Ranking Every Disney Live-Action Remake: Which One Reigns Supreme?

Disney’s live-action adaptations breathe life into beloved animated stories, combining a touch of the past with innovative narratives. Ranging from enchanting fairy tales to animal escapades, they strive to preserve their heritage while forging new paths. Some sparkle brilliantly, others may stumble, but each contributes to Disney’s rich history.

In this list, we find ourselves evaluating 24 movies that are remakes of animated classics. For instance, ‘Maleficent’ and ‘Cruella’ offer fresh perspectives on well-known characters, while ‘Christopher Robin’ continues the storyline from the ‘Winnie the Pooh’ series, and ‘Mufasa: The Lion King’ delves into the past events preceding the original. We’ve arranged them in order from least to most impressive, considering factors like emotional resonance, visual appeal, and overall impact.

24. Pinocchio (2022)

As a movie enthusiast, I’m thrilled to share that Robert Zemeckis is at the helm of this modern take on the 1940s classic, “Pinocchio.” Benjamin Evan Ainsworth lends his voice to Pinocchio, a wooden puppet yearning for reality. In this version, Tom Hanks embodies Geppetto, while both Jiminy Cricket and the Blue Fairy are brought to life through cutting-edge CGI.

The movie seems lackluster, devoid of the heartfelt appeal found in the original. The overly polished visuals and sluggish tempo diminish its appeal, and despite Tom Hank’s sincere performance, it struggles to overcome a dialogue that fails to ignite any emotional connection.

23. Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016)

In this follow-up to the 2010 reboot, I, as a movie enthusiast, find myself stepping back into the whimsical world of Wonderland once more, with Mia Wasikowska reprising her role as Alice. The Mad Hatter, played by Johnny Depp, and the Red Queen, portrayed by Helena Bonham Carter, bring their unique charm to the storyline. However, this tale veers significantly from the 1951 classic, offering a fresh take on the beloved narrative.

Instead of maintaining the original’s enchanting charm, the disorganized storyline and excessive special effects overpower its whimsical spirit in this adaptation. While it showcases visual daringness, it seems to fall short on emotional depth, positioning itself as one of the less impactful remakes within Disney’s repertoire.

22. Dumbo (2019)

In Tim Burton’s reimagining of the 1941 original, Colin Farrell and Danny DeVito star, focusing on an elephant with the ability to fly who hails from a struggling circus. The movie introduces a more somber atmosphere and human elements to Dumbo’s straightforward tale.

Instead of adding depth, excess side stories weaken the initial enchantment. Burton’s approach seems incongruous, and an overemphasis on human characters detracts from Dumbo’s magical appeal, making it less appealing compared to others.

21. 102 Dalmatians (2000)

In the follow-up to the 1996 reboot, Glenn Close once again plays Cruella De Vil, now reformed but still with an insatiable appetite for dalmatian coats. A fresh group of adorable puppies find themselves entangled in her daring, over-the-top plot to acquire their spotted pelts in this fun, action-packed sequel.

Essentially, it feels like a remake of the original movie, with an over-reliance on Close’s acting. Unfortunately, due to the scarcity of new concepts, it ranks quite low on the list.

20. Lady and the Tramp (2019)

In this updated Disney+ version of the 1955 original, Tessa Thompson and Justin Theroux provide the vocal talents for a sophisticated spaniel and an unkempt stray. Live animals and computer-generated imagery are used to depict their loving relationship and their adventures in rat hunting.

The movie opts for a more conventional approach, falling short of recapturing the emotional impact of the original. Despite its charm, it fails to leave a lasting impression, paling in comparison to other remakes with more vibrant appeal.

19. Rudyard Kipling’s The Jungle Book (1994)

In this modern retelling of the 1967 original, Jason Scott Lee takes on the role of Mowgli. This film, set amidst the backdrop of colonial India, emphasizes adventure and romance over the animal characters and musical elements that were prevalent in the previous version.

The change from its lighthearted essence seems to hinder its progress. The human-focused narrative, while daring, appears disconnected from Disney’s traditional charm.

18. Mulan (2020)

In this new version of the 1998 movie, Niki Caro takes the helm, casting Liu Yifei in the role of Mulan, a character who disguises herself as a man to defend China. Unlike the original, this adaptation eliminates the musical numbers and the character of Mushu, opting instead for a more somber and action-focused atmosphere.

Liu’s acting and visuals are impressive, yet they fall short due to the absence of humor and emotion. The movie maintains a gritty tone instead of a charming one, placing it in the middle tier of quality.

17. 101 Dalmatians (1996)

In this fresh retelling of the 1961 original, I can’t help but be captivated by Glenn Close’s mesmerizing portrayal of Cruella De Vil. As Pongo and Perdy’s adorable puppies find themselves in the crosshairs of her daring fur scheme, they embark on an exhilarating, comically chaotic rescue operation.

The over-the-top wickedness portrayed by Close is simple yet entertaining, lacking significant novelty. It’s enjoyable more for her vivacity than any fresh ideas, keeping the narrative interesting.

16. Peter Pan & Wendy (2023)

In this modern reinterpretation of the 1953 tale, it’s Ever Anderson and Alexander Molony who take on the roles of Wendy and Peter Pan. Jude Law’s portrayal of Captain Hook adds a chilling edge to their escapades in Neverland, brimming with enchantment.

As a movie buff, I’d say it’s commendable, but it doesn’t exactly break new ground. The acting is on point, yet the film seems to stick to familiar paths, lacking the daring creativity that could have taken it to greater heights.

15. Alice in Wonderland (2010)

In a modern retelling of the 1951 original film, Tim Burton’s adaptation casts Mia Wasikowska as an adult Alice and Johnny Depp as the Mad Hatter. This cinematic journey is a visually striking adventure where Alice confronts the Red Queen in a gloomy Wonderland.

In this rephrased version, I’ve tried to maintain the essence of your statement while making it more accessible and engaging: The powerful images eclipse the storyline, causing a diminished sense of the original’s appeal. It presents a daring approach, yet one that feels disconnected, favoring flashy style over the original’s straightforward delight.

14. Mufasa: The Lion King (2024)

In this pre- sequel to the 2019 reboot, we delve into the story of Mufasa’s ascension to the throne, portrayed by Aaron Pierre. Directed by Barry Jenkins, it delves deep into his earlier years and the tense rivalry with Scar, employing breathtaking computer-generated imagery.

The visuals and Jenkins’ direction are powerful, however, compared to a remake, it seems more like an origin story. It delivers strong emotional resonance, but it doesn’t surpass the original versions in terms of impact.

Jenkins’ direction and visuals are impressive, but as a prequel, it lacks the feel of a remake. While it offers deep emotional connections, it doesn’t outshine direct retellings.

13. Snow White (2025)

In this updated version of the timeless 1937 story, Rachel Zegler takes on the role of Snow White, while Gal Gadot portrays the wicked queen. The fresh tunes and contemporary motifs breathe new life into the fairytale about a princess navigating peril.

Zegler delivers an outstanding performance, yet the blend of modern updates and traditional elements appears somewhat unbalanced. It’s an admirable attempt, though it falls short of perfectly capturing the original’s enduring enchantment.

12. Christopher Robin (2018)

In this follow-up to the original animated series, Ewan McGregor takes on the role of grown-up Christopher Robin, who once again encounters his beloved friends Winnie the Pooh and company. The story seamlessly combines computer-generated imagery with live action, resulting in a touching tale about rediscovering what truly matters in life.

The emotional heart of it is robust, yet it feels somewhat out of place as a follow-up when compared to reimaginings. Despite its cozy appeal, it doesn’t quite match up with the primary focus on direct remakes.

11. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil (2019)

In this continuation of the 2014 movie, Angelina Jolie reprises her role as Maleficent, encountering Michelle Pfeiffer’s character Queen Ingrith. This installment delves further into both Aurora’s tale and Maleficent’s past, using striking visual effects to do so.

Jolie’s acting and the cinematography are captivating, however, the story veers away more from ‘Sleeping Beauty.’ Despite its boldness, it fails to recapture the original’s unique perspective.

10. Cruella (2021)

In the 1970s London scene, Emma Stone portrays a youthful version of Cruella De Vil, who emerges as a fashion maverick. Emma Thompson’s character, Baroness von Hellman, serves as the spark for their contentious rivalry in this backstory that links to ‘101 Dalmatians.’

The captivating magnetism displayed by Stone and the movie’s vibrant style give it a radiant appeal. Despite not being a literal remake, its daring originality secures a prominent position.

9. The Sorcerer’s Apprentice (2010)

Under the guidance of director Jon Turteltaub, this fresh take on the 1940 ‘Fantasia’ segment stars Jay Baruchel as Dave, a young man selected by sorcerer Balthazar, portrayed by Nicolas Cage, to confront malevolent entities. The movie extends the famous broom scene into a contemporary magical journey.

The film’s energetic plotline and eccentric charisma of Cage make for an enjoyable journey. While it may not strictly adhere to the original, its daring approach and stylish presentation secure it a strong position on the lists.

8. The Little Mermaid (2023)

In this modern adaptation of the 1989 original, Halle Bailey brings Ariel to life beautifully, pursuing love alongside Prince Eric within an enchanting underwater realm. Fresh tunes and breathtaking graphics are employed to rekindle the enchantment.

Bailey’s voice and rich imagery significantly enhance the overall experience, however, certain elements seem slightly unbalanced. It manages to pay tribute to the original version whilst introducing new, refreshing aspects, ultimately resulting in a highly commendable outcome.

7. The Jungle Book (2016)

In a modern retelling of the 1967 original film, Jon Favreau’s adaptation employs lifelike computer-generated imagery to portray Mowgli, played by Neel Sethi. Characters such as Baloo voiced by Bill Murray and Shere Khan voiced by Idris Elba contribute vibrancy to the jungle setting.

The unique combination of engaging visuals and an innovative yet authentic narrative sets it apart from others. However, some rhythmic inconsistencies slightly hinder its potential, the emotional connection and technological integration, though, are seamlessly blended.

6. Cinderella (2015)

In this modern retelling, director Kenneth Branagh casts Lily James in the role of Cinderella, opposite Cate Blanchett as the malevolent stepmother. The film, a fresh take on the 1950 original, beautifully blends romance and virtue with visually stunning scenes.

The film’s uncomplicated allure, combined with Blanchett’s outstanding acting, elevates it to great heights. It skillfully embodies the enchanting spirit of a fairytale without becoming too intricate, thereby making it truly special and precious.

5. Maleficent (2014)

As a movie buff, I’m thrilled about the captivating portrayal of Angelina Jolie as Maleficent, transforming the ‘Sleeping Beauty’ antagonist into a misunderstood guardian. Elle Fanning’s Aurora infuses this darker, emotional reinterpretation with warmth and compassion, making it an enchanting tale that delves deeper into the classic story we all know and love.

1. Jolie’s strong aura and innovative revamp set it apart. Its unique point of view and breathtaking imagery secure it a place in the top five.

2. With her commanding presence, Jolie gives it an edge, while its daring reinvention makes it stand out. Its fresh perspective and captivating visuals earn it a spot among the top five.

3. The powerful influence of Jolie and the bold reimagining make it distinctive. Its innovative viewpoint and striking visuals place it in the top five.

4. Jolie’s commanding persona and audacious remake set it apart. Its fresh perspective and awe-inspiring aesthetics earn it a position in the top five.

5. The strong impact of Jolie and the daring reinterpretation make it stand out. Its unique angle and stunning visuals secure it a spot in the top five.

4. Lilo & Stitch (2025)

In this updated version based on the 2002 hit, we find ourselves in Hawaii with a girl named Lilo and an unruly extraterrestrial called Stitch. This fresh take combines computer-generated and real-life elements to preserve the warmth and wit of the first film, creating a new family tale that’s sure to delight viewers once more.

The place exudes lively spirit and genuine culture, standing out vividly. The heartfelt essence and captivating personalities give it a solid position in the top-tier options.

3. Beauty and the Beast (2017)

In this modern retelling of the 1991 original, Emma Watson portrays Belle, while Dan Stevens takes on the role of the Beast. Bill Condon is at the helm of this production, enhancing the classic love story with fresh tunes and more complex character developments.

The vivid imagery and authentic narration have made it a beloved choice among fans. Watson’s captivating portrayal, along with the blend of nostalgia and fresh ideas, consistently place it among the best.

2. Aladdin (2019)

In this modern retelling of the 1992 original, director Guy Ritchie casts Mena Massoud as Aladdin, Naomi Scott as Princess Jasmine, and Will Smith in the role of the Genie. The film is filled with vivid colors and fresh tunes that breathe new life into the tale.

In a more relaxed phrase, we could say that Smith’s captivating Genie and Scott’s strong-willed Jasmine shine brightly. Their energetic acts and visually striking scenes almost flawlessly reimagine the original production.

1. The Lion King (2019)

In simpler terms, Jon Favreau’s modern version of the 1994 original story focuses on Simba, played by Donald Glover, regaining his position as king. Beyoncé’s portrayal of Nala and James Earl Jones’ return as Mufasa make this epic tale even more compelling.

The cutting-edge computer graphics and outstanding voice actors beautifully recreate the grandeur of the original. It has a modern feel while still maintaining an ageless quality, setting it apart as the benchmark for Disney’s reimaginings.

2025-05-27 22:16