Costco: Still a Bargain, or Just a Really Nice Warehouse?

by

Okay, so Costco. Everyone’s obsessed. It’s the retail equivalent of a golden retriever – relentlessly cheerful, always bringing you something (usually in bulk), and surprisingly good at guarding its turf. The stock’s been doing the happy dance for a while now, and honestly, it’s starting to feel a little suspicious. Like, what if this whole warehouse thing is just a really elaborate performance art piece? They’re good at logistics, I’ll give them that. But can they keep the magic going? Because let’s be real, the bar is now higher than the stack of toilet paper I bought last month.

Everyone agrees Costco’s a solid business. That’s boring. The real question isn’t if it’s good, it’s if it’s still worth the hype. Investors are basically saying, “Impress us. We’ve seen the free samples, now show us the long-term plan.” Here’s what they’re quietly obsessing over – and what I, as someone who actively seeks out companies everyone else is overpaying for, am paying attention to.

Can They Keep the Membership Train Rolling Without Price-Hiking Like a Used Car Salesman?

The membership model is the engine. It’s like a subscription to… well, everything. And people are into it. Last year they raked in $5.3 billion from memberships. Which is… a lot of Kirkland Signature rotisserie chickens. Renewal rates are sky-high, which means people aren’t just signing up, they’re staying signed up. But here’s the thing: they bumped up the fees recently. It’s the retail equivalent of a surprise tax. Now, can they keep growing without constantly squeezing more money out of their loyal fanbase? It’s a delicate dance. They don’t want to alienate the people who buy five-gallon tubs of mayonnaise, but they also need to keep the numbers going up.

I’m watching to see if they can add new members and keep the existing ones happy. If the membership numbers stay strong, that’s a good sign. If they start to slow down, it means the free samples aren’t enough to distract from the rising costs of, well, everything. Which, let’s be honest, is a very 2026 problem.

Loading widget...

International Expansion: Can They Replicate the Magic Outside of North America?

Okay, so they’re trying to conquer the world. Good luck with that. They’ve got warehouses popping up everywhere, but opening a store is the easy part. Actually making it profitable is where things get tricky. China is the big prize, obviously. Everyone wants a piece of the Chinese market. But it’s not like you can just plop a warehouse down and expect people to line up for bulk toilet paper. There are cultural differences, supply chain nightmares, and the general chaos of international business. It’s basically “Amazing Race” with spreadsheets.

I’m not interested in how many warehouses they open. I want to see if those warehouses actually make money. Are they getting high renewal rates? Are they managing costs effectively? Are they avoiding any international incidents involving questionable Kirkland Signature products? Because that could be a PR disaster.

Can Earnings Actually Keep Up With the Stock Price?

Let’s talk about valuation. The stock is trading at a premium. A significant premium. It’s like they’re selling hope, not just bulk goods. And hope is a volatile commodity. Everyone believes in Costco. The question is, can they justify the price tag? They need to show consistent earnings growth, driven by efficiency and sales. No smoke and mirrors, just solid results. It’s the retail equivalent of a sensible pair of shoes – reliable, comfortable, and not likely to fall apart after one wear.

Costco has looked “expensive” for years, and people have kept buying it. That’s impressive. But eventually, reality sets in. If earnings slow down, the premium could come under pressure. And that would be… awkward.

What Does This Mean for Investors?

Costco isn’t facing an existential crisis. It’s facing a credibility test. Everyone already likes them. Now they need to prove they can scale globally, maintain organic membership growth, and justify the stock price. It’s like being a beloved sitcom star – you’ve had a good run, now you need to deliver a killer season finale.

If they can execute on these three fronts, they’ll solidify their position as a retail leader. If not, well, even golden retrievers have bad hair days. As for me, I’m watching. And quietly hoping for a dip. Because a bargain, even at Costco, is still a bargain.

For investors, 2026 will be a year to observe if Costco can continue its world-class execution.

Read More

2026-01-22 00:14