You Won’t Believe Who Tops Our List of Hallmark’s 20 Greatest Stars—Ranked

As a die-hard movie buff, I can’t help but admire the special talent that Hallmark Channel stars possess. They have this uncanny ability to infuse every tale with warmth and charm, making them the soul of the network’s cherished films. Whether they’re playing romantic leads or holiday heroes, these actors and actresses weave moments that resonate long after the final credits fade away.

In this list, I’ve arranged the top 20 actors who have shone brightest on the Hallmark Channel over the years. Their performances, characterized by impact, adaptability, and an uncanny knack for embodying the channel’s beloved feel-good vibe, have become a staple of the network’s programming. These popular figures have indelibly marked the Hallmark brand, providing us with memorable characters that keep us tuning in. So, let’s get to know these cherished personalities better.

20. Jonathan Bennett

In a vibrant debut, Bennett graced Hallmark with ‘Elevator Girl’ (2010), becoming a trailblazer as the platform’s inaugural lead character in a gay role for ‘The Holiday Sitter’ (2022). His cheerful enthusiasm is captivatingly showcased in heartwarming holiday romantic comedies.

I’m particularly fond of his contagious excitement, particularly in ‘The Christmas House’ series. His knack for combining wit with emotion sets him apart, even though he’s relatively new on the network, indicating a promising future.

19. Taylor Cole

Cole lends grace to movies such as ‘Christmas in Homestead’ (2016) and the ‘Ruby Herring Mysteries.’ The well-structured, courageous characters she portrays enhance the complexity of Hallmark’s romantic storyline.

Her quiet power holds my attention, despite some roles appearing somewhat repetitive. She’s consistently a solid choice for those who appreciate the charm of traditional Hallmark tales.

18. Jesse Metcalfe

In 2017, Metcalfe, famously recognized for ‘Desperate Housewives,’ entered Hallmark with the film ‘Christmas Next Door.’ Additionally, he played a role in ‘Chesapeake Shores.’ Given his enchanting demeanor, he seems to be an ideal fit for the romantic leads on this network.

I appreciate his passion, particularly in Christmas movies, although his tenure with Hallmark is limited compared to others. He’s an excellent choice for romantic tales set in small towns.

17. Jessica Lowndes

Actress Shannen Doherty, who is known for her role on ‘90210’, shines brightly in festive films such as ‘A December Bride’ (2016) during the Christmas season. Her lively portrayals and vocals bring an extra touch of charm to Hallmark’s holiday movie collection.

Despite the unexpected shift to GAC Family, her luminous aura continues to draw me in. Her Hallmark movies, cherished by fans, still hold a special place.

Or:

Though her move to GAC Family prematurely ended her tenure at Hallmark, I’m still captivated by her dazzling presence. Her films continue to be fan favorites.

Or:

Her radiant energy keeps pulling me in, even though her move to GAC Family curtailed her time at Hallmark. Her movies remain adored by fans.

16. Wes Brown

In the movies ‘Christmas at Graceland’ (2018) and ‘Wedding at Graceland’ (2019), Brown’s rugged appeal is clearly evident. His characters, typically grounded and occasionally featuring a Southern accent, seem genuine.

The relaxed atmosphere around him suits him perfectly for the charming narratives at Hallmark. I appreciate his adaptability, even if he’s not as productive as some others might be.

15. Alicia Witt

The captivating aura of Witt significantly enhances both ‘A Very Merry Mix-Up’ (2013) and ‘Christmas List’ (2016). Her innate charm makes her an ideal choice for festive romantic comedies.

I really appreciate how she combines cleverness and kindness, even though she’s only made nine Hallmark movies compared to others. She’s consistently charming, making her a true pleasure to watch.

14. Danica McKellar

Previously a renowned young actor, McKellar graced 16 Hallmark movies, among them ‘You, Me, & the Christmas Trees’ from 2021. The allure of the relatable neighbor was the essence of her character portrayals.

Her on-screen relationships with fellow actors make me eager to watch, yet transitioning to the GAC Family network seems to affect her popularity. She remains a beloved figure from the past.

13. Paul Campbell

In the 2022 Hallmark favorite, ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’, Campbell’s humor is brilliantly showcased. Not only does he star in it, but he also contributed to its scriptwriting, demonstrating his versatile artistic abilities.

As a film enthusiast, I can’t help but appreciate the charm of his character in those heartwarming holiday comedies. He brings an endearing goofiness to every role that truly sets him apart. Despite being relatively new to the scene compared to some other actors, his growing presence is undeniable and adds a fresh energy to any production.

12. Kristoffer Polaha

In the 2023 movie ‘A Biltmore Christmas’ and the 2016 film ‘The Dater’s Handbook’, Polaha’s enchanting charm from the Golden Era shines brightly. His characters seamlessly intertwine romance, depth, and frequently incorporate a historical element.

His acts have a movie-like quality that captivates me, and there’s something genuinely appealing about his radiant aura. Although he’s on the rise, he doesn’t have as many films under his belt compared to industry veterans.

11. Holly Robinson Peete

Peete, a dominant figure in Hollywood, appears in the 2021 film ‘Our Christmas Journey’ and frequently produces movies she’s involved in. Her emotional portrayals mirror her commitment to raising autism awareness.

I appreciate how she skillfully combines kindness and power. While her number of films might be limited, her role as an executive producer significantly enhances their impact.

10. Luke Macfarlane

Macfarlane’s fourteen movies, such as ‘Catch Me If You Claus’ from 2023, are filled with holiday magic. His endearing character shines through in ‘The Mistletoe Promise’, a film from 2016.

In the 2020 movie ‘Chateau Christmas’, his cello playing introduces an exceptional flair that I admire. His laid-back demeanor is appealing, even as he primarily focuses on Christmas narratives.

9. Niall Matter

The transformation of this individual, from an oil rig worker, to a star in Hallmark productions such as the ‘Aurora Teagarden Mysteries’ and ‘Christmas at Dollywood’ (2019), showcases his raw charm brilliantly.

I’m particularly attracted to his realistic acting, particularly in mystery genres. His wide range of characters adds to his appeal, even though he may not always be the main star.

8. Brennan Elliott

Elliott’s twenty movies, which include the ‘All of My Heart’ series, highlight his knack for comedy and charming good looks. He’s adored by fans in the 2023 movie, ‘Ms. Christmas Comes to Town’.

His ability to blend romance and humor consistently captivates me, making me eager to keep watching. Despite this, he hasn’t yet reached the very pinnacle of stardom.

7. Alison Sweeney

In a new twist, the ‘Murder, She Baked’ and ‘Hannah Swensen Mysteries’ movies introduce Alex McPherson as their main character. To keep things interesting, her romantic comedies such as ‘Open by Christmas’ (2021) offer a change of pace.

My preferred characters she portrays are detectives, showcasing both charisma and intelligence. Her extensive experience and adaptability place her in a top tier.

6. Ryan Paevey

Previously of ‘General Hospital’, Paevey appears in the 2016 film ‘Unleashing Mr. Darcy’ and the 2020 production ‘A Timeless Christmas’. His captivating blue eyes transform even his initial haughty personas.

He has an amazing ability to captivate crowds at the end, which is why he’s often considered a romantic lead in Hallmark movies, although his work is not as frequent compared to others.

5. Kimberly Williams-Paisley

In the productions ‘Darrow & Darrow’ and ‘The Christmas Train’ (2017), Reese Witherspoon truly excels. Her performances in these legal thrillers and holiday movies demonstrate her versatility as a compelling, quick-witted leading actress.

Her captivating acts hold my attention, particularly when it comes to mysteries. The increasing visibility she has on Hallmark solidifies her top position.

4. Kevin McGarry

McGarry’s talent is diverse, extending from series such as ‘When Calls the Heart’ to movies like ‘The Wedding Veil’ (2022). His charisma reminiscent of an ordinary man is evident in ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ (2022).

I find myself drawn to his convincing portrayals that resonate with me, and the undeniable chemistry he shares with his fellow actors. With an impressive career at Hallmark, he stands out as a strong candidate for leading roles.

3. Autumn Reeser

In ‘The O.C.’ fame, Reeser takes center stage in ‘The Wedding Veil’ (2022) and ‘A Bramble House Christmas’ (2017). Her lively and imaginative roles bring a sparkle to the screen.

Her early beginnings and wide range of roles have solidified her as a consistent figure in Hallmark productions. I genuinely appreciate her touching portrayals, even though she’s not quite at the very pinnacle yet.

2. Andrew W. Walker

Walker’s 27 movies, including ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ (2022), establish him as a king of Hallmark productions. His enterprising nature and charisma are evident in ‘Jingle Bell Run’ (2024).

The hilarious characters he plays and his steady stream of work have made him a beloved figure among fans. I find myself particularly captivated by his genuine charm, which often places him at the top.

1. Lacey Chabert

In a delightful twist, Chabert, having starred in 32 films such as ‘The Wedding Veil’ from 2022 and ‘All of My Heart’ in 2015, reigns supreme on Hallmark. Her warm allure graces both holiday and mystery genres with an undeniable charm.

Her unprecedented number of films and deep emotional range place her at the top. I adore how she perfectly captures the essence of Hallmark’s sentiment, whether in romantic comedies or thrillers.

2025-07-11 05:15