The S&P 500: A Modest Proposal

Stock Market Scene

Vanguard, that bastion of sensible investing, recently issued its forecast for the years ahead. It wasn’t a proclamation of boundless prosperity, let us say. More a quiet sigh, a resigned acceptance of… moderation. They foresee a return to something resembling normalcy, which, in the current climate, feels almost revolutionary. A mere 4 to 5 percent annually, they suggest, and attribute this dampened enthusiasm to the inflated egos – and valuations – of the large-cap technology companies. These titans, it seems, are not quite as immortal as their share prices would have us believe.

The concern, naturally, isn’t merely that these companies are expensive – though, dear reader, they are. It’s the specter of disruption, the inevitable arrival of newcomers eager to dismantle the established order. A most unpleasant business, this “creative destruction,” as the economists so blandly term it. It’s like watching a perfectly good samovar being smashed to make room for a… a microwave oven. Utterly barbaric, yet undeniably efficient.

Value stocks, small-caps, international markets… these are the realms where Vanguard sees a glimmer of hope. A rotation, they predict, away from the bloated giants and towards more… discreet opportunities. It’s a sensible suggestion, of course, but one wonders if the herd will listen. They rarely do, preferring instead to stampede off the cliff, bleating about “growth” and “disruption.”

The Decade of Diminished Expectations

Vanguard’s assessment, while prudent, is not an isolated one. Goldman Sachs, with the grim predictability of a tax collector, has declared the next decade a “dead one,” anticipating a meager 3 percent return. Charles Schwab, ever the optimist, offers a slightly more generous 5.9 percent, while JPMorgan Chase predicts 6.7 percent. The consensus, it seems, is that the recent bonanza is over. The party, as they say, is winding down.

Loading widget...

Consider this: the S&P 500 averaged a rather extravagant 12.9 percent annually over the past decade. But rewind just ten years before that, and the average drops to a far more modest 5 percent. The market, you see, is a fickle mistress. She grants favors generously one moment, then snatches them away with a cruel smile the next.

Should You Embrace the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF?

One could argue that an ETF tracking the 500 largest U.S. companies should be a cornerstone of any portfolio. The Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF, the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF… they are all, in essence, variations on the same theme. Reliable, predictable, and… well, rather dull. But then, stability is a virtue, particularly in these chaotic times.

However, to assume that past performance guarantees future results would be a folly worthy of Master and Margarita. The leading investment houses foresee lower returns for U.S. large caps, and it would be unwise to ignore their warnings. A sensible strategy, therefore, would be to maintain a core holding in a broad market ETF, but to diversify more aggressively than in the past. Consider adding a value ETF, as well as exposure to international and emerging markets. Perhaps even a small allocation to something… unconventional. A vineyard in Moldova, perhaps? Or a collection of antique samovars? One must, after all, have some amusement in this absurd existence.

The market, dear reader, is a labyrinth. And the only certainty is that, sooner or later, we will all get lost.

Read More

2026-03-23 20:02