Costco vs. Walmart: The Beige Battle

So, we’re talking about Walmart (WMT +1.47%) and Costco (COST 1.19%). Two titans. Two behemoths. Two places where you can buy a flat-screen TV and enough mayonnaise to embalm a small nation. Walmart, the everything store. Costco, the everything store…but you need a membership. It’s like they’re daring you to earn the right to overspend. Honestly, it’s exhausting being this insightful.

Is one a better buy? Let’s not get carried away. It’s like asking if beige is a better color than slightly different beige. Both are perfectly serviceable, utterly predictable, and will likely still be around when our robot overlords arrive.

Why You Might Want to Run Screaming From These Stocks

If you’re a value investor, congratulations on your excellent taste in restraint. These two are priced like they’ve discovered the fountain of youth. Price-to-sales, price-to-earnings, price-to-book…they’re all doing the high-kick routine, way above their five-year averages. They’re expensive, folks. Shocking, I know. And not just expensive compared to themselves. They’re expensive compared to everything! It’s like they’re daring you to find a cheaper way to buy bulk toilet paper.

Dividend investors? Forget about it. Walmart’s yield is a pathetic 0.8%. 0.8%! I’ve seen gum wrappers with a better return. Costco’s? Even more insulting. 0.5%. At that rate, you’d make more money collecting lint. Seriously, start a lint-collecting business. It’s a solid plan.

Who’s Foolish Enough to Consider These?

Okay, so the value guys and income seekers are out. That leaves us with the growth investors. And honestly? Costco has a slight edge. It’s not quite as gargantuan as Walmart, and they’re still expanding. It’s like watching a slightly less obese elephant trying to do the tango.

Loading widget...

And here’s the kicker: Costco’s membership fees. It’s like a subscription to consumerism. They get half their profits from people paying to spend money. It’s brilliant, really. Pure genius. They could sell you rocks painted gold and you’d thank them for it. They have you by the bulk-sized pickle jar, and they know it.

Loading widget...

Walmart has some of that long-term stability, but it’s mostly riding the wave of people trading down. Belt-tightening consumers flocking to Walmart because, well, it’s cheap. But let’s be honest, the moment the economy perks up, they’ll be back to buying artisanal kale chips and complaining about the lack of organic quinoa. It’s the circle of life…or, more accurately, the circle of spending.

Neither is a Steal, But One’s Slightly Less Offensive

Look, both Walmart and Costco are well-run companies. Walmart is a Dividend King, which means they’ve been handing out crumbs to shareholders for over 50 years. Bravo. But both stocks are pricey right now. So, if you insist on throwing your money at one of these behemoths, Costco’s business model is marginally less… depressing. They’ve at least figured out how to make you pay them to spend more money. It’s a masterful stroke of corporate villainy, I tell you. A masterpiece.

Read More

2026-02-01 12:14