The Last of Us: Why Singing in a Nightmare Makes Us Human

by

In a natural and easy-to-understand manner: We’re all susceptible, in a delightful sense, to certain narrative themes, and during its second season, “The Last of Us” has exceeded my expectations with one of my favorites. The series has presented two remarkable scenes, both derived from the video game, where a character in dire straits demonstrates their humanity through singing. It’s fascinating that this specific trope consistently resonates with me, even when executed moderately well, but it truly shines on “The Last of Us”. This type of scene underscores why art holds significance in the first place because it encapsulates the essence of what makes human experiences meaningful.

In “The Price,” there were several flashbacks showcasing Ellie’s birthday celebrations during her time in Wyoming. For her first birthday, Joel presented her with a repaired guitar, mentioning earlier that he would teach her when she was going through tough times. True to his word, he was now ready to fulfill his promise. However, Ellie insisted on listening to him play first. And so he did, not long after he had killed numerous Fireflies and doomed humanity. As the world beyond the commune’s walls erupted in flames, Joel played the guitar. He played despite the uncertainty of whether they would survive another day. For a while, the harsh realities of life, their past hardships, and the looming dangers seemed insignificant. It was just the two of them, sharing a moment with a guitar and a song.

Although Joel might not have taken home the title of “Jackson Idol”, his heartfelt interpretation of Pearl Jam’s “Future Days” certainly left an impression. It showcased a more delicate side of Joel, suggesting he may fare better in a harsh zombie apocalypse than conventional society. The performance was deeply poignant, resonating not only with the characters but also enriching the broader narrative. Moreover, it served as a backstory for Ellie’s struggles to sing the song in season two’s fifth episode. For her, the opening line, “If I ever were to lose you,” was too emotionally taxing. The very song, written before the world perished, connected her to Joel, yet prevented her from performing it. The power of “Future Days” was overwhelming, but that’s precisely why Ellie found solace in it initially.

In episode four, Ellie managed to play an entire song, having discovered a functioning guitar amidst the devastated remains of Seattle. Despite being overwhelmed by sorrow and rage prior to that moment, Ellie chose to sit and strum the instrument. She did so as a means to recall happier times, and also to connect more deeply with the man who had taken the time to teach her. When Dina entered the scene, Ellie continued playing for the woman she cherishes dearly, her closest friend.

In comparison to Joel, Ellie wasn’t meant to triumph in singing contests, that much was clear. However, the quality of their singing was irrelevant. What truly mattered was that they sang at all. Given the horrific circumstances they endured, the heinous actions they committed and were subjected to, and in Ellie’s case, the dark path she was about to embark on, they both demonstrated that they had preserved a piece of their heart through their songs.

Art serves as a means for individuals to connect with their compassionate sides and with one another, which is something that cold-hearted beings like cordyceps monsters or sociopaths who lack empathy fail to comprehend. They find solace in art as a way to reach out and remind us all that we’re not alone in the universe.

As a film enthusiast, I can’t help but feel that certain cinematic tropes resonate deeply within me, much like the haunting melody of A-ha’s “Take On Me” echoing through an abandoned building, reminding me that art is what truly makes us human. It’s not about our superiority in creating it compared to other beings, but rather our unique ability to express ourselves in this way.

Art has a remarkable power to uplift us when we’re at our lowest points, serving as a beacon of hope amidst the darkness. It’s a testament that our emotions, whether they are pain, hope, fear, dreams, or worries, are not solitary burdens but shared experiences that bind us together.

In the hustle and bustle of life, it’s easy to forget this sense of unity. But art serves as a reminder that even in the most desolate of settings, such as a dystopian wasteland, being human is not an isolated existence, but rather a collective journey. There is strength in sharing our stories, even if we are the only ones singing another’s song at times.

I’m captivated by stories that showcase a performer or artist in challenging circumstances, whether it’s a knight singing eve of his imminent demise, three distinct individuals enjoying life on a boat while a fearsome shark lurks nearby, a father consoling his child during an apocalypse, or a soldier entertaining fellow soldiers on the brink of death in war. This narrative device resonates deeply with me because it underscores the importance of art. It provides solace and joy during pleasant times, and solace especially during trying ones. Art serves as a constant reminder that our shared humanity is something worth defending vigorously – particularly when forces within and without seem determined to erode or destroy it.

Kindly share with us your preferred variation of the trope, as Mikey Walsh, who is a staff writer at TopMob, can be reached at his Bluesky handle @burgermike.

Read More

2025-05-19 19:33