‘A Complete Unknown’ Review Roundup: Timothée Chalamet’s Bob Dylan Captivates Critics Despite Mixed Reception

by

As a seasoned gamer of both the big and small screens, I must say that ‘A Complete Unknown’ has certainly piqued my interest. Being a lover of biographical dramas and a fan of Bob Dylan‘s music, this film seems to tick all the right boxes. The mixed reviews are intriguing, with some praising it for its profound portrayal of Dylan’s complex personality and cultural impact, while others find it shallow and lacking in depth.

‘James Mangold’s American film, ‘A Complete Unknown’, is a biographical drama inspired by Elijah Wald’s book ‘Dylan Goes Electric!’. This movie delves into the contentious decision made by Bob Dylan to employ electric instruments during the 1965 Newport Folk Festival, a choice that sparked controversy.’

In this movie, Timothée Chalamet plays the role of Dylan, with an ensemble that also includes Elle Fanning, Edward Norton, and Monica Barbaro. The film derives its name from Dylan’s hit song “Rolling Stone.

The movie is scheduled to premiere in the U.S. on December 25, 2024. Searchlight Pictures will be handling its distribution. The American Film Institute and the National Board of Review both listed it among their top films of 2024. Elle Fanning received the Best Supporting Actress award from the latter, while Chalamet got three Golden Globe nominations, including one for Best Actor – Drama.

Despite the release of the review embargo for the film, opinions have varied among critics. Let’s delve into what online commentators are discussing.

Critic Tim Grierson praised the movie as it highlights Dylan’s mysterious and complex personality.

The movie effectively portrays how Dylan’s mysterious charm unfolds as he ascends in the American folk music world, only to stir controversy when he elects to perform electrically. This portrayal sheds light on why Dylan’s enigmatic nature remains fascinating.

Screen International

Additionally, Nick Curtis commended the film for presenting a deeply insightful depiction of Bob Dylan that transcends simple mimicry. It effectively illustrates his impact on music, the transformative cultural movements he initiated, and the sweeping social transitions taking place during that period.

As a devoted fan, I’m utterly captivated by this exceptional showcase. It’s not just about imitating; it delves much deeper, tracing the journey of the singer-songwriter, the transformation he brought to the music scene, and the significant events in the world during tumultuous times of change.

London Evening Standard

David Rooney from THR recognizes that the movie ‘A Complete Unknown’ has similarities with ‘Walk the Line’, yet it also possesses distinct weaknesses of its own. Nevertheless, Timothée Chalamet’s powerful and captivating acting stands out as a significant advantage in the film.

The Hollywood Reporter

According to John Nugent from Empire, although the movie doesn’t bring new, revolutionary understandings about Bob Dylan, it still presents a skillfully made musical drama featuring impressive acting.

Those seeking a groundbreaking portrayal of a renowned artist may find themselves slightly underwhelmed. However, despite its traditional nature, this musical drama offers remarkably skillful production and exceptional acting performances.

Empire

Now, onto the bad.

As a dedicated admirer, I must say that according to Kevin Maher from The Times, this movie seems to fall flat in terms of depth and substance. However, it’s essential to emphasize that Timothée Chalamet’s captivating performance should not be held accountable for these shortcomings.

It’s important to note that the disappointing outcome of the casual, uninquisitive Bob Dylan biography film isn’t attributable to the lead actor, Timothée Chalamet.

Times

According to Trace Sauveur, the movie oversimplifies Bob Dylan’s life using expected sequences of scenes, failing to offer insight or a unique viewpoint.

Recalling the movie “Walk Hard,” Bob Dylan might not need to ponder over every aspect of his life before taking the stage, yet his past seems to whizz by in a series of familiar scenes, much like a well-rehearsed montage.

AwardsWatch

David Jenkins from Little White Lies contends that, unlike Bob Dylan who skillfully unveiled deep truths amidst his self-mythologization through his poetry, director James Mangold falls short in creating a comparable level of depth or insight in the movie he made.

Bob Dylan didn’t always adhere strictly to the facts when crafting his personal legend, but he managed to unveil profound, hidden truths about the world through his powerful poetry. As of now, James Mangold hasn’t achieved the same level of credibility yet.

Little White Lies

The movie currently holds a 73% approval rate based on 41 reviews on Rotten Tomatoes.

Read More

2024-12-10 21:14