Etsy: A Spot of Value in the E-Commerce Garden?

by

Now, the rise of this online shopping business has been quite the thing, hasn’t it? A veritable revolution, really, in how one acquires one’s knick-knacks and necessities. It’s all very modern, and one must confess, rather convenient. The swiftness with which goods appear on one’s doorstep is nothing short of wizardry. And, of course, the increased adoption of those pocket-sized telephones – smartphones, they call them – has given the whole affair a jolly good push.

One observes, however, that the vast majority of spending still occurs in those rather old-fashioned establishments known as shops. But fear not, for the trend is undeniably upwards, and a shrewd investor might well consider where the best opportunities lie. It’s a positively brimming market, and we’re not talking about Amazon, you understand.

A Bargain to be Had

Amazon, you see, is a bit like a particularly efficient department store – it has everything, and it delivers it with alarming speed. Difficult to fault, naturally. But one mustn’t overlook the smaller, more specialized establishments. And it is Etsy, bless its quirky soul, that currently appears to be trading at a most agreeable price. A price-to-sales ratio of 2.3, you understand, is not to be sneezed at. In fact, it’s rather like stumbling upon a perfectly good pair of trousers at a jumble sale.

A Niche Nicely Filled

The key to Etsy’s appeal, you see, lies in its rather clever focus. It’s cornered the market, if you will, for the unique, the handcrafted, the vintage – all those delightful things one simply can’t find amongst the mass-produced offerings. A recent survey – a perfectly reliable one, naturally – revealed that a staggering 83% of Etsy customers believe its marketplace contains items unavailable elsewhere. A truly remarkable statistic, wouldn’t you agree?

Furthermore, Etsy operates on a rather sensible, asset-light model. It doesn’t bother with warehouses, delivery trucks, or any of that cumbersome nonsense. It simply provides the platform – a rather ingenious bit of coding, what! – connecting 86.6 million eager buyers with 5.5 million enthusiastic sellers. A veritable hive of industry, if you will.

This, naturally, creates a rather delightful network effect. More users mean more value for everyone. Buyers have more choice, and sellers have a larger audience. It’s a win-win situation, and one always appreciates a good win-win.

Loading widget...

A Spot of Bother

Despite these advantages, one must confess that Etsy has encountered a few difficulties since the rather exceptional demand of the COVID years. This explains, to a degree, why the stock is currently trading a rather alarming 82% below its November 2021 peak. A bit of a pickle, you might say.

In the third quarter of 2023, the marketplace processed $2.4 billion in gross merchandise sales – a decline of 11% compared to the same period in 2021. Consumers, it seems, have become a touch less enthusiastic about discretionary spending. A dashedly inconvenient truth, naturally.

And, rather unfortunately, Etsy has also increased its expenses in areas like product development and marketing. Not precisely the most encouraging trend, one must admit.

The stock is cheap, undoubtedly. But a prudent investor might well wait for a clear improvement in the fundamentals – particularly regarding growth – before taking the plunge. A bit of patience, you see, can often be rewarded.

Read More

2026-02-01 16:42