18 U.S. States File Against the Securities and Exchange Commission

by

As a seasoned crypto investor with over two decades of experience navigating the ever-evolving financial landscape, I find myself closely watching the legal challenge mounted against SEC Chair Gary Gensler and his commissioners. Having witnessed numerous regulatory shifts throughout my career, I can’t help but feel a sense of deja vu as this latest development unfolds.

The group headed by Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman argues that the Securities and Exchange Commission’s actions encroach on states’ authority to manage their respective economic domains, particularly in the fast-developing digital assets industry, and hinder innovation in this sector.

The lawsuit directly focuses on SEC Chair Gary Gensler and other commissioners, voicing disapproval of their assertive stance towards cryptocurrency companies. Under Gensler’s tenure, the SEC has started multiple enforcement cases against significant crypto players like Coinbase and Binance, claiming that numerous digital assets meet the criteria for securities, making them subject to federal securities regulations.

States contend that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is overreaching its regulatory authority with vague claims, as there’s insufficient congressional approval. They believe these actions disrupt established state-level regulations meant for consumer protection and economic development. The SEC’s approach is seen as a “regulatory takeover” that pushes some cryptocurrency companies towards hasty settlements or even foreign relocations.

DeFi Education Fund

As an analyst, I’ve decided to participate in this lawsuit along with other states, joining forces with the DeFi Education Fund – a prominent voice advocating for cryptocurrencies. This group has been vocal about its disagreement with the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) stance on digital assets, and they believe that the SEC’s enforcement-driven strategy fosters uncertainty and hinders the growth of decentralized financial technologies.

This court case underscores the ongoing discussion about what kind of regulatory system is best for cryptocurrencies within the United States. While the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) believes its actions are essential to safeguard investors and uphold market honesty, opponents claim that the agency’s methods are excessively aggressive and lack the needed clarity for the industry to prosper. The decision of this lawsuit could have substantial consequences for crypto regulation in the U.S., possibly altering the power distribution between federal and state authorities in managing the rapidly growing digital asset market.

Gensler’s Address, The Long Goodbye?

Last week at the Practising Law Institute’s 56th Annual Institute on Securities Regulation, Gensler addressed the audience, highlighting that when he joined in 2021, the Commission, under Chairman Jay Clayton, had already initiated around 80 actions against crypto market participants who were not adhering to basic road rules. This included the case involving Ripple.

Multiple courts have upheld our actions to safeguard investors’ interests by enforcing the law on securities offerings, regardless of their form. It’s important to note that not all assets fall under the category of securities. Previous SEC Chairman Clayton and I both stated that Bitcoin is not classified as a security, and the Commission has consistently treated Bitcoin as something other than a security.

Instead of concentrating solely on Bitcoin, Ether, and Stablecoins, we’ve been investigating a significant number of other digital assets – approximately 10,000 in total. Many of these have been classified as securities by courts. To give you an idea of the scale, this sector represents about $600 billion within the broader crypto market, which is less than 20% and less than 0.25% of the global capital markets.

Let me make two points.

Initially, entities that deal in selling securities to the general public must register themselves and provide accurate information to the public about their offerings.

Indeed, it appears that Gensler is bidding farewell as he expressed gratitude towards the SEC staff and his family for the privilege of serving them. Keep an eye out for future developments.

 

Read More

2024-11-17 13:44