Black Actors Who Made History by Playing Characters Originally Written as White

The way actors are chosen for movies and TV shows is changing. Filmmakers are now focusing more on finding the best talent and ensuring diverse representation, rather than strictly following how characters were originally described. We’ve seen incredible performances by Black actors in iconic roles – characters that were once typically portrayed as white in the source material, like comic books, novels, or historical accounts. These actors are challenging old industry standards and bringing new life to familiar stories. This list celebrates the talented men who have broken down barriers by taking on these legendary parts.

Samuel L. Jackson

Samuel L. Jackson has become synonymous with Nick Fury, a role he first played in the 2008 film ‘Iron Man’ as part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Interestingly, the original Nick Fury in the Marvel comics was a white man. Jackson’s portrayal was inspired by a different version of the character from the ‘Ultimate Marvel’ comics, which was specifically designed to look like him. His performance was so popular and definitive that he’s now considered the main version of Nick Fury in all things Marvel, bringing a unique blend of coolness, power, and intrigue to the head of SHIELD.

Morgan Freeman

Morgan Freeman famously played Ellis Boyd Redding in the 1994 film ‘The Shawshank Redemption,’ which was adapted from a story by Stephen King. Originally, the character was depicted as a redheaded Irishman, but the filmmakers kept the nickname ‘Red’ and cast Freeman for his powerful and dignified presence. His performance was critically acclaimed, earning him an Academy Award nomination and is often cited as one of the best supporting roles ever filmed. He brought a sense of wisdom and depth to the movie, providing a strong emotional center.

Michael Clarke Duncan

Michael Clarke Duncan famously played Wilson Fisk, the Kingpin, in the 2003 film ‘Daredevil’. Originally depicted as a white character in Marvel comics, Duncan brought a powerful presence to the role, requiring him to maintain a large physique. His performance successfully conveyed the villain’s threat and strength, and was groundbreaking for superhero movie casting. This role showcased his range as an actor, proving he could convincingly play both kind, large characters and frightening villains.

Will Smith

Will Smith became a global superstar through roles like Agent J in ‘Men in Black’ and Robert Neville in ‘I Am Legend’. Interestingly, both of these characters were originally written as white in the source material – a comic book and a novel, respectively. Smith’s charisma and comedic timing were key to the success of ‘Men in Black’, and his performance in ‘I Am Legend’ further cemented his status as a major movie star. He demonstrated that audiences were eager to see Black actors take the lead in stories that hadn’t traditionally included them.

Idris Elba

Idris Elba became known for playing Heimdall in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, starting with the film ‘Thor.’ Interestingly, the character is traditionally depicted as a fair-skinned god in both the original comics and Norse mythology. Elba also portrayed Roland Deschain in ‘The Dark Tower’ movie, a role originally written as a white gunslinger. He was widely praised for bringing a powerful and reserved energy to these iconic characters. His casting choices often led to conversations about representation and diversity within fantasy and action films.

Laurence Fishburne

Laurence Fishburne portrayed Perry White, the editor of the Daily Planet, in the 2013 film ‘Man of Steel.’ Traditionally, Perry White was shown as a white man in Superman comics and earlier movies and TV shows. Fishburne’s performance brought a smart, no-nonsense energy to the role, fitting the movie’s darker style. He played Perry White again in ‘Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice,’ continuing to provide a realistic and relatable perspective. This casting decision modernized a well-known character, making him relevant for today’s audiences.

Michael B. Jordan

Michael B. Jordan starred as Johnny Storm, the Human Torch, in the 2015 ‘Fantastic Four’ movie, and as Guy Montag in the television adaptation of ‘Fahrenheit 451’. Both characters were originally written as white in their source material. Jordan delivered powerful and emotionally resonant performances in both roles, generating considerable discussion about the casting choices. These parts demonstrated his ability to lead major film and television projects.

Jeffrey Wright

Jeffrey Wright portrayed Commissioner James Gordon in Matt Reeves’ 2022 film, ‘The Batman.’ Traditionally, James Gordon has been depicted as a white character in DC comics, and Wright also previously played Felix Leiter in James Bond films – another role originally written for a white actor. His performance as Gordon was well-received, particularly for the character’s understated strength and effective teamwork with Batman. Wright brought a sense of seasoned honesty and realism to the role of the Gotham City police officer.

David Oyelowo

David Oyelowo portrayed Inspector Javert in the 2018 TV series ‘Les Misérables’. Traditionally, the character from Victor Hugo’s novel has been depicted as white, but Oyelowo chose to focus on Javert’s strict dedication to justice, rather than his race or physical appearance. Critics praised his nuanced performance, noting how it offered a fresh take on the role and proved that classic characters can be powerfully reimagined by actors of color.

Ncuti Gatwa

Ncuti Gatwa is the Fifteenth Doctor in the popular sci-fi show ‘Doctor Who.’ For more than fifty years, the Doctor was always played by white actors, until Jo Martin and Jodie Whittaker broke that pattern. Gatwa is the first Black actor to take on the leading role, and he brought a lot of energy and a new sense of style to the character when he first appeared. His casting was a landmark moment for the show and a big step forward for diversity on British TV.

Lance Reddick

Lance Reddick was well-known for playing Albert Wesker in the ‘Resident Evil’ TV series. Wesker was a major villain in the original video game, and Reddick perfectly captured the character’s cold and calculating nature. Throughout his career, Reddick often played powerful and composed characters, consistently delivering a strong and captivating on-screen presence.

Billy Porter

In the 2021 film ‘Cinderella,’ Billy Porter took on the role of the Fairy Godmother, reimagined as the fabulous ‘Fab G.’ Traditionally portrayed by white women, Porter brought a fresh, gender-neutral magic to the character, dazzling audiences in a stunning gold gown. His performance celebrated self-acceptance and being true to oneself, connecting with viewers today. Porter’s unique flair and charisma helped redefine this classic fairytale character.

Lakeith Stanfield

In the 2017 film ‘Death Note’, Lakeith Stanfield played the enigmatic character L. Originally depicted as Japanese and white in the popular anime and manga, Stanfield brilliantly brought L’s unique personality and sharp intellect to life. His performance heightened the tense psychological conflict between L and Light Turner. This casting decision was made to help connect the story with a wider, international audience.

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

I was completely blown away by Yahya Abdul-Mateen II’s performance as Cal Abar in ‘Watchmen’! It was such a brilliant reveal that he was actually Doctor Manhattan. It’s amazing how the show took the original character – Jon Osterman, who was a white scientist in the graphic novel – and reimagined him as a Black man. They really delved into what that meant for him and for the world around him. And honestly, Yahya deserved all the praise he got, including that Emmy! He perfectly captured the duality of Doctor Manhattan – this incredibly powerful, almost godlike being, but also a man who was deeply human and capable of love.

Chiwetel Ejiofor

Chiwetel Ejiofor joined the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2016, playing the character of Baron Karl Mordo in ‘Doctor Strange’. While Mordo was originally depicted as a white nobleman in the comics, Ejiofor brought a nuanced and dignified portrayal to the role. He played Mordo as a committed sorcerer grappling with the moral implications of using magic, adding complexity and depth to the magical world within the films.

Mehcad Brooks

Mehcad Brooks played James Olsen on the TV show ‘Supergirl’. The character, often known as Jimmy, started as a traditional, freckled white photographer in the Superman comics. Brooks reimagined him as a strong and heroic figure who ultimately became the vigilante Guardian. This was a significant change from the typical sidekick role, giving Jimmy more power and involvement in the storyline. Viewers generally praised this updated version of the classic supporting character.

David Harewood

In the series ‘Supergirl,’ David Harewood skillfully portrayed two characters: Hank Henshaw and J’onn J’onzz. J’onn J’onzz, an alien with shapeshifting abilities, consistently appeared as a Black man while maintaining a secret identity. This was a change from the DC comics, where Hank Henshaw was originally white. Harewood’s performance as the Martian Manhunter brought a sense of fatherly guidance and strong ethics to the show, making the character a beloved and important mentor to the main heroes for many seasons.

Isaiah Mustafa

As a big fan of ‘Shadowhunters,’ I always thought Isaiah Mustafa was fantastic as Luke Garroway. It’s cool how he took on the role – originally, Luke was written as white in Cassandra Clare’s ‘The Mortal Instruments’ books, but Isaiah brought so much to the part. He really played up the protective, fatherly side of Luke, and you totally bought him as the leader of a werewolf pack. Critics loved him, and rightfully so – he had this amazing emotional depth and just owned every scene. He completely made the character his own, and it was awesome seeing that transition from the books to the screen with a fresh take on the character’s identity.

Regé-Jean Page

Regé-Jean Page became famous for playing Simon Basset, the Duke of Hastings, in the first season of ‘Bridgerton’. The character was originally written as white in Julia Quinn’s novels. Page’s performance as the intense and charming lead was a hit with audiences. The show deliberately cast actors of color to create a more inclusive depiction of Regency-era society. This role led to bigger opportunities for Page in Hollywood, including roles in action movies.

Giancarlo Esposito

Giancarlo Esposito is known for playing compelling villains, notably Stan Edgar in ‘The Boys’ and Moff Gideon in ‘The Mandalorian’. In ‘The Boys’, he portrayed Stan Edgar, a character originally written as a white executive, bringing a chillingly composed and corporate demeanor to the powerful figure who manages the world’s superheroes. Similarly, his role as Moff Gideon in ‘The Mandalorian’ echoed the archetype of a classic, typically white, Imperial officer. Esposito’s talent for playing complex and nuanced villains has earned him widespread respect within the acting industry.

Jamie Foxx

Jamie Foxx portrayed Max Dillon, the villain Electro, in ‘The Amazing Spider-Man 2’. Originally depicted as a white engineer in Marvel comics, Foxx revisited the role in ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ with a new appearance and a more assertive personality. He infused the character with both humor and a threatening presence, setting his version apart from earlier portrayals. This casting choice offered a unique and modern interpretation of a classic Spider-Man foe.

Billy Dee Williams

In Tim Burton’s 1989 ‘Batman’ film, Billy Dee Williams portrayed District Attorney Harvey Dent. Originally a white character in the comics, Dent eventually becomes the villain Two-Face. The filmmakers initially planned for Williams to play Two-Face in a future movie, but the role went to another actor. Years later, Williams finally voiced the character in ‘The Lego Batman Movie’. His casting as Harvey Dent in the 1989 film was a significant step forward for Black representation in big-budget superhero movies.

Aldis Hodge

In the 2022 film ‘Black Adam’, Aldis Hodge starred as Carter Hall, also known as Hawkman. The character has a history in DC comics as both an archaeologist and an alien prince. Hodge brought a powerful and commanding presence to the role, portraying Hawkman as the leader of the Justice Society. He highlighted the character’s deep history and strong commitment to protecting the world, and his performance was praised for its physicality and the strong connection he had with his teammates.

Leslie Odom Jr.

Leslie Odom Jr. was the first to play Aaron Burr in the hit Broadway musical ‘Hamilton’. Burr was a historical figure – a white man who served as the third Vice President – and the musical creatively cast a diverse group of actors to portray the founding fathers, using hip hop and R&B. Odom’s performance as Hamilton’s strategic and driven opponent earned him a Tony Award and demonstrated how history can be reimagined to reflect contemporary American culture.

Daveed Diggs

Daveed Diggs famously played both Thomas Jefferson and the Marquis de Lafayette in the musical ‘Hamilton’. While these historical figures were both important white men – in America and France respectively – Diggs brought a fresh, energetic style to the roles using his talents as a rapper. His performance, which earned him a Tony Award, was a standout part of the show, with his portrayal of Jefferson being especially known for its lively energy and cleverness.

Christopher Jackson

As a huge fan of ‘Hamilton,’ I was particularly struck by Christopher Jackson’s performance as George Washington. It wasn’t just about playing the first President – a hugely important figure in American history – but how he did it. Jackson brought this incredible strength and vocal power to the role, but also a real sense of weariness and dignity. He showed Washington as a man who understood his legacy. And honestly, seeing a Black actor portray such a foundational figure felt absolutely essential to what ‘Hamilton’ was trying to do – reflecting America as it is today.

Robert Guillaume

Robert Guillaume broke barriers when he starred as the Phantom in ‘The Phantom of the Opera’ on stage. He was the first Black actor to take on the role in a large-scale production of the famous Andrew Lloyd Webber musical, which had previously been played by white actors like Michael Crawford. Guillaume, a seasoned performer on stage and television, brought depth and nuance to the complex and heartbreaking character. His performance was a significant step forward for diversity and representation in musical theater.

Norm Lewis

Norm Lewis made history as the first Black actor to star as the Phantom in Broadway’s ‘The Phantom of the Opera,’ following Robert Guillaume, who played the role in Los Angeles previously. Lewis was already a well-known Broadway performer, celebrated for his powerful voice and captivating presence. His casting was hailed as a significant achievement for diversity in theater, and he delivered a deeply moving performance as the troubled musical genius.

Denzel Washington

Denzel Washington starred as Don Pedro in the 1993 film version of Shakespeare’s ‘Much Ado About Nothing.’ Traditionally, this character was played by white actors in European settings, but Washington brought his own compelling presence and regal bearing to the role. He blended seamlessly with the film’s impressive cast and the bright, Italian backdrop, demonstrating his skill with classic literature and his ability to make it feel effortless.

Louis Gossett Jr.

In the 1982 film ‘An Officer and a Gentleman’, Louis Gossett Jr. powerfully portrayed Gunnery Sergeant Emil Foley. Originally, the character was written for a white actor, but the director chose Gossett because he was the best fit for the role. He delivered a memorable performance as the demanding drill instructor, pushing recruits to their breaking points. This earned him the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor – a historic win, as he was the first Black man to receive that honor. His performance is still considered one of the most recognizable and impactful depictions of a military figure in film.

Dennis Haysbert

Dennis Haysbert played the role of Manute in the 2014 film ‘Sin City A Dame to Kill For’. Manute is a large, quiet bodyguard, and while originally portrayed as white in the graphic novels by Frank Miller, Haysbert took on the role from Michael Clarke Duncan, who played him in the first film. Haysbert brought a powerful and intimidating presence to the character, and his performance was a highlight of the movie’s distinctive, dark style.

Bernie Casey

As a Bond fan, I always thought it was a really cool move casting Bernie Casey as Felix Leiter in ‘Never Say Never Again’! It’s easy to forget now, but he was the first Black actor to play the role, which was originally written as a white character in the books. He was a great, solid ally to Sean Connery’s Bond, and honestly, it was a significant moment for the franchise, helping to open things up and show a bit more diversity. Jeffrey Wright later took on the role, but Bernie Casey was a true pioneer.

Bernie Mac

Bernie Mac starred as Frank Catton in Steven Soderbergh’s ‘Ocean’s Eleven’ movies. The character was originally played by a white actor in the 1960 version of the film. Mac brought a lot of humor and charisma to the role of the casino dealer and con man, becoming a crucial part of the heist crew and delivering some of the films’ most memorable laughs. His performance helped update the story and make it appealing to modern viewers.

Don Cheadle

Don Cheadle first appeared in the ‘Ocean’s Eleven’ movies in 2001, playing the explosives expert Basher Tarr. Like his co-star Bernie Mac, Cheadle stepped into a role originally played by a white actor. Basher’s Cockney accent made him a memorable addition to the team. Cheadle is also known for playing James Rhodes, or War Machine, in the Marvel films – a character who was always Black in the original comic books. His performance in ‘Ocean’s Eleven’ demonstrated his talent for both comedic and action-packed roles.

Corey Hawkins

As a big fan of ‘The Walking Dead,’ I always thought Corey Hawkins absolutely nailed the role of Heath. It’s cool how they cast him, because in the original comics, Heath was written as a white guy with glasses. But Corey really became that resourceful, brave survivor in Alexandria. He perfectly captured Heath’s practical side, dealing with all the zombie craziness. Honestly, he did a fantastic job bringing the character’s personality to life, even with the change in how he looked – it felt really true to the spirit of the comic book version.

James Earl Jones

James Earl Jones starred as Big Daddy in a groundbreaking all-Black production of Tennessee Williams’s ‘Cat on a Hot Tin Roof.’ Originally written as a white Southern plantation owner, the role was powerfully reimagined by Jones, who brought his iconic voice and commanding stage presence to the part of the ailing family head. He skillfully portrayed the play’s themes of family conflict and what we leave behind. This production was a landmark event, proving the story’s themes resonate with everyone.

Sidney Poitier

In the 1965 film ‘The Bedford Incident,’ Sidney Poitier portrayed Ben Munceford, a journalist aboard a naval ship. Interestingly, the character was originally written as white in the source novel. By taking on the role, Poitier brought an added dimension of racial tension to the intense military thriller. Throughout his career, he frequently chose roles not intended for Black actors, and this film was another instance of him challenging conventions and paving the way for others.

Harry Lennix

Harry Lennix portrayed General Swanwick in DC films, and it was later revealed he was actually the Martian Manhunter. Though often depicted as green, the character sometimes appears as a white man in the comics, and Lennix captured this military leader with a serious and enigmatic presence throughout his appearances. The reveal of his true identity was a significant moment for fans, as he’d been subtly watching over everything for a long time.

Peter Mensah

Peter Mensah played Oenomaus in the TV series ‘Spartacus’. Oenomaus, a historical Gallic gladiator, was likely of European descent. Mensah portrayed him as the Doctore, a strong and well-respected gladiator trainer. He brought both impressive physical strength and a strict sense of morality to the role, making Oenomaus a popular character and important part of the show’s rebellion.

Adrian Lester

Adrian Lester starred as Mickey Bricks in the British TV series ‘Hustle’. His character was a clever con man who led a team of swindlers in London. Although the show was fresh, the ‘gentleman thief’ role was historically played by white actors in British television. Lester’s sophisticated and intelligent portrayal was key to the show’s success, making him the recognizable face of ‘Hustle’ and earning praise for his smooth, carefully-planned performance.

Jordan Fisher

Jordan Fisher starred as Evan Hansen in the Broadway musical ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. The role was initially created and performed by white actors, most notably Ben Platt. Fisher offered a fresh take on the character, portraying the anxious and isolated teenager with emotional depth and impressive vocals. His performance demonstrated that the musical’s themes of loneliness and connection could powerfully connect with audiences no matter the actor’s race.

Taye Diggs

As a huge fan, I’ll always remember Taye Diggs as Benny in ‘Rent’! It’s amazing to learn that the character actually started as a white Jewish man in the early versions of the show. Taye brought such a unique energy to the role – he really made Benny feel like this powerful, almost villainous figure, especially as the friend who ended up becoming a landlord. He played Benny both on Broadway and in the movie, and I think he truly shaped how everyone sees that character. Plus, he was part of this incredible cast that really changed musical theater forever!

Nonso Anozie

Nonso Anozie portrayed Tommy Jepperd in the TV show ‘Sweet Tooth’. While the character was originally depicted as a large, white, athletic man in Jeff Lemire’s comic book, Anozie brought a sense of kindness and protectiveness to the role, contrasting with the character’s history of violence. His performance was crucial to the show’s emotional impact, as he acted as a guide and protector for a young hybrid child navigating a perilous world. This casting choice ultimately changed the dynamic between the two central characters.

Bokeem Woodbine

Bokeem Woodbine played Herman Schultz, the villain known as the Shocker, in ‘Spider-Man Homecoming’. Traditionally, the Shocker was depicted as a white character in the Marvel comics. Woodbine brought a tough, realistic edge to the role of the tech-savvy thief, acting as a strong and intimidating member of the Vulture’s crew. His casting contributed to a diverse ensemble that mirrored the real demographics of Queens, New York.

Paterson Joseph

Paterson Joseph famously played the Marquis de Carabas in both the television and radio versions of ‘Neverwhere’. The Marquis was a cunning and charming character who lived in a fantastical London. Although the original script didn’t specify the character’s race, he was typically imagined as a traditional white nobleman. Joseph’s energetic and humorous performance made his portrayal of the Marquis particularly memorable, and he perfectly captured the character’s enigmatic and clever personality.

Share your thoughts on these historic casting choices in the comments.

2026-02-22 00:20