Robert Downey Jr.’s MCU Return as Doctor Doom: Is Marvel Creatively Bankrupt or Genius?

by

As a lifelong Marvel fan who has followed the development of their cinematic universe since its inception, I find myself torn over the casting of Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom in the upcoming Avengers sequels. On one hand, I am thrilled to see RDJ back in the MCU after his iconic portrayal of Tony Stark. His charm and wit have always been a highlight of the franchise, and I can only imagine the emotional turmoil that the Avengers would go through if Doom revealed his face and it was their dearly departed loved one under the mask.

“It’s puzzling; have you transformed into a villain this time around?” That was Gwyneth Paltrow’s perplexed response to the surprising revelation that Robert Downey Jr. will be rejoining the MCU, not as Iron Man but as the formidable Marvel antagonist, Doctor Doom. And truthfully? I share your bewilderment, Gwyneth Paltrow. I share your bewilderment.

At San Diego Comic-Con 2024 in Hall H, the Russo Brothers made a major announcement as the masterminds behind four Marvel blockbusters, including the last two Avengers films, Infinity War and Endgame. They’ve signed on to direct Avengers: Doomsday and Avengers: Secret Wars for Marvel Studios. The news of Downey reprising his role as Doom has sparked intense fan reactions, with some expressing excitement and others voicing disappointment. Let’s explore the reasons behind these contrasting views and potential plans from Kevin Feige and team.

Robert Downey, Jr.’s Return Could Smooth a Rough Patch in the MCU

As a longtime Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) fan, I can’t contain my excitement about Robert Downey Jr.’s (RDJ) anticipated return to the MCU after a five-year hiatus. His portrayal of Tony Stark/Iron Man has been nothing short of revolutionary in the modern superhero genre. From his early days as a solo hero to his selfless sacrifice to save the universe from Thanos, RDJ’s performances have left an indelible mark on fans.

The MCU has been facing some challenges since the beginning of the Multiverse Saga, with an abundance of new characters, less-than-impressive projects, and a seemingly absent overarching storyline leaving certain fans underwhelmed. Even Deadpool didn’t hold back in poking fun at Marvel’s slump in “Deadpool & Wolverine.” It’s no surprise then that Marvel chose to reunite RDJ and the Russos – they are beloved figures in the Marvel Universe who consistently deliver high-quality superhero films.

Does Marvel Studios’ Decision to Replace Kang With Downey’s Doctor Doom Suggest a Lack of Creativity?

The original plan for the fifth Avengers movie was for Earth’s mightiest heroes battle it out against Kang the Conqueror in Avengers: The Kang Dynasty. Kang actor Jonathan Majors was fired from the role and left Marvel in a bad spot. Upset fans think it makes Marvel look desperate and creatively bankrupt to simply bring back Downey (and the Russos) in an effort to recapture their pre-Endgame glory. We all figured that RDJ would return to the MCU one day. Downey himself said he would be happy to return; however, this feels far too soon for some fans.

As a gaming enthusiast, I can’t hide my excitement: I’ll be slipping into the menacing role of Doctor Doom in the epic clash, Avengers: Doomsday. A fresh mask, but the same daunting mission awaits! #Avengers #sdcc #marvel

— TopMob (@nerdist) July 28, 2024

Wait, How Can Robert Downey, Jr. Play Doctor Doom After Portraying Iron Man?

1. Fans are puzzled about how Downey, who has previously played various roles within the MCU, can now portray Doctor Doom. For instance, Gemma Chan played Minn-Erva in Captain Marvel and Sersi in Eternals; Michelle Yeoh appeared as Aleta Ogord in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 before taking on a supporting role in Shang Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings as Ying Nan. While viewers may not have caught these recurring actors, they’ll certainly recognize Downey. (Paraphrased with a focus on clarity)

It seems out of place for Downey to take on the role of MCU’s most renowned villain, Doctor Doom, without a compelling reason. Fans find it hard to accept this casting and are speculating that Downey is merely portraying Doom in an acting capacity for the upcoming “Avengers” films. They anticipate the genuine Doctor Doom will emerge with a new actor, delivering a more faithful representation of the comics character. Marvel’s explanation on how Doctor Doom could have Tony Stark’s face might influence fans’ acceptance or rejection of this decision.

How the MCU Can Use Comics and Heart to Make This Doctor Doom Venture Satisfying for Fans

1. There’s plenty of emotional impact to be gained by having Marvel’s top hero die and then have the same actor portray Marvel’s most notorious villain. It would be heart-wrenching for the Avengers, particularly Peter Parker, if Doom unmasked himself and revealed that their lost comrade was hidden beneath the mask. Intriguingly, the emblems for “Avengers: Doomsday” are green and silver, reminiscent of Doom, while “Avengers: Secret Wars” features red and gold, colors associated with Iron Man. It’s possible that Marvel intended this color scheme to hint at a deeper Doctor Doom/Iron Man narrative. Maybe the forthcoming Avengers films will provide a compelling explanation for this unconventional casting decision.

There’s been a lot of history in the comic books showing exciting interactions between Iron Man and Doctor Doom, with some stories even having one character temporarily replace the other. For example, after Tony Stark’s apparent death in 2016, Doctor Doom stepped into the role and led the series called “Infamous Iron Man.” A story from 2010 titled “Iron Man: Demon in an Armor” had an interesting twist where Doctor Doom swapped bodies with Tony Stark. And in a 2004 issue of “Marvel Team-Up,” a version of Tony Stark from another universe became the Iron Maniac, a character similar to Doctor Doom, and was sent to Earth-616, which is where the Avengers reside. It’s possible that these comic book stories could serve as inspiration for the upcoming Avengers sequels.

Is Downey’s Doctor Doom a Tony Stark Variant in the MCU?

The Russos didn’t clearly state whether Downey’s portrayal of Doom will be a modified Stark character or not, fueling uncertainty about this casting selection. They merely announced he’s acting as Victor von Doom. However, they also mentioned the “endless possibilities in the Marvel multiverse,” implying that he could indeed be a variant. If Downey’s Doom isn’t a variant and fans are supposed to accept a Doom with Stark’s features as standard, this might be too hard for audiences to accept. It could reinforce perceptions of stunt casting instead of an innovative creative decision.

Some fans may require a compelling reason to accept Downey as Doom, while others are unbothered, only eager for an entertaining superhero film. Just like Hugh Jackman’s portrayal of Wolverine showed, an actor’s seemingly last appearance as a cherished Marvel character doesn’t hinder fans from turning up in large numbers to witness their return in a new project. The success of “Deadpool” and “Wolverine,” which shattered box office records, undoubtedly validated Marvel’s faith in Downey’s comeback, at least financially speaking.

Will Marvel Address Doctor Doom’s Romani Heritage in the MCU?

1. Although Robert Downey Jr.’s acting abilities are beyond question, some fans have voiced concerns about his suitability for the role of Doctor Doom due to some key differences between him and the character as portrayed in the comics. For instance, Doctor Doom is Romani in the source material, and his experiences with prejudice early in life greatly impact his origin story. Thus, casting Downey might be seen as whitewashing the character. On the other hand, Iron Man’s witty and playful personality contrasts sharply with Doctor Doom’s cold and intense demeanor, which resembles that of Darth Vader.

Typically, Doom’s visage is gruesomely scarred, and he’s so obsessed with his appearance that he rarely removes his mask except in exceptional circumstances. This could be advantageous for Downey since consistently wearing a mask might help audiences forget his past role as Tony Stark. It would enable him to offer a completely different kind of performance, similar to Hugo Weaving’s V in “V for Vendetta.” However, it seems unlikely that Marvel would invest a significant amount of money on Downey only to conceal him most of the time.

Will Robert Downey, Jr. Play Doom for the Long Run? Probably Not.

Doctor Doom is a multifaceted character in Marvel’s comic books, renowned for his genius intellect and sorcerous abilities. His background is richly layered and intriguing. While often portrayed as a villain, he doesn’t embody pure evil. Instead, he adheres to a personal code of honor that occasionally leads him to collaborate with the good guys instead of opposing them. For comic enthusiasts, the MCU’s development of Doctor Doom is highly anticipated, with hopes for an intricate narrative that explores his rule over Latveria, mastery of techno-sorcery, and complex alliances with heroes. Fans also desire to see a passionate rivalry between Doctor Doom and Reed Richards of the Fantastic Four, surpassing previous adaptations.

Giving Doctor Doom’s storyline in the MCU its due respect would require a significant investment of time. However, keeping Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom for an extended period seems unlikely given his high salary in Hollywood. Fans who have long anticipated MCU’s Doctor Doom may feel cheated. It appears Marvel took a safe approach to safeguard box office revenue and revitalize the franchise. Ultimately, the responsibility of delivering impressive Avengers movies lies with Downey and the Russos. However, it will be up to fans to decide if their efforts are deserving of Doctor Doom.

Read More

2024-07-30 19:03