Emilia Clarke Prefers ‘The Lord of the Rings’ Over ‘Harry Potter,’ and the Fans Are Going Crazy About It

As a die-hard fan of both epic franchises, I’ve spent countless hours immersed in the magical worlds of Middle Earth and Hogwarts, each offering me a unique and captivating journey. The debate between which is superior has been an ongoing battle since their initial releases, and it’s one that I’ve personally enjoyed watching unfold from the sidelines.


Despite having little in common and debuting at roughly the same time, both “The Lord of the Rings” and “Harry Potter” series gained massive popularity. This overlap in timing sparked intense discussions among fans about which one was superior, a debate that may have cooled somewhat over the years but remains significant.

In a past conversation, the actress who starred in both “Game of Thrones” and “Star Wars”, Emilia Clarke, expressed her stance on this issue, aligning herself with one particular viewpoint.

Indeed, these comments ignited a lively discussion among internet users, particularly on Reddit, where they’re dissecting her statements and examining the broader implications of the franchises collectively. Consequently, we are sharing updates and unveiling further insights about this topic to keep you informed.

Back in the day, I stumbled upon an intriguing Reddit discussion that’s stood the test of time. It’s so captivating that I can’t help but share some insights with you on its origins: here’s a sneak peek into its fascinating beginning.

She’s one of us
byu/patthepatriot2020 inlotrmemes

Regarding its origin, the material stemmed from a past interview conducted by Collider Ladies Night during Clarke’s promotion for her Terminator movie. This conversation was published approximately eight years ago, and for the complete account, you can find it here:

What interests us is what the fans had to say about Clarke’s answer and here are some of the comments from the original Reddit thread:

Allow me to clarify. I didn’t care for Harry Potter as it seemed like a weak imitation of The Lord of the Rings to me. I was at an awkward, rebellious teenage stage when those books first came out. To me, they appeared to be trendy and unoriginal. Terms such as “Hufflepuff” and “Dumbledore” didn’t help my perception.

As I’ve grown older, I appreciate its charm more. I’ve yet to encounter a diehard Harry Potter fan who turned out to be a real jerk.

– SmashBusters

In her latest interview, it was revealed that Khaleesi has recently rediscovered the Harry Potter series and developed quite a fascination for them. It’s clear to see that these books have captured her heart, as her passion for them is evident! Indeed, she now counts herself among their admirers.

– flou14

Just like countless others, I can’t help but compare Harry Potter to Lord of the Rings when it comes to world-building. However, let me clarify that this doesn’t diminish the charm or intrigue of the Harry Potter universe. It’s simply a testament to how exceptional J.R.R. Tolkien’s work is in this regard. Yet, what I admire most about Harry Potter isn’t its world-building or lore, but rather the masterful way J.K. Rowling wove seven separate books into one captivating narrative. Each book had its unique flavor while maintaining the essence of the Harry Potter experience. In my opinion, Rowling crafted a children’s epic that was not only engaging but also concluded in a way that left me deeply satisfied.

Each series has its ups and downs when it comes to reader preference, and Harry Potter is no exception. However, what makes Harry Potter unique among other popular book/movie series is that J.K. Rowling successfully crafted a cohesive and satisfying story spanning seven books, each of which stands well on its own. This doesn’t diminish the greatness of works like The Lord of the Rings by Tolkien, which is objectively of higher quality in many aspects. Nevertheless, Harry Potter has earned its place as a noteworthy series with good reason, and it will undoubtedly continue to gain classic status as time goes on.

LOTR FTW FOREVER THO

– kurapikachu64

Read More

2024-08-28 17:44