Dividends & Dilemmas: A Most Pleasant Comparison

by

Now, a fellow can find himself in a bit of a pickle when contemplating the acquisition of dividends. One wants a steady income, you see, something to keep the coffers from looking quite so alarmingly bare. And it appears two perfectly respectable funds, the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM +2.29%) and the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD +1.66%), are vying for the honour of assisting in this most crucial endeavour. Both are frightfully economical on fees – a point in their favour, naturally – but a discerning investor, such as ourselves, must delve a bit deeper, mustn’t one?

The matter, you see, isn’t merely about scraping together a few extra shillings. It’s about constructing a portfolio that’s as solid as a bank manager’s principles, and as reliable as the rising of the sun. Both funds aim to provide access to American companies that are generous with their dividends, but they approach the task with slightly different degrees of enthusiasm. This comparison, therefore, is a bit like choosing between a perfectly serviceable motorcar and one with a rather dashing chrome finish – both will get you there, but one does it with a touch more… panache.

A Snapshot of the Situation

Metric VYM SCHD
Issuer Vanguard Schwab
Expense Ratio 0.06% 0.06%
1-Year Return (as of 2026-01-30) 15.7% 11.3%
Dividend Yield 2.3% 3.5%
Beta 0.76 0.74
AUM $84.6 billion $78.4 billion

Now, the ‘Beta’ measurement, as the chaps at Vanguard and Schwab are keen to point out, is a rather technical affair, indicating how much the fund tends to bounce about compared to the general market. But let’s not get bogged down in details. The salient point is that both are reasonably well-behaved, and the 1-year return of VYM is rather spiffing, though SCHD’s dividend yield is decidedly more generous.

Performance & Risk: A Spot of Bother?

Metric VYM SCHD
Max Drawdown (5 years) -15.83% -16.86%
Growth of $1,000 over 5 years $1,636 $1,393

A ‘drawdown’, you see, is when the value of your investment takes a bit of a tumble. Both funds have experienced a few such moments, naturally – the market is a fickle beast – but neither has fallen into the soup to any alarming degree. VYM, however, appears to have been rather more adept at growing one’s initial investment over five years. A most agreeable outcome, wouldn’t you say?

What’s Inside the Machine?

SCHD, it seems, prefers a concentrated basket of 101 American companies, with a particular fondness for the energy, consumer defensive, and healthcare sectors. Lockheed Martin Corp. (LMT +2.28%), Texas Instrument Inc. (TXN 1.13%), and Chevron Corp. (CVX +0.91%) are rather prominent names within its holdings. It’s a fund with a respectable track record, and thankfully, free of any unnecessary complications.

VYM, on the other hand, adopts a broader approach, encompassing 589 stocks, with a leaning towards financial services, technology, and, of course, healthcare. Broadcom Inc. (AVGO +7.26%), JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM +3.89%), and Exxon Mobil Corp. (XOM +2.03%) are among its leading lights. Both funds, thankfully, refrain from employing any risky leverage or currency hedges – a sensible precaution, in my book.

The Meaning of it All for the Discerning Investor

Both the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) and the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) are top-notch, low-cost exchange-traded funds designed to provide a steady stream of income. Choosing between the pair, therefore, is a matter of nuance, a delicate balancing act between yield, growth, and diversification.

SCHD offers a rather more substantial dividend yield, which is undeniably attractive. However, VYM’s recent performance has been rather sprightly, thanks to its holdings in the technology sector. Those tech stocks, you see, have been enjoying a period of rather exuberant growth, fuelled by the ever-expanding world of artificial intelligence.

VYM also boasts a more diversified portfolio, which can help to cushion the blow should any particular sector experience a downturn. However, the technology industry is notoriously volatile, and SCHD’s higher yield could potentially deliver superior returns over the long haul. As a result, SCHD is particularly well-suited to investors seeking a robust dividend yield to provide a steady income stream.

VYM, on the other hand, appeals to those who prioritize broad diversification and greater exposure to the exciting world of AI, even if it means accepting a slightly lower dividend yield. It’s a bit like choosing between a reliable family saloon and a dashing sports car – both will get you there, but one offers a bit more… pizzazz.

Read More

2026-02-08 00:12