay” production so far. The creator, Jac Schaeffer, has made several remarks about this.

To put it simply, I see Agatha not only as a symbol but also as an exceptional performer who adapts her behavior based on her company. The writing team boldly chose to make these characters openly LGBTQ+, reflecting the strong connection between the history and oppression faced by witches and the LGBTQ+ community. Additionally, there’s a significant intersection between horror stories and the queer community, making it a fitting choice to have queer representation in the show.

Source: Zavvi

Additionally, other actors on the show have touched upon this topic as well. Aubrey Plaza subtly suggested a potential romantic angle for her character, Rio Vidal, with Agatha. Furthermore, Joe Locke has been vocal about the importance of LGBTQ+ representation within the show’s narrative.

In essence, The Acolyte was likened to how Leslye Headland and certain cast/crew members described it as “gay” and criticized those who held differing opinions. This sparked a wave of fans, many of whom had not yet seen the show, to demand that it be deemed poor quality. Given this pattern, could Agatha All Along face the same backlash? It’s unlikely!

There are two principal reasons why we think that. First, it is the franchise. The MCU has been like this from the start, and MCU fans are used to LGBTQ+ representation in these works. On top of that, Marvel’s comics are likewise more open to such topics, so the fanbase we’re dealing with does not have that many toxic “fans.” On the other hand, Star Wars “fans” are very vocal about their conservative interpretation of Lucas’ franchise, and when something changes (for example, a woman is the main character), it is immediately a problem, regardless of the overall quality of the work.

To clarify, “Agatha All Along” starts off in an entirely distinct manner compared to “The Acolyte”. While both shows belong to different narrative realms, it’s not really surprising given the unique nature of each storyline. In contrast, Disney has been introducing significant alterations across the “Star Wars” universe, and “The Acolyte” was a clear demonstration of this trend.

Following this, we’re quite optimistic that Agatha All Along won’t face the same challenges. There will always be critics and supporters, but if the show proves to be well-made, as it appears to be, it likely won’t meet a similar end as The Acolyte.

Read More

2024-09-18 14:44