Global Stock Market Chaos Looms as Japanese Yen Carry Trade Unravels, Warns Peter Schiff

by

As a seasoned analyst with over two decades of experience in financial markets and economics, I have witnessed numerous shifts and transformations in global economies. Having closely followed the career of Peter Schiff, who shares my skepticism towards fiat currencies and central bank policies, I find his latest analysis on the unwinding of the yen carry trade particularly insightful.

SchiffGold is a business that deals in precious metals such as gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. It primarily serves investors who are interested in purchasing physical precious metals to protect their assets from potential economic instability and inflation. The company offers various services, including direct sales, secure storage options, and guidance on investing in precious metals. SchiffGold advocates for owning actual precious metals over paper assets, a viewpoint that aligns with Peter Schiff’s broader economic perspective and his cautious stance on fiat currencies.

Peter Schiff is a highly regarded economist, financial analyst, and investment consultant. He serves as the CEO of Euro Pacific Capital, a brokerage company, and established SchiffGold. Known for his skeptical perspective on economic policies, particularly those relating to central banks and paper currencies, Schiff is often seen on TV and radio, sharing his perspectives on market movements, economic events, and investment plans. Additionally, he has written multiple books focusing on economics and finance.

In early 2021, Schiff examined the possible consequences of ending the yen carry trade due to the Bank of Japan’s decision to discontinue its long-standing zero-interest rate policy (ZIRP). As stated in a blog post published on the SchiffGold website on August 3, this forecast is becoming a reality.

If you’re not familiar with the term ZIRP, it refers to a monetary policy tactic employed by central banks. This strategy involves lowering or even setting interest rates at zero in order to stimulate economic growth. By doing so, borrowing costs for businesses and individuals decrease, which in turn encourages spending and investment, ultimately boosting the economy. This approach is often implemented during periods of economic decline, like downturns or recessions, to increase consumer demand and ward off deflation. But it’s important to note that prolonged use of ZIRP can introduce financial risks, such as the formation of asset bubbles and diminished savings returns.

Based on a Reuters report, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) increased interest rates to their highest point in 15 years on July 31. The BOJ also unveiled a broad plan to decrease its significant bond purchases. This move signifies a major departure from a decade of heavy stimulus. The rate increase was more substantial than anticipated, as it was the largest since 2007 and came after the conclusion of an eight-year period with negative interest rates. Following a two-day meeting, the BOJ’s board voted 7-2 to lift the overnight call rate target from 0-0.1% to 0.25%, making the short-term policy rate its highest since 2008.

As a crypto investor, I’ve been considering the yen carry trade strategy – essentially borrowing yen at low-interest rates to invest in higher-yielding assets like T-bills and stocks. In the past, Japan’s nearly zero-interest rates made yen borrowing extremely appealing. However, I’ve noticed that as Japan starts to raise its interest rates while other countries are lowering or have already lowered theirs, the appeal of this trade is gradually decreasing. It seems the landscape for this strategy might be shifting.

As an analyst, I’ve noticed a trend among investors: they’re offloading their yen holdings due to the loss of nearly interest-free borrowing, which in turn has heightened volatility within the currency market. Schiff, another analyst, emphasizes that since the Bank of Japan (BoJ) ended Zero Interest Rate Policy (ZIRP), the yen has seen substantial fluctuations, despite repeated attempts to stabilize it.

According to Schiff’s perspective, even though the carry trade could continue as long as U.S. interest rates stay higher than Japan’s, the projected rate decreases from the Federal Reserve this year and the Bank of Japan’s tendency towards additional increases increase the risks, making the trade less enticing.

As per Schiff’s analysis, unlike many other countries that are lowering interest rates due to high inflation, Japan stands out. Central banks in Canada, Switzerland, Sweden, China, Mexico, Brazil, and the UK are reducing rates, but Japan is keeping its rates higher. Schiff points out that the Bank of Japan’s recent actions have caused the yen to appreciate by 8% against the dollar, as it had reached its weakest exchange rate in 38 years. Higher interest rates in Japan make yen-based investments more appealing, according to Schiff, but as the traditional carry trade is phased out, it could lead to a “reverse carry trade” scenario instead.

Schiff explains that a reverse carry trade involves borrowing Japanese yen to purchase currencies or investments with lower returns. The idea is that the yen will depreciate in value. When this happens, traders can convert their assets back into yen at a reduced cost, earning profits from both the difference in interest rates and the decrease in the value of the yen.

As an analyst, I’m sounding the alarm about the potential far-reaching effects of the current situation on international markets. Volatility in the yen could destabilize leveraged positions, possibly leading to margin calls and a broader market sell-off, as I’ve observed. This risk becomes even more pronounced if yen appreciation causes commodity prices, like oil, to rise, necessitating more Bank of Japan interventions and further unraveling of the carry trade. Such a chain of events could snowball into a significant global market disruption, a scenario I believe we should all be mindful of.

Schiff points out that Japanese stocks have experienced significant volatility recently, with the Nikkei 225 dropping significantly from its recent record high to levels not seen since January, and the Topix index losing more than 9% in just two days. This sharp decline, the biggest since the 2011 Fukushima disaster, indicates domestic unease as Japan grapples with rising interest rates and potential Fed rate cuts later in the year, Schiff notes. These factors could potentially boost the value of the yen compared to the dollar, possibly leading to a complete reversal of the carry trade, as per Schiff’s analysis.

According to Schiff, the yen carry trade, historically, has fueled global bull markets by making it possible to borrow money at low rates to invest elsewhere. If this trend is reversed or ‘unwound’, it could potentially cause increased volatility in stock markets beyond Japan, as per Schiff’s analysis. The Bank of Japan (BoJ) is currently grappling with a tough decision: whether to safeguard the yen, maintain market stability, or bolster government bonds, which they own approximately half of, as Schiff points out. In terms described by Schiff as a monetary and economic cycle that feeds on itself, the BoJ finds themselves without easy solutions for this dilemma.

In a similar vein, Schiff points out that central banks such as the Federal Reserve find themselves in a challenging situation, attempting to address banking and real estate crises by reducing interest rates while dealing with ongoing inflation. Schiff compares the financial system to a powder keg, suggesting that the only unknown factor is who will initially set off the explosion.

Read More

2024-08-05 00:51