Six Flags: A North American Tragedy

by

The prevailing notion that one might ‘beat the market’ is, of course, a persistent folly. Most sensible souls content themselves with mirroring the S&P 500, a task readily accomplished with a minimum of exertion and a gratifying lack of independent thought. To aspire to anything more is to invite disappointment, and, more importantly, to attract the attention of those who profit from such misplaced ambition.

Turning, with a degree of trepidation, to the leisure industry, we find Six Flags Entertainment (FUN 9.07%) in a state best described as advanced disrepair. The share price, one observes, has suffered a decline commensurate with a minor geopolitical catastrophe. The question, therefore, is not whether this represents a ‘value opportunity’ – a phrase which should always be uttered with a distinct air of desperation – but rather, whether a determined plunge into the abyss might, at least, be briefly diverting.

A closer inspection, as always, is required, though one approaches it with the same enthusiasm as a dentist approaches a particularly stubborn molar.

The Underlying Business

The recent amalgamation with Cedar Fair has resulted in an entity claiming the title of North America’s largest theme park operator. A distinction, one suspects, more alarming than impressive. The portfolio comprises 26 amusement parks, 15 water parks, and nine resorts – a veritable empire of manufactured gaiety.

Naturally, the company’s fortunes are inextricably linked to the American economy, and, by extension, the prevailing mood of the American consumer. High prices and a sluggish employment market do not, as a general rule, encourage extravagant spending on simulated thrills. This, undoubtedly, has contributed to the recent downturn, though one suspects a degree of managerial incompetence may also be at play.

The seasonal nature of the business is, of course, self-evident. The majority of revenue is generated during the warmer months, leaving the remainder of the year to be endured with a stoic resignation. Approximately 70% of the annual income materializes in the second and third quarters – a fleeting period of prosperity before the inevitable decline.

The third-quarter revenue, we are informed, fell by 2.3% to $1.3 billion. Attendance, inexplicably, increased slightly, while spending per attendee diminished by 3.6%. A curious paradox, suggesting that more people are willing to endure the ordeal at a reduced cost. Both admissions and in-park spending declined – a double blow, and a rather damning indictment of the entire enterprise.

The fourth quarter results, predictably, offer little cause for optimism. Variations in operating days complicate the comparison, but revenue per day increased by 7%, offset by a 2% decline in attendance and a marginal increase in spending. Such nuances, however, are largely irrelevant in the face of the broader, and rather gloomy, picture.

Market Beater or Laggard?

Management, with the unwavering optimism characteristic of those in their position, has outlined a plan to revive operations and stimulate growth. The strategy involves a focus on the ‘guest experience,’ the introduction of new rides (presumably designed to induce nausea), and a revamped marketing campaign. An attempt will also be made to increase spending through pricing initiatives and improved food and beverage offerings – a noble, if somewhat naive, ambition.

Expense reduction is, naturally, also on the agenda, though the other initiatives will require time – and, one suspects, a considerable amount of luck. Meanwhile, Six Flags faces stiff competition from a multitude of alternative entertainment venues – a fact which, one imagines, causes considerable consternation in the executive suite.

The share price, as one might expect, reflects the current predicament and the anticipated challenges. Over the past year, the stock has plummeted by 62.6%, while the S&P 500 has enjoyed a respectable gain of 13.7%. A rather stark contrast, and a cautionary tale for those who believe in the power of positive thinking.

Loading widget...

The company, having reported a loss under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), renders the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio meaningless. The price-to-sales (P/S) ratio, however, offers a glimmer of hope, currently standing at 0.6, down from 1.3 a year ago. This is, admittedly, a fraction of the S&P 500’s P/S ratio of 3.4.

The valuation appears attractive, at least on paper, and relative to the broader market. However, given Six Flags’ difficulties in achieving sustained sales growth, one concludes that beating the S&P 500 over the long term remains, to put it mildly, an uphill battle. A rather forlorn prospect, and one best viewed from a safe distance.

Read More

2026-02-24 02:12