Robinhood: A Most Improbable Investment

by

The curiously named Robinhood (HOOD 1.46%), a company whose origins suggest a delightful misunderstanding of medieval property rights, has recently experienced a minor gravitational adjustment – a 20% dip from its previous apogee. This, in the grand scheme of things, is less a crash and more a gentle reminder that even improbably successful ventures are still subject to the whims of, well, everything. The question, of course, isn’t merely whether this represents a buying opportunity, but whether one should participate in a system so elegantly designed to separate people from their money (and occasionally, return some of it).

What Does Robinhood Actually Do?

Robinhood is, at its core, a discount brokerage. It competes with established institutions like Charles Schwab and Interactive Brokers, companies whose names suggest a comforting, if slightly bureaucratic, solidity. Robinhood, however, arrived on the scene like a rogue asteroid, disrupting the established order by offering commission-free trading. This, it must be noted, isn’t entirely altruistic. It’s a bit like offering free oxygen… eventually, you’ll find a way to charge for the mask. (The details are, naturally, buried in the user agreement, a document so dense and labyrinthine it’s rumored to contain the lost city of Atlantis.)

But the disruption didn’t stop there. Robinhood was digitally native, conceived in the silicon and nurtured on algorithms. It gamified stock trading, a practice that simultaneously appeals to and terrifies anyone with a passing understanding of behavioral economics. It embraced cryptocurrency, a digital phantom whose value fluctuates more wildly than a startled hummingbird. And, most recently, it ventured into sports betting, a pastime that proves, beyond any doubt, that humans will bet on absolutely anything. (Including, presumably, the outcome of a coin toss conducted on Mars.)

The stock itself has performed remarkably well, rising approximately 1,100% over the past three years. A truly astonishing feat, considering the inherent improbability of predicting the future. However, before leaping aboard this particular rocket ship, a few cautionary flags warrant consideration.

Valuation and the Inevitable Bear Market

The first, and perhaps most pressing, concern is valuation. Robinhood currently boasts a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio approaching 50. This is, to put it mildly, rather optimistic. Charles Schwab, a company that appears to have been around since the invention of money itself, trades at a P/E of 24. Interactive Brokers, a slightly more enigmatic entity, sits at 34. Robinhood, therefore, is considerably more expensive. (One suspects the premium is based on the sheer audacity of its branding.)

Comparing Robinhood’s valuation to the broader market offers further perspective. The S&P 500 (^GSPC 0.06%) currently trades at a P/E of around 31. The Vanguard Financials Index ETF (VFH +0.08%), a reasonably representative proxy for the financial sector, has a P/E of approximately 19. While brokers only constitute about 10% of the ETF’s portfolio, it highlights the significant premium assigned to Robinhood. (One can almost hear the market whispering, “But it’s disruptive!“)

Loading widget...

This lofty valuation must be viewed in historical context. Robinhood’s clientele skews younger, and the stock only began trading after the pandemic-induced bear market of 2020. Consequently, it has only experienced a bull market. Its customers have yet to navigate a truly deep and prolonged downturn, such as those witnessed during the Great Recession or the dot-com bubble. (Which, incidentally, proved that people will invest in absolutely anything with a “.com” suffix.)

History suggests that investors tend to panic and sell during bear markets. This, predictably, increases trading activity. However, a sufficiently deep and protracted downturn may lead Robinhood’s younger customers to conclude that investing is simply too risky. A perfectly rational response, and one that has played out countless times on Wall Street. Robinhood will likely survive such a downturn, but the current valuation premium seems unsustainable. (Especially if its customer base shrinks along with stock prices.)

A Cautious Recommendation

Robinhood has achieved some impressive feats in a short period, most notably forcing the entire industry to lower trading costs. However, the market appears to have already factored in a considerable amount of optimism, despite the recent 20% correction. The true test of the business, however, remains unknown until the next significant bear market arrives. Most investors would be well-advised to observe the outcome of that event before considering this innovative discount broker. (It’s always prudent to let others test the structural integrity of a potentially collapsing system.)

Read More

2026-01-17 15:12