Controversial “Gay” Green Lantern Comic Fails in Sales but Earns GLAAD Nomination for ‘Outstanding Comic’

In the previous year, a section of Green Lantern fan base experienced turbulence upon the unveiling of Sheridan’s ‘Alan ‘Scott: Green Lantern.’ The uproar in this comic revolves around the significant transformation of Alan Scott, an iconic character from the Golden Age of DC comics, into a gay individual.

A significant number of fans expressed disappointment over this move, as they felt it significantly deviated from the authentic representation of the character. The comic received criticism not just for its new interpretation, but also for its controversial marketing tactics and explicit content that some perceived as pornographic.

Instead of emphasizing the narrative itself, Sheridan urged readers to purchase the book as a means of “claiming victory over closed-minded individuals.” Some perceived this approach as controversial and disregarding of valuable feedback and constructive criticism.

Detractors argue that the comic writer places more emphasis on promoting a certain viewpoint than crafting an engaging Green Lantern narrative. Particular elements, such as Alan Scott’s romantic liaisons, involving a male sex worker who affectionately calls him “Scotty,” and representations of God endorsing his actions through The Spectre character, have sparked controversy among some readers, particularly those with deeply held religious or moral convictions.

Many believed that the show veered away from maintaining the essence of the Green Lantern universe, focusing more on presenting specific ideas instead.

1) It appears that the comics weren’t selling well, suggesting a general dislike from readers. Furthermore, it’s been said that Sheridan departed from DC Comics because he felt the company didn’t give enough backing to the book. However, critics counter this by suggesting the reason for poor reception was more likely due to issues with the storyline and its execution.

Inspite of facing criticism, the comic book received a nomination for a GLAAD Award in the category “Outstanding Comic.” This recognition has sparked ongoing discussions about the comic’s quality and public response.

As a passionate cinephile of comic books, I’m thrilled to see the diverse and inclusive narratives being highlighted in this year’s Outstanding Comic Book nominations. Notable mentions go to ‘Avengers Academy: Marvel’s Voices’ (Marvel Infinity Comics) and ‘Captain Marvel’ by Alyssa Wong (Marvel Comics), both of which brilliantly emphasize representation and groundbreaking storytelling. Here’s the complete list:

1. Avengers Academy: Marvel’s Voices (Marvel Infinity Comics)
2. Captain Marvel by Alyssa Wong (Marvel Comics)
3. Black Panther: T’Challa and the Crew (Marvel Comics)
4. Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed (DC Comics)
5. Bitter Root (Image Comics)
6. The Good Asian (Oni Press)
7. Lumberjanes: True Colors (BOOM! Studios)
8. Moth & Whisper (BOOM! Box, BOOM! Studios)
9. Monstress (Image Comics)
10. Runaways (Marvel Comics)
11. Teen Titans: Raven (DC Comics)
12. The Wicked + The Divine (Image Comics)
13. X-Men: Grand Design – Second Genesis (Marvel Comics)

  • ‘Alan Scott: The Green Lantern,’ by Tim Sheridan, Cian Tormey, Jordi Tarragona, Raúl Fernandez, John Livesay, Matt Herms, Chris Sotomayor, Lucas Gattoni (DC Comics)
  • ‘Avengers Academy: Marvel’s Voices,’ by Anthony Oliveira, Carola Borelli, Bailie Rosenlund, IG Guara, Alba Glez, Elisabetta D’Amico, Pablo Collar, Karen S. Darboe, Carlos Lopez, KJ Díaz, Ian Herring, Frank William, Ariana Maher, Joe Caramagna (Marvel Infinity Comics)
  • ‘Captain Marvel,’ by Alyssa Wong, Jan Bazaldua, Ruairí Coleman, Roberto Poggi, Bryan Valenza, Carlos Lopez, Ariana Maher (Marvel Comics)
  • ‘I Heart Skull-Crusher,’ by Josie Campbell, Alessio Zonno, Angel De Santiago, Jim Campbell (BOOM! Studios)
  • ‘The Nice House by the Sea,’ by James Tynion IV, Álvaro Martínez Bueno, Jordie Bellaire, Andworld Design (DC Comics)
  • ‘NYX,’ by Jackson Lanzing, Collin Kelly, Francesco Mortarino, Enid Balám, Elisabetta D’Amico, Michael Shelfer, Raúl Angulo, Joe Sabino (Marvel Comics)
  • ‘The Oddly Pedestrian Life of Christopher Chaos,’ by Tate Brombal based on an idea by James Tynion IV, Isaac Goodhart, Soo Lee, Naomi Franq, Miquel Muerto, Patricio Delpeche, Héctor Barros, Aditya Bidikar (Dark Horse Comics)
  • ‘Poison Ivy,’ by G. Willow Wilson, Marcio Takara, Luana Vecchio, Haining, Arif Prianto, Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou (DC Comics)
  • ‘Spectregraph,’ by James Tynion IV, Christian Ward, Aditya Bidikar (DSTLRY)
  • ‘Suicide Squad: Dream Team,’ by Nicole Maines, Eddy Barrows, Eber Ferreira, José Luís, Adriano Di Benedetto, Adriano Lucas, Becca Carey (DC Comics)

Read More

2025-01-25 18:14