Arbor Realty: A REIT Reckoning

by

Right. Arbor Realty Trust. ABR. It’s down… well, let’s just say it’s having a moment. A 40% drop since the start of 2025. Feels a bit like my dating life, actually. Lots of potential, then… a rapid decline. Currently trading near COVID-era lows with a yield that looks amazing, but… always a ‘but’, isn’t there? It’s tempting, of course. A 15% yield. It whispers promises of early retirement and exotic holidays. But I’ve learned, painfully, that things that sound too good usually are. So, let’s dissect this, shall we? Like a particularly complicated tax return.

What Is Arbor Realty, Exactly?

Okay, so Arbor Realty is, essentially, a sophisticated mortgage REIT. They lend money, mostly for multifamily properties. They hold these loans, intending to get paid back over time. It sounds… straightforward. They also have this agency platform where they refinance these loans into longer-term mortgages backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Which is… a lot of acronyms. They also collect fees for servicing these mortgages. It’s clever, really. A way to get multiple revenue streams. Like trying to have three side hustles at once. It seems like a good idea, until you realize you’re completely exhausted and nothing is getting done properly.

Why the Share Price Has Decided to Take a Dive

The problem, as always, is timing. In 2021 and 2022, everyone was throwing money around. Near-zero interest rates, stimulus checks… it was a lending frenzy. Arbor, naturally, participated. Then, interest rates went up. Surprise, surprise. Originating new loans slowed to a trickle. And suddenly, those loans they made at the peak of the market… aren’t looking so clever. As of the latest quarter, over half of their portfolio – 51.4% – is made up of these 2021-2022 vintages. It’s like buying a house at the absolute height of the bubble. You just know it’s going to end badly.

Borrowers are struggling to refinance because property valuations have… adjusted. Downwardly. The newer loans are doing better, naturally. They were made at lower property values. It’s just… basic math. Arbor’s loans typically have three-year terms, with one-year extensions. But many borrowers can’t refinance with the same principal. And long-term rates haven’t exactly plummeted, despite the Fed’s attempts. It’s all a bit… frustrating. Arbor is now restructuring these loans, sometimes taking over the properties. Which is… a lot of work. And potentially a lot of loss.

They used to be known for increasing their dividend. Now they’ve cut it. From $0.43 to $0.30 per quarter. Which, let’s be honest, is never a good sign. The share price has been trickling down ever since. The recent low of $8 came when they announced a new issue of senior notes with higher interest rates. Higher interest rates! It’s like adding insult to injury.

The Path to… Something?

Okay, deep breaths. It’s not all bad. They’ve largely preserved book value per share, which was $12.08 as of Q3. But a lot of those assets haven’t been adjusted for potential losses yet. They say it will take several months to work through the troubled assets. If they can execute well – and they’ve done okay so far – the reported asset values might be reliable. But ‘might’ is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. The troubled portion of the 2021-2022 vintages accounts for 40.3% of the loan portfolio. If they can’t restructure or rotate these assets, book value could take a serious hit. And that means another dividend cut. Joy.

One bright spot is their single-family rental portfolio. It’s been surprisingly durable and profitable. It makes up 23.6% of the loans and has been the main source of growth. If they can continue originating loans here, it might mitigate some of the losses from the multifamily side. It’s a small victory, but I’ll take it.

Before You Invest (Seriously, Think About This)

Look, Arbor isn’t out of the woods yet. The current share price probably reflects what’s left on the books if things get worse. More dividend cuts mean the yield on cost will be much lower than 15% for a long time. Investors need to decide what yield they’d accept before buying. Maybe under 10%? There is value here, but how much of a bargain it is depends on their execution in the next few quarters. It’s a gamble, really.

They’ve been in worse condition before, during the 2008 financial crisis. They became a penny stock, but they didn’t go bankrupt. This is their toughest hour since then. The fact that they haven’t completely imploded yet is… encouraging. It suggests they’ve learned some lessons. But let’s not get carried away. It’s still a risk. A very real risk.

Units of Cryptocurrency Lost: 12. Hours Spent Watching Charts: 9. Number of Panicked Texts to Friends: 24. Will become disciplined long-term investor: 0.

Read More

2026-01-15 23:06