‘Pathological Liar’: Nigel Lythgoe Denies Paula Abdul’s Assault Claims In New Legal Response To Lawsuit

by

As a dedicated follower of the entertainment industry with years of experience under my belt, I must say that this latest development between Nigel Lythgoe and Paula Abdul has left me quite perplexed. On one hand, we have Paula Abdul, a beloved figure in the music and dance world, who has bravely come forward with allegations of sexual assault against her former colleague and producer, Nigel Lythgoe. On the other hand, we have Mr. Lythgoe, who vehemently denies these charges, describing them as appalling lies.

As an ardent admirer putting this into my own words, let me share the news: Nigel Lythgoe, the esteemed TV producer, has forcefully refuted Paula Abdul’s accusations of sexual assault. In legal documents submitted on October 15, Lythgoe responded to Abdul’s amended complaint by branding her allegations as despicable lies.

As an ardent admirer putting words to my feelings, I can’t help but share the latest developments in the saga I’ve been following closely. Abdul, the ex-American Idol judge, has escalated her legal battle by enriching her amended complaint with fresh allegations against Lythgoe. She claims he assaulted her and her assistant back in 2015. In response to these serious charges, Lythgoe has labeled Abdul as a compulsive liar and someone who craves attention.

Initially, Abdul lodged a complaint alleging that Lythgoe had only attacked her assistant in April 2015. But in her updated filing, Abdul declared that she too was physically harmed by Lythgoe during the same event.

The recent complaint additionally offered further information about supposed events dating back to the early 2000s, a period during which they both appeared on American Idol, as well as in 2015 and 2016, when Abdul was engaged with So You Think You Can Dance.

In simpler terms, Lythgoe’s legal response raised doubts about when and specifically what Abdul was accusing him of. He pointed out that Abdul’s initial claim lacked clear details about the events in question, and suggested that Abdul’s recent allegations were a convenient way of remembering them.

The document implies it’s hard to believe that Abdul would suddenly recall being assaulted during the same event as her assistant, seeing as she hadn’t mentioned it earlier.

In his follow-up, Lythgoe cast doubt on Abdul’s trustworthiness by bringing up their professional and personal bond. He provided evidence such as emails, texts, and social media posts where Abdul purportedly conveyed warm sentiments towards him, both during the alleged incidents and afterwards.

In an email sent on June 20, 2014, it said, “Thank you for the lovely flowers… I value our friendship and am excited about starting our project.” In another message from June 9, 2015, Abdul is said to have congratulated Lythgoe on a professional success with the words, “I admire your courage!!!

Lythgoe responded, saying it was unthinkable that Abdul would remain friendly and affectionate if her claims were true. He also noted that Abdul was often accompanied by security while filming American Idol and So You Think You Can Dance, making such incidents difficult to occur without witnesses.

Lythgoe’s legal filing also accused Abdul of launching a tactical campaign to harm his reputation. He claimed Abdul was weaponizing the current climate to defame him, and the claims were part of a larger pattern of attention-seeking behavior.

The document stated that the allegations made by Abdul against Lythgoe were untrue, offensive, unacceptable, and potentially devastating, implying that Abdul was misusing the legal system for his own advantage.

Following the initial rejection of assault allegations by Lythgoe, Melissa Eubanks, Abdul’s attorney, alleged that Lythgoe had been victim-shaming. Eubanks argued that Lythgoe held a significant influence over Abdul due to his role as a producer on American Idol and So You Think You Can Dance, while Abdul was merely a talent in these shows.

Read More

2024-10-22 09:55