AEO Stock in 2026: What to Watch

by

American Eagle Outfitters (AEO 3.54%) has proven that one need not chase the latest fads-be they artificial intelligence or the latest TikTok dance-to outpace the S&P 500. This global purveyor of denim and sweatpants has surged over 50% in a year, its fortunes boosted by a marketing stunt so audacious, it made conservatives reconsider their shopping lists. The brand’s fiscal third quarter, ending Nov. 1, saw a return to growth after years of waning sales, a turnaround as surprising as a drought in the Sahara.

Yet, let us not mistake a spark for a fire. AEO’s stock has only climbed 21% over five years, with most of that gain crammed into the second half of 2025. Investors should tread with caution, for the stock’s recent rise may be as fleeting as a summer breeze. The question remains: can this retailer sustain its momentum, or is it merely a passing fancy?

Here’s what the discerning investor should keep an eye on.

The Sydney Sweeney Campaign: A Game-Changer

The first ads in the Sydney Sweeney campaign dropped on July 23, 2025, and suddenly, American Eagle was the talk of the town. Before this, the company seemed destined for another lackluster year, but the campaign-so popular among conservatives it could have swayed an election-spurred a surge in sales. One might say it was a masterstroke, though the term “masterstroke” is reserved for those who don’t have to explain it to their grandchildren.

Conservatives, ever fickle, have been known to abandon brands that stray from their values-remember Bud Light’s woes after the Dylan Mulvaney debacle? Yet AEO’s campaign showed that aligning with this crowd could resurrect a struggling enterprise. It’s a lesson in marketing, if not in morality.

Advertisement

American Eagle’s revenue grew 6% year over year in Q3, the first full quarter to reflect the Sweeney campaign. Comparable sales rose 4%, a modest gain but one that pleased dividend-seeking investors. The CFO, Craig Brommers, declared the campaign “worth every penny,” a sentiment that would have made a used-car salesman weep with pride.

While these numbers may not dazzle, they are a lifeline for a stock with a yield nearing 2%. In Q2, sales dipped 1%, but the Sweeney campaign’s arrival in August seemed to reverse the trend. By December, management reported a record-breaking Thanksgiving, though one might argue that even a turkey dinner can seem “record-breaking” if you’ve been fasting since 2023.

Aerie’s Rise: A Bright Spot in the Storm

American Eagle cannot rely solely on political theater. It must also innovate, releasing quality goods to keep shareholders happy. Enter Aerie, the brand’s body-positive line, which has been gaining traction even before the Sweeney campaign. In Q2, Aerie’s sales rose 3%, a glimmer of hope amid a 1% revenue decline for the company as a whole.

In Q3, Aerie’s sales jumped 11%, while AEO’s own sales barely budged. Gross margins dipped slightly, a casualty of tariffs that have made imported goods costlier. Investors should watch these tariffs like a hawk, for they could turn a modest gain into a loss, much like a well-timed rainstorm on a picnic.

Though not all of AEO’s recent gains stem from the Sweeney campaign, it has undeniably played a role. If the company can maintain its momentum, it may yet surprise investors in 2026-a year when even a cautious investor might find themselves betting on a long shot.

So, what to watch? The Sweeney campaign’s longevity, Aerie’s growth, and the ever-looming shadow of tariffs. The market is a fickle mistress, but with a dash of luck and a sprinkle of savvy, AEO might yet ride the wave. 📈

Read More

2026-01-13 10:13