The Nodules’ Folly: A Speculative Comedy

Upon the ocean floor, a most curious spectacle unfolds. Billions of tons of polymetallic nodules lie undisturbed, awaiting a decree upon their fate – whether to remain in the watery depths, or to be roused for the benefit – or, perhaps, the folly – of mankind. These are not mere stones, mind you, but contain the very metals essential to these modern contraptions we call ‘clean energy’ and ‘electric vehicles’ – cobalt, copper, nickel, manganese, and a host of others, all slumbering in the dark.

There exists a company, The Metals Company (TMC +14.06%), which dares to envision itself as the master of this submerged realm. They claim the right to harvest these nodules, to drag them forth and transmute them into profit. A bold ambition, certainly, though one not entirely divorced from a certain…optimism. One might even suggest a touch of delusion, were it not for a recent turn of events.

Loading widget...

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, in a gesture of bureaucratic streamlining, has altered its permitting process. Henceforth, a single application shall suffice for both exploration and commercial recovery. A simplification, to be sure, though one wonders if it is a simplification of the path to prosperity, or merely a quicker route to potential ruin. It is as if the authorities, witnessing the company’s precarious position, have offered a ladder…built of sand.

Until recently, the tale of this enterprise was fraught with uncertainty – a lack of regulatory approval, a hazy path to revenue, and a most alarming consumption of capital. Yet, with this newly defined regulatory landscape, the timeline for actual operations in the Pacific may, indeed, be shorter than previously feared. Or, one might add, expected. A company with a market capitalization of $3.7 billion, yet generating no revenue, is a sight to behold. They claim control over nodules valued at $23.6 billion. A grand claim, to be sure, but one must always remember the difference between valuation and realization.

As of late, TMC has been the first to submit this consolidated application. Risks remain, naturally. Execution, as they say, is everything. But shares below $10 might, for the patient investor, present an opportunity. Though I caution all to remember the old adage: a fool and his money are soon parted, especially when lured by the promise of treasures from the deep. Consider this not as a recommendation, but as a theatrical observation: a comedy unfolding, and we, the audience, are invited to wager on the outcome.

Read More

2026-01-25 01:23