Bonds & Boredom: A Matter of Taste

by

The financial world, dear reader, is seldom about finding the best instrument, but rather the one most suited to one’s temperament. In the realm of fixed income, this translates to a choice between the Vanguard Intermediate-Term Treasury ETF (NASDAQ:VGIT) and the Fidelity Investment Grade Bond ETF (NYSEMKT:FIGB). One offers the quiet respectability of a well-managed estate; the other, the slightly bolder flourish of a gentleman with a penchant for speculation. The difference, as always, lies in the details – and, of course, in the cost of maintaining appearances.

Loading widget...

Both funds, you see, aspire to offer a core U.S. fixed income experience. But while VGIT is a study in monastic simplicity – a portfolio exclusively devoted to intermediate-term Treasury bonds – FIGB is a more flamboyant affair, encompassing a wider spectrum of high-grade bonds. It is a question of preference: do you desire the serene predictability of the state, or the slightly more adventurous, though not entirely reckless, path of corporate credit?

A Snapshot of Propriety (and Price)

Metric VGIT FIGB
Issuer Vanguard Fidelity
Expense ratio 0.03% 0.36%
1-yr return (as of 2026-02-10) 1.7% 2.8%
Dividend yield 3.8% 4.1%
AUM $44.6 billion $354.6 million
Beta 0.82 1.01

The matter of cost, naturally, is paramount. VGIT, with its expense ratio of a mere 0.03%, is the epitome of fiscal prudence. FIGB, at 0.36%, requires a slightly more generous allowance. One might argue that a higher yield of 4.1% (versus VGIT’s 3.8%) justifies the extravagance, but then again, one often pays a premium for the illusion of excitement. As I always say, a small fortune is a terrible thing to waste, and high fees have a habit of doing just that.

Performance & Risk: A Question of Temperament

Metric VGIT FIGB
Max drawdown (4 y) (13.4%) (15.6%)
Growth of $1,000 over 4 years $1,056 $1,050

The numbers, while useful, tell only a partial story. FIGB boasts a slightly higher return over the past year, but VGIT has demonstrated a remarkable steadiness, a quality often undervalued in our age of breathless speculation. It is a fund for those who prefer to accumulate wealth slowly and deliberately, like a connoisseur collecting fine art. FIGB, by contrast, is for the investor who enjoys a little more volatility, a touch of drama in their portfolio. A gentleman, after all, must have some vices.

The composition of each fund further illuminates their contrasting philosophies. FIGB, with its 707 positions spanning both government and corporate bonds, is a study in diversification. It is a fund that seeks to capture a broad swathe of the fixed income market. VGIT, however, holds a mere 102 positions, all exclusively in U.S. Treasury securities. It is a fund that embraces simplicity, a quality increasingly rare in the modern world.

For those seeking guidance, one might consult further resources, but ultimately, the decision rests on one’s personal inclinations. As I have observed, the market rewards not necessarily the most informed investor, but the most self-aware.

The Implications, Briefly Stated

Both VGIT and FIGB are perfectly respectable options for the intermediate-term bond investor. They have both delivered positive returns with minimal disruption. However, the choice hinges on two key considerations: diversification and duration. FIGB’s broader exposure and longer average duration (5.9 years versus VGIT’s 4.9 years) may prove advantageous if interest rates decline. But remember, dear reader, anticipating the whims of central bankers is a fool’s errand.

VGIT’s slightly superior performance over the past four years, coupled with its lower volatility, makes it a compelling choice for the long-term investor. It is a fund that prioritizes stability and preservation of capital, qualities that are often overlooked in the pursuit of fleeting gains. In an age of excess, a touch of restraint is always in style.

With the Federal Reserve signaling a potential shift towards a more accommodating monetary policy, bond investors may find themselves in a favorable position. VGIT, with its focus on U.S. Treasuries, offers a safe haven in times of uncertainty. FIGB, with its allocation to corporate bonds, may benefit from an improving economy. But as always, the future remains delightfully unpredictable. And isn’t that, ultimately, the most amusing prospect of all?

Read More

2026-02-11 22:13