Black Actors Who Auditioned for One Role But Ended Up Creating a More Iconic Character

by

Landing a role in Hollywood is rarely straightforward. Actors often prepare for one part, but directors sometimes see potential for something different, leading to iconic performances we remember today. For many Black male actors, this unexpected shift in direction led to them becoming cultural icons. This article shares the fascinating stories of performers who achieved legendary status after their careers took an unexpected turn.

Chadwick Boseman

Chadwick Boseman first auditioned for the role of Drax in ‘Guardians of the Galaxy,’ but didn’t get the part. However, the casting directors were very impressed with him and remembered him for other opportunities. This led to him being cast as T’Challa in ‘Captain America: Civil War,’ which eventually led to his iconic role as Black Panther. He became a worldwide symbol of strength and dignity, and his performance as the king of Wakanda is considered a landmark achievement in superhero films.

Isaiah Washington

Isaiah Washington initially auditioned for the part of Derek Shepherd on ‘Grey’s Anatomy’. Although he wasn’t chosen for that role, the show’s producers liked him and offered him the part of Preston Burke instead. Burke, a highly skilled and challenging heart surgeon, quickly became a key character, especially through his complicated and emotionally charged relationship with Cristina Yang in the show’s early seasons.

Anthony Mackie

Anthony Mackie really wanted to play a villain, like the Mandarin in ‘Iron Man 3’, and let Marvel Studios know. While the producers didn’t think he was right for that role, they were impressed with his enthusiasm for the Marvel universe. They ended up casting him as Sam Wilson, also known as the Falcon, who he first played in ‘Captain America: The Winter Soldier’. Eventually, he took on the role of Captain America, creating a significant and lasting impact on the cinematic universe.

Lance Reddick

I always found Lance Reddick captivating, and it’s fascinating to learn he initially auditioned for roles like Bubbles and Bunk on ‘The Wire’! The show’s creators clearly saw something special in him – a commanding presence – and smartly steered him towards playing a figure of authority. Casting him as Lieutenant Cedric Daniels was genius. He brought such a grounded, dignified weight to the role, which was essential amidst the chaos of the Baltimore drug world. Honestly, looking back, his performance as Daniels remains one of the most consistently strong and memorable parts of the entire series.

Wood Harris

During the early stages of ‘The Wire,’ Wood Harris auditioned for the roles of Bubbles and Cedric Daniels. However, the show’s creators saw he was better suited for a different character. He ultimately landed the part of Avon Barksdale, the powerful and dangerous leader of a major drug operation. Harris’s performance as Barksdale was incredibly impactful, fueling much of the show’s conflict in its first few seasons, and the character has become iconic in television history.

Jamie Hector

Jamie Hector originally tried out for the role of Cutty on ‘The Wire,’ a former soldier adjusting to life after service. Though he didn’t get that part, the casting directors were impressed by his intense and controlled presence. He was later chosen to play Marlo Stanfield, a ruthless and ambitious drug lord determined to control the city. Hector’s performance was remarkably effective and changed how villains were depicted on television. Marlo’s climb to power became a central and captivating storyline in the show’s later seasons.

Seth Gilliam

Seth Gilliam didn’t immediately find his way onto ‘The Wire.’ He auditioned for different parts over several seasons until producers discovered the ideal role for him: Sergeant Ellis Carver. Gilliam brilliantly portrayed Carver’s development from a flawed officer into a strong and committed leader, earning praise from both viewers and critics. This performance established him as a skilled and dependable actor in intense dramatic series.

J.D. Williams

As a huge ‘The Wire’ fan, I always found it fascinating to learn that J.D. Williams initially tried out for the part of Poot Carr. The creators clearly saw something special in him, though, and wisely decided to cast him as Bodie Broadus instead. Bodie was one of the few characters who stuck around for almost the entire series, and his story – a really heartbreaking mix of loyalty and just trying to survive – always resonated with me. J.D. Williams brought this incredible street smartness to the role, but also a quiet vulnerability that made Bodie so relatable. Honestly, even now, people still talk about how emotionally impactful his ending was – it’s one of those moments that really stays with you.

Andre Royo

Andre Royo had a tough audition for ‘The Wire,’ trying out for multiple parts. The show’s creators wanted an actor who could portray both funny and heartbreaking qualities. They eventually chose him to play Bubbles, a homeless man battling addiction who helps the police. Royo was so believable in the role that someone once actually offered him drugs, mistaking him for a person genuinely in need. He transformed what was initially a smaller part into a deeply moving and unforgettable portrayal of hardship.

Giancarlo Esposito

Giancarlo Esposito initially joined ‘Breaking Bad’ for a brief role. The character of Gustavo Fring wasn’t planned to be a major, long-term villain. But the show’s creators were so impressed by Esposito’s cool and composed performance that they greatly expanded the part. He turned a seemingly ordinary restaurant owner into one of television’s most terrifying villains, and his performance was key to the show’s increasing suspense and psychological complexity.

Craig Robinson

Craig Robinson initially auditioned for a minor role on the American version of ‘The Office’. The character of Darryl Philbin wasn’t originally a major part of the show. However, Robinson’s talent for comedy and his understated humor quickly impressed the producers. They started giving him more screen time, and he was eventually made a main cast member. He became a vital part of the show, offering a realistic perspective that balanced out the quirky behavior of the office staff.

Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje

When Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje initially auditioned for ‘Lost’, he was considered for a different part. However, the show’s creators realized he had the strong presence they needed for season two and cast him as Mr. Eko. Eko, a former warlord searching for forgiveness through religion, quickly became a fan favorite and a compelling character within the show’s overall story. Akinnuoye-Agbaje played the role with a remarkable intensity and a powerful physical demeanor.

Terry Crews

When ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’ was first being developed, Terry Crews wasn’t meant to be a main character – he was initially considered for a small, background role. However, the show’s creators were so impressed with his personality and physique that they created the character of Terry Jeffords just for him. Jeffords became a strong, family-oriented sergeant with a love for yogurt, and allowed Crews to display his comedic talents like never before. He quickly became a fan favorite and a central figure in the show’s police precinct.

Mahershala Ali

Mahershala Ali initially auditioned for a minor part on ‘House of Cards’, intended for just a few episodes. However, his portrayal of lobbyist Remy Danton was so impressive that the show’s writers expanded his role, making him a significant character throughout several seasons. This part proved to be a breakthrough for Ali, demonstrating his talent for playing nuanced and driven characters, and ultimately helped propel him to win multiple Academy Awards for his film work.

Bokeem Woodbine

Bokeem Woodbine originally tried out for a different role on the second season of ‘Fargo’. However, the show’s creators were immediately impressed by his natural charm and how effortlessly he delivered the show’s distinctive lines. They then cast him as Mike Milligan, a stylish and thoughtful hitman. Woodbine quickly became the season’s most popular actor, captivating audiences in every scene. Many fans still consider his performance one of the best in the entire ‘Fargo’ series.

Orlando Jones

Orlando Jones originally auditioned for a different role in the ‘American Gods’ TV series. However, the show’s creators recognized his talent and asked him to play the captivating character of Mr. Nancy. This character is based on Anansi, a lively and mischievous god from West African folklore, and needed an actor with a lot of energy and flair. Jones powerfully delivered several monologues exploring issues of racial inequality and historical events. His performance became a highlight of the show and resonated deeply with viewers.

David Harewood

David Harewood initially believed he was playing Hank Henshaw when he joined ‘Supergirl.’ However, the producers surprised him during filming of the pilot episode by revealing his character was actually Martian Manhunter in disguise. This unexpected twist dramatically altered his performance and his character’s place in the series. Harewood had to portray both a reserved government agent and a deeply emotional alien refugee, and his ability to balance these two sides became a highlight of the show’s many seasons.

Sterling K. Brown

Sterling K. Brown first tried out for a different part in ‘The People v. O. J. Simpson’, but the show’s creators realized he was ideal for the role of prosecutor Christopher Darden. He received a lot of praise for his realistic depiction of the stress Darden experienced during the trial, and the performance won him an Emmy Award, launching him to fame as a standout actor. He continued his success with a starring role in the popular series ‘This Is Us’.

Ron Cephas Jones

Ron Cephas Jones initially tried out for a minor role on ‘This Is Us’ but quickly impressed the show’s creators. They were searching for someone to portray William Hill with a sense of a difficult past and deep sorrow, and Jones was a perfect fit. He instantly connected with the other actors, and his story of reconnecting with his son became a central, emotional part of the first season. His sensitive and layered performance earned him widespread critical acclaim and several awards.

Leslie Odom Jr.

Leslie Odom Jr. helped develop the musical ‘Hamilton’ from its earliest stages, trying out for various roles. He ultimately played Aaron Burr, the show’s main rival and storyteller. His portrayal of Burr, full of both drive and sadness, perfectly contrasted with the character of Hamilton. This performance won him a Tony Award and made him a highly respected actor on stage and screen. Today, his interpretation of Burr is widely considered the most iconic version of the historical figure.

Daveed Diggs

I remember when Daveed Diggs auditioned for ‘Hamilton’ – it was amazing! He didn’t even know which roles he’d be up for at first. But the creators quickly realized how incredibly fast he was as a rapper and how much charisma he brought to the stage. They ended up giving him two parts: the Marquis de Lafayette in Act One and then Thomas Jefferson in Act Two. It was a brilliant move because it really let him show off his versatility, and it quickly became one of the most talked-about aspects of the show. He deservedly won a Tony, and it launched a fantastic career for him in TV and film – I’ve been following his work ever since!

Christopher Jackson

Christopher Jackson and Lin-Manuel Miranda had worked together for years before Jackson auditioned for the musical ‘Hamilton’. He eventually landed the role of George Washington, a part that demanded both vocal strength and a strong stage presence. Jackson’s portrayal of Washington brought a relatable and serious quality to the character, balancing the show’s energetic style. His performance of ‘One Last Time’ is now considered a classic moment in musical theater. Since ‘Hamilton’, Jackson has become a well-known figure on Broadway and in film and television.

Okieriete Onaodowan

Okieriete Onaodowan initially auditioned for several roles in the popular musical ‘Hamilton’ and eventually landed the parts of Hercules Mulligan and James Madison. He skillfully portrayed both the energetic, rapping revolutionary spy Mulligan and the more subdued fourth U.S. President, Madison. These performances brought him national attention and opened doors to significant roles in shows like ‘Station 19’. He’s well-known for his commanding stage presence and versatility in both comedic and dramatic acting.

Winston Duke

When Winston Duke auditioned for ‘Black Panther,’ he didn’t know much about the character he was trying out for. He gave such a strong performance that the director realized he was perfect for the role of M’Baku, the leader of the Jabari Tribe. Originally, M’Baku was meant to be a smaller role, but Duke’s charm and powerful presence made him memorable in every scene. The character quickly became a fan favorite, known for his funny lines and unwavering dedication to his tribe. This role launched Duke’s career, leading to appearances in other big films and making him a well-known actor.

Tim Russ

I remember when Tim Russ first tried out for ‘Star Trek: The Next Generation’ back in the late eighties – he auditioned to be Geordi La Forge! While he didn’t get that role, everyone involved really took notice of him. It was amazing to see him come back a few years later as Tuvok on ‘Voyager’. He totally nailed the Vulcan character, staying true to their logical side but also making Tuvok uniquely his own. He quickly became a really well-known face in science fiction, and for good reason!

Tony Todd

Tony Todd originally tried out for the main role of Benjamin Sisko on ‘Star Trek: Deep Space Nine,’ but didn’t get the part. However, the show creators were so impressed with him that they repeatedly cast him in important guest roles. He famously played Kurn, Worf’s brother, and a grown-up Jake Sisko in a particularly well-regarded episode. His powerful voice and commanding presence made him ideal for playing Klingon characters. Over time, Tony Todd has become a celebrated figure in both horror and science fiction, known for his many unforgettable performances.

Michael Dorn

Michael Dorn didn’t get the role of Worf on ‘Star Trek: The Next Generation’ right away – he auditioned for other parts first. Worf wasn’t initially intended to be a major character, but Dorn’s strong performance quickly made him a fan favorite and a key part of the show. He played Worf for seven seasons and in multiple movies, and later continued the role on ‘Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’. Dorn is the actor who has appeared in the most ‘Star Trek’ episodes ever, and his performance as Worf significantly shaped how Klingons are seen in the franchise.

J. August Richards

J. August Richards originally auditioned for a small part as a demon on the show ‘Angel.’ However, the show’s creators were so impressed with his performance that they wrote a brand-new character just for him. He ended up playing Charles Gunn, a resourceful vampire hunter who later became a key member of the investigative team. Richards brought both emotional depth and physical energy to the role over the show’s run, and he remains a fan favorite. He’s continued to work consistently in television since then.

Charles Michael Davis

Charles Michael Davis initially tried out for various parts on ‘The Vampire Diaries’ but didn’t land any of them. Luckily, he didn’t give up. When the network started developing a spin-off called ‘The Originals,’ he was cast as Marcel Gerard, the captivating and strong leader of the New Orleans vampire community. Davis’s portrayal of Marcel, blending both charisma and a threatening edge, made him a memorable adversary to the show’s central characters. This role ultimately became his most famous performance and established him as a prominent figure in supernatural television.

Sinqua Walls

When Sinqua Walls first auditioned for ‘Teen Wolf’, he actually tried out for a different part. The show’s creators felt he was perfect for Vernon Boyd – a quiet, unassuming teen who transforms into a strong werewolf. Walls played Boyd with a subtle power that deeply resonated with viewers. Even though he wasn’t on the show for long, he made a memorable impression on both the story and the fans. Since then, he’s become a leading actor in several successful TV shows and movies across different genres.

Khary Payton

Khary Payton didn’t get the part on ‘The Walking Dead’ right away – he actually auditioned for several roles before landing the part of King Ezekiel in season seven. The role needed someone who could convincingly play both a proud, dramatic king and a survivor in a brutal zombie world. Luckily, Payton’s experience with voice acting allowed him to nail Ezekiel’s distinctive way of speaking while still delivering a realistic and moving performance. Ezekiel quickly became a key character, offering a beacon of hope to the other survivors, and his portrayal of the king – especially his relationship with his tiger, Shiva – is remembered as one of the show’s best parts.

Lawrence Gilliard Jr.

I remember when Lawrence Gilliard Jr. auditioned for ‘The Walking Dead’ – he was already a really experienced actor! They actually thought of him for a different role at first, but then the creators realized he was perfect as Bob Stookey. Bob was such a complex character, a former medic haunted by his past and battling addiction while trying to survive the apocalypse. Lawrence really brought something special to the role; even in that dark world, he managed to make Bob hopeful and relatable. He made him someone you really rooted for, and I think that’s why so many of us connected with Bob during his time on the show.

Chad L. Coleman

I’ll never forget when Chad L. Coleman finally landed the role of Tyreese in ‘The Walking Dead’ – he actually auditioned for a few different parts first! It was such a perfect fit, because Tyreese was already a beloved character from the comics, and the showrunners needed someone who could really embody both his strength and his kindness. Chad absolutely nailed it; he showed us this incredibly complex man who was tormented by the violence around him, even though he was forced to participate. His performance was so moving and really deepened the emotional impact of the whole group’s fight to survive. He quickly became a standout and earned so much respect from everyone involved in the show.

Tyler James Williams

Before landing the role of Noah on ‘The Walking Dead,’ Tyler James Williams actually auditioned for a different part in the show’s fifth season. Noah was a young man rescued from a hospital who then joined the core group of survivors. Williams’ performance brought a lot of energy and strength to the character, making his storyline memorable. Although he was only on the show for a short time, Noah had a significant impact on the development of other characters. Williams has since become a lead actor in the popular comedy series ‘Abbott Elementary.’

Corey Hawkins

As Corey Hawkins’ film career started gaining momentum, he auditioned for multiple parts on ‘The Walking Dead.’ He ultimately landed the role of Heath, a resourceful character from the Alexandria Safe Zone who was well-known in the comic books. Hawkins’ portrayal brought a cool, confident vibe to the character, quickly making him popular with viewers. Though Heath eventually left the show, the performance helped establish Hawkins as an up-and-coming actor. Since then, he’s starred in both big-budget blockbusters and highly praised dramatic projects.

Kenric Green

I have to say, Kenric Green really made an impact as Scott on ‘The Walking Dead.’ It’s interesting to learn he actually auditioned for a few different parts before landing the role! Scott quickly became a solid member of the Alexandria community – a dependable soldier and someone you knew the main characters could always count on. It probably helped that he was married to another cast member, making him feel like part of the family from the start. He was a consistent presence for many seasons, and what I appreciated most was how he made even a supporting role feel absolutely vital to the story. He’s one of those actors who elevates everything around him, and I think that’s why audiences connected with Scott so strongly.

Idris Elba

Idris Elba didn’t originally audition for the role of Stringer Bell in ‘The Wire,’ but the show’s creators quickly realized he was a perfect fit. To land the part of the Baltimore drug kingpin, the British actor had to conceal his accent during auditions. His performance as the cool, calculating second-in-command became a television classic, launching his career in the United States and leading to international fame. Today, he’s a highly recognizable and respected actor in the film industry.

Gbenga Akinnagbe

Gbenga Akinnagbe initially joined the show ‘The Wire’ with a minor role in its third season. However, his compelling performance and ability to portray a dangerous, yet controlled character impressed the writers, who subsequently expanded his part. He ultimately became Chris Partlow, the main muscle for the Stanfield crew. Akinnagbe’s chillingly calm and professional portrayal made him a truly frightening villain, and he became a regular cast member for the remainder of the series.

Colman Domingo

I remember when Colman Domingo first auditioned for ‘Fear the Walking Dead’ – it wasn’t even for the role he ultimately became famous for! The producers were instantly captivated by his incredible presence and energy, so they made a brilliant decision and cast him as Victor Strand. Strand quickly became one of the most fascinating characters in the whole ‘Walking Dead’ universe, and Colman just owned that role. He was so good, in fact, that he eventually became a lead actor and even started directing episodes! It’s no surprise he’s gotten so much recognition and award nominations for his work since then – he’s truly a phenomenal talent.

Michael Kenneth Williams

Michael K. Williams initially tried out for a minor role on ‘The Wire,’ but the show’s creators quickly recognized his talent and potential. He was then cast as Omar Little, a complex and compelling stickup man with his own strong sense of right and wrong. Williams transformed what could have been a typical character into someone incredibly nuanced and memorable. Omar Little became one of the most popular and talked-about characters in television history, and the performance cemented Williams’s reputation as a truly exceptional actor.

Lennie James

Lennie James originally tried out for a different part in ‘The Walking Dead’ pilot. However, the director was so impressed with his audition that he was cast as Morgan Jones – the first person Rick Grimes encounters after the world falls apart. Even though Morgan only appeared in a few episodes at first, he made a big impression on viewers who quickly wanted to see more of him. James eventually became a main cast member and even starred in his own spin-off show. Many fans and critics consider his performance as a man battling inner demons and moral dilemmas to be one of the best in the entire series.

Tell us which of these iconic casting shifts surprised you the most in the comments.

Read More

2026-02-22 19:20