Games Accused Of Pandering With Sudden Diversity DLCs

by

The video game industry often deals with tricky discussions about including diverse characters and stories in popular game series. Developers commonly use downloadable content and updates to add depth to existing characters or introduce new viewpoints. While these additions are often praised for improving representation, some players see them as attempts to simply appeal to current social trends. This conflict is especially noticeable when changes are made after a game’s initial release, through expansions or story updates. Several games have faced criticism for content added that some considered forced or insincere.

‘The Last Of Us’ (2013)

The ‘Left Behind’ expansion delved into the connection between Ellie and her friend Riley. This sparked controversy, with some players claiming the story felt forced because Ellie’s sexual orientation wasn’t previously established in the main game. The focus on a romantic relationship between the two characters led to a lot of online discussion about whether the subplot was necessary. Some critics believed the developers were prioritizing positive public perception with this content. However, the studio maintained that the story was an important and integral part of Ellie’s development as a character.

‘Assassin’s Creed Odyssey’ (2018)

The ‘Legacy of the First Blade’ expansion sparked controversy by initially requiring players to have a heterosexual relationship to continue their family line. Following criticism, the developers revised the content to give players more freedom in choosing their character’s romantic interests. Some players believed this change was a response to criticism and an effort to be more inclusive. The situation demonstrated the challenge of staying true to a historical setting while also meeting players’ expectations for diverse representation. This update is still frequently discussed as a significant example of how games can change character options after release.

‘Horizon Forbidden West’ (2022)

The ‘Burning Shores’ expansion allowed players to develop a romantic relationship for Aloy with a new female character. This sparked negative reviews on some platforms, with some players feeling the romance felt out of place. These players argued that the game hadn’t hinted at this side of Aloy’s personality beforehand. However, the developers defended their choice, saying it was a logical step in Aloy’s character development. Despite the backlash, many players appreciated the expansion’s emotional storytelling.

‘Overwatch 2’ (2022)

During a recent update, the game’s creators shared a story revealing Pharah’s sexual orientation. Some players believe this was a calculated effort to improve public perception at a time when many were unhappy with the game. This led to accusations of ‘pandering,’ as these kinds of character details are usually revealed outside of the game itself. The studio has often used external sources to share character backstories, which continues to be a point of contention among players. While some fans appreciate learning more about the characters, others feel it’s a shallow way to appear diverse.

‘Apex Legends’ (2019)

The game regularly adds new characters from a wide variety of backgrounds. While many players appreciate this inclusivity, some have criticized the timing of these additions, suggesting they feel like an attempt to appeal to a specific group. The game’s stories often center on the personal lives of its characters, showcased in trailers and background information. Developers explain that having a diverse cast of characters is meant to represent the game’s worldwide audience.

‘The Sims 4’ (2014)

The ‘My Wedding Stories’ expansion received attention for featuring a same-sex couple in its marketing, which led to it being temporarily unavailable in some areas. Some players and critics believed the developers prioritized sending a social message over ensuring the game worked well. The expansion launched with many technical problems, reinforcing this idea. These critics felt the studio was more focused on appearing progressive than on delivering a polished gaming experience. Eventually, the developers released several updates to fix the issues.

‘Guilty Gear Strive’ (2021)

Adding Bridget to the game as a playable character caused a lot of discussion about her identity and past. Though she’d been in earlier games, her story was different this time, leading some players to believe the developers had altered her background to reflect current social issues. This change sparked a lot of debate online about the studio’s motivations. The developers explained that Bridget’s evolution was simply a continuation of her personal growth.

‘Dead By Daylight’ (2016)

Recent updates to the game’s character histories have confirmed that David King is the first openly gay character players can control. This information was shared long after David King was originally introduced. While some fans believe the developers changed the character’s story to meet diversity goals, others appreciated the addition as a way to enrich his background. The game studio is consistently adding details to its characters’ stories through regular updates and new cosmetic items.

‘Mass Effect: Andromeda’ (2017)

After players raised concerns, the game received an update that revised the dialogue of Hainly Abram, a transgender character. Some felt the initial writing was insensitive, while others believed the change was made due to online criticism. The update made the character’s introduction feel more authentic. This incident sparked a wider conversation about how diversity is portrayed in big role-playing games. The developers apologized for the original version and promised to improve representation in future games.

‘Street Fighter 6’ (2023)

When the game introduced Eternity as a host for special events, some players accused the developers of simply trying to appeal to current trends. These critics believed the character’s design and personality felt forced and were included only to meet diversity expectations. The discussion became more heated as players contrasted Eternity with the game’s long-standing characters. However, other fans praised Eternity as a lively and welcome addition to the game’s world. Despite the online debate, the studio hasn’t made any major changes to the character.

‘Dragon Age: Inquisition’ (2014)

Okay, so the ‘Trespasser’ DLC really wrapped things up for a lot of characters, especially if you were into the romance options – there were a bunch, and it was cool to see those stories finished. Honestly, some players thought the DLC focused too much on those relationships, like the devs were just trying to please certain fans. The game was already pretty good about having a diverse cast, but this felt like it went even further. I saw some people complaining that characters like the Iron Bull and Cremisius felt…written a certain way, like they were pandering. But the developers have always said they wanted to include all kinds of people and identities in their world, and I think that’s a good thing.

‘Mortal Kombat 1’ (2023)

The ‘Khaos Reigns’ expansion and subsequent story updates made the relationship between Mileena and Tanya officially romantic. While some longtime fans of the series felt this differed from the established backstory, critics suggested the change was aimed at attracting a wider audience. The developers responded that the new timeline gave them the freedom to reimagine classic characters. This romantic storyline continues to be a debated topic among dedicated players.

‘Starfield’ (2023)

An update to this space exploration game focused on letting players choose pronouns and offering a wider range of character backgrounds. Although these options were available when the game first launched, later marketing materials really emphasized them. Some players thought this drew attention away from more pressing problems with the game’s performance and gameplay. The addition of these features sparked a lot of discussion online about how important identity is in role-playing games. The game developers are still adding new content and expansions.

‘Cyberpunk 2077’ (2020)

After a difficult launch, the game received significant updates, including more choices for romantic relationships and more detailed dialogue, especially for characters from diverse backgrounds. While some reviewers thought these changes were meant to distract from the game’s original issues, many players welcomed the added depth to the game’s social interactions and the richer development of the Night City world. Some also saw the expanded relationship options as a way to address concerns from a passionate part of the player base.

‘Baldur’s Gate 3’ (2023)

The game is generally welcoming to all players, and recent updates have focused on improving the different romantic relationships available. Some players felt the developers were spending too much time on these features instead of fixing bugs and improving how the game runs. The game offers a lot of freedom in how players build relationships with other characters. Some critics thought the focus on romance was excessive, pointing to it in the game’s update descriptions. Despite this, the game has received many awards for its strong story and well-developed characters.

‘Life Is Strange: True Colors’ (2021)

The ‘Wavelengths’ DLC centered around the character Steph and her experiences as part of the LGBTQ+ community. While some players thought the DLC prioritized social commentary over a strong story or fun gameplay, many fans appreciated its realistic portrayal of characters and themes. The series as a whole has always made an effort to include diverse perspectives and voices.

‘Fire Emblem Engage’ (2023)

The translated version of the ‘Expansion Pass’ included adjustments to how characters spoke and how romantic storylines ended. Some players felt the translation team changed the original meaning from the Japanese version to better suit Western audiences, sparking a discussion about representation and censorship in video game translations. Critics claimed these changes seemed like an attempt to appeal to players in a specific region. Despite feedback from some fans, the developers have kept these changes in place.

‘Disney Dreamlight Valley’ (2023)

During Pride Month, the game received rainbow-themed items and quests promoting inclusivity. While some players appreciated these additions as a way to create a more welcoming environment, others felt they didn’t fit the game’s family-friendly focus and accused the developers of simply trying to appeal to a wider audience through marketing. The developers have consistently released similar themed content for different holidays and events.

‘World Of Warcraft’ (2004)

The ‘Dragonflight’ expansion and its updates brought in a variety of new characters with different backgrounds and identities. While some longtime players appreciated this, others felt it strayed from the classic, epic fantasy war setting the game was known for. One particular point of discussion was the inclusion of a transgender character in a significant role, with some critics claiming the writers were prioritizing current social issues over the game’s established history. The developers, however, have explained they aim to make the world of Azeroth reflect the diversity of its players worldwide.

‘Destiny 2’ (2017)

Recent story updates revealed that the characters Osiris and Saint-14 have been in a romantic relationship for quite some time. Although fans had guessed at this for a while, the official confirmation in the downloadable content led to accusations that the developers were simply trying to please fans. Some players also felt that focusing on the characters’ personal lives took away from the main science fiction story. However, the developers intended these story elements to make the game’s central conflict more emotionally impactful. This relationship is now an important and established part of the game’s overall story.

‘Valorant’ (2020)

Recent story updates, shared through social media and in-game videos, revealed a romantic relationship between the characters Killjoy and Raze. Some players believe this reveal was intentionally timed to generate more excitement during a competitive period. Whenever the game’s story expands through things like social media posts, some people accuse the developers of trying too hard to please everyone. The developers have created a diverse group of agents, each from different parts of the world, to attract a wide range of players. Despite the online debate, many fans enjoy and anticipate these story updates.

‘League Of Legends’ (2009)

Pride events frequently add backstory to existing champions like Varus and K’Sante. Some players think these updates are made to improve the company’s reputation and respond to public feedback. The events often emphasize a champion’s identity through special missions and in-game rewards. However, some critics feel these additions seem tacked on, as if the characters weren’t originally conceived with these characteristics. Despite this, the game studio continues to prioritize diverse representation with its large cast of characters.

‘Spider-Man 2’ (2023)

After the game was released, updates and extra missions highlighted diverse communities and addressed social issues. While some players appreciated this effort to make the game’s world feel more realistic, others found these additions felt out of place in a superhero action game and came across as overly instructive. A particular mission centered around a cultural center drew criticism from those who felt it was an attempt to appeal to specific groups. Despite these disagreements, critics generally praised the game’s overall story and how it played.

‘Hogwarts Legacy’ (2023)

The decision to include Sirona Ryan, a transgender witch, sparked discussion among players both before and after the game launched. Some felt her inclusion seemed forced, as if to counter the controversial opinions of the game’s creator. Others believed the character didn’t fit the game’s historical context. However, the developers explained they aimed to create a more diverse and inclusive wizarding world, and Sirona Ryan remains a significant example of the game’s varied non-player characters.

‘Saints Row’ (2022)

The downloadable content and updates for this game’s revival kept featuring a young and diverse group of characters. However, many longtime fans felt this was a deliberate attempt to attract new players, moving away from the darker, more realistic tone of the original games. The expansions’ emphasis on social issues and trends popular with millennials became a major source of disagreement. Some players believed the game was trying to appeal to people who weren’t originally interested in the series, and these changes ultimately made it difficult to maintain a dedicated fanbase.

‘Ghostwire: Tokyo’ (2022)

As a fan, I was really excited about the ‘Spider’s Thread’ update – it added a ton of new story and characters! I noticed a lot more diversity in this update than in the original game, which some people felt was done just to meet current expectations for representation. It’s true the game is deeply rooted in Japanese folklore, and a few fans worried that these new additions took away from that core feeling. But honestly, the developers did a great job expanding the gameplay and giving us more to do. Even with the discussions about the story, most people really liked the update because it ran so much smoother and just felt more polished overall.

‘Battlefield V’ (2018)

Adding a variety of new character skins and options after the game launched caused a lot of debate about how well it represented history. Some players thought including female soldiers in certain positions was done to appeal to current trends rather than historical fact. This discussion started with the game’s first trailer and continued for years. The developers explained they wanted to give players more ways to personalize their experience. This disagreement ultimately became a well-known part of the game’s story within the shooter game community.

‘Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare II’ (2022)

Some players criticized the introduction of ‘Pride Month’ themed items and banners, calling it a superficial attempt by the company to appeal to a wider audience. They argued that these items didn’t fit the serious, realistic tone of the game, which centers on global military conflicts. The discussion became heated online, with players debating whether social issues have a place in competitive gaming. However, other fans welcomed the additions as a way to show inclusivity and support for all players. The game studio has consistently released different themed cosmetic items for all of its games.

‘Rainbow Six Siege’ (2015)

The addition of operators like Flores and Sens increased the diversity of characters in the game. However, some players criticized the developers for focusing heavily on the operators’ personal stories in updates. Concerns arose that the developers were simply trying to appeal to certain groups by including details about characters’ sexual orientation or gender identity in a game centered around tactical combat. The developers explained that they aim to create a team of operators who feel like real people from all over the world. Despite the debate, the game continues to be a leading competitive title in its genre.

‘Final Fantasy XIV’ (2013)

Recent updates to the in-game marriage system, known as the ‘Ceremony of Eternal Bonding,’ have removed restrictions based on player gender. While many players welcomed this change, some believed it was intended to appeal more to Western players. Later updates that removed gender-specific clothing and features also led to similar discussions. Some critics argued these changes strayed from the game’s original artistic style. However, the developers have consistently focused on giving players more ways to express themselves within the game.

‘Sea Of Thieves’ (2018)

So, the developers added rainbow flags and some Pride-themed stuff to the game with recent updates, and it’s caused a bit of a stir. Some people think it’s cool to see more representation and a way to personalize your pirate, which I get. Others feel like it’s bringing real-world issues into a fantasy game, and I can see their point too. The studio has said they want everyone to feel welcome, and honestly, these items are just a small part of all the cool cosmetic options they keep adding. It’s been a bit of a debate, but I’m just here to sail the seas and look good doing it!

‘Fallout 76’ (2018)

The ‘Wastelanders’ update and its expansions added many new characters with different stories. Some players thought these additions were in response to the initial lack of human characters in the game. Some critics claimed the developers were focusing on diversity to distract from the game’s problems at launch. However, the game has improved a lot since it first came out, and the developers are now concentrating on creating a vibrant world with a variety of groups. The game’s community is also well-known for being welcoming and inclusive.

‘Borderlands 3’ (2019)

The ‘Guns, Love, and Tentacles’ expansion centered around a wedding between two male characters, which sparked debate among players. Some felt the developers were promoting a particular viewpoint, while others appreciated the game’s consistently diverse and quirky characters. The DLC received praise from fans who enjoyed its funny and heartfelt story. The game is well-known for its over-the-top style and commitment to including a wide range of characters.

‘Tell Me Why’ (2020)

This game, released in episodes, prominently featured a transgender character, making their identity a key part of both the story and how the game was advertised. Some players felt the studio was simply trying to appeal to a specific audience by highlighting this aspect. The developers worked with advocacy groups to make sure the character felt genuine and respectful. However, some critics thought that focusing too much on the character’s identity detracted from the game’s mystery and overall gameplay. Despite this, many critics praised the game for handling sensitive themes with care and thoughtfulness.

‘The Outer Worlds’ (2019)

Parvati’s storyline, focusing on her romance, was a popular part of the game for some players, but others didn’t appreciate it. A few felt the inclusion of an asexual character felt forced or catered to a very specific audience. However, many praised the storyline’s honest and original writing. The game also offers a humorous critique of corporate life, which some felt clashed with the generally sincere and diverse characters. The developers are known for creating well-developed and varied characters in their role-playing games.

‘Animal Crossing: New Horizons’ (2020)

After the game launched, updates were released that added new hairstyles and made clothing and character features available to all players, regardless of gender. While some players believed these changes were made in response to calls for more inclusive options online, others felt they weren’t necessary for the game. Despite the debate, the updates were generally well-received by the community, and the game itself proved to be very popular. These changes ultimately allowed players more freedom to customize their characters in the relaxing island setting.

‘Minecraft’ (2011)

Okay, so the game got some new default character skins, and honestly, it felt a little… late to the party for some people. A lot of us felt like the original characters were perfect as they were, and this just seemed like they were trying too hard to please everyone. The devs said they wanted new players to be able to see themselves in the game right from the start, which is a good goal, I guess. It was part of a bigger push to keep the game fresh and appeal to players all over the world. Still, it’s one of the best-selling games ever, and it’s awesome to see such a huge and diverse community playing it.

‘Roblox’ (2006)

The platform has been regularly updated with new avatar choices and ways to connect with others. While some long-time users feel these changes are too focused on current social media trends, the platform itself hosts millions of games created by its users, covering a wide range of interests. Some people believe the company is attempting to influence the platform’s social environment with these updates, but the company insists it’s just giving its diverse community more ways to express themselves.

‘Gotham Knights’ (2022)

Recent updates to character backgrounds and conversations in the game have given us a deeper look into the heroes’ lives. However, some DC fans believe these changes don’t align with the original comic books. The addition of pride flags and other social elements sparked criticism, with some players accusing the developers of trying to appeal to specific groups rather than focusing on gameplay. The developers explained they wanted to present a contemporary take on the Bat Family within a dynamic Gotham City.

‘Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League’ (2024)

Some players have criticized recent updates for focusing too much on current social issues. When the game first launched and struggled to gain players, accusations arose that the developers were prioritizing diversity to attract a wider audience, rather than staying true to the game’s original focus on a live-service shooter experience. The game does feature a wide range of diverse villains who are central characters. Despite the criticism, the studio is still releasing new content as planned.

‘Forspoken’ (2023)

The ‘In Tanta We Trust’ expansion added more depth to the story of the main character and the world of Athia. However, some players thought the hero’s personality felt forced to appeal to current trends. The game received criticism online for its writing and the inclusion of many different female characters. Many critics felt the expansion didn’t adequately fix the story problems people had with the original game. Ultimately, the development studio was absorbed into Square Enix due to the game’s sales.

‘Genshin Impact’ (2020)

Adding new areas like Sumeru and Fontaine sparked conversations about how cultures and skin tones were portrayed in the game. Some players wanted to see more diversity in character designs, while others thought the game was changing too much to appeal to Western audiences. This showed how difficult it is to create a game enjoyed by people all over the world with different expectations. The developers keep adding new characters with interesting stories, and the game continues to be very popular, even with these ongoing discussions among players.

‘Tales Of Arise’ (2021)

The ‘Beyond the Dawn’ expansion included more conversations and scenes exploring the relationships and lives of the main characters. While the original game’s story was well-received, this expansion received a mixed reaction from players and critics. Some felt the added content wasn’t needed and seemed to focus on current storytelling trends. Reviewers suggested it felt like an afterthought, rather than a natural continuation of the game’s story, though the developers intended it to wrap up the characters’ personal arcs.

‘Watch Dogs: Legion’ (2020)

The recent ‘Bloodline’ expansion and game updates added many new characters with different backgrounds and abilities. However, some reviewers thought the way these characters were included felt like an artificial attempt to promote social harmony. This came at a time when the game’s London setting was already sparking political conversations. A few players also felt the emphasis on diversity overshadowed the game’s somewhat repetitive gameplay. The developers designed the game to mirror the diverse population of a contemporary city.

‘Star Wars: The Old Republic’ (2011)

I’ve been playing this MMO for years, and it’s been interesting to see how it’s evolved. One of the biggest changes came with later updates when they added options for same-sex relationships – something that wasn’t there at the beginning. It definitely sparked some debate among the older fans, with some feeling it didn’t really fit with what the game originally was. The developers explained they were just listening to players who’d been asking for more inclusivity, which I get. Others thought it was more about the game trying to stay current with how society is changing. It’s just one of the many shifts the game has seen over the past ten years, and it still has a really loyal group of players.

‘Fortnite’ (2017)

The game’s recent introduction of ‘Icon Series’ skins and ‘Pride’ events in its store has led to criticism, with some players accusing the developers of simply trying to appeal to current social trends to increase sales, especially among younger players. Given the game’s huge cultural influence and history of partnerships with celebrities and brands, critics suggest these diverse skins are more about marketing than genuine inclusivity. Despite the criticism, the game continues to be incredibly popular with a large global audience.

‘Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical’ (2023)

The ‘Orpheus’ expansion added new songs and romantic options to the game, building on its already large cast of characters. While some players enjoyed the focus on relationships and social issues, others felt it overshadowed the main storyline. The developers set out to retell Greek myths in a contemporary way, emphasizing individual identity. However, some critics believed the game catered too much to audiences interested in theater and social justice topics. Despite these criticisms, many praised the game’s original idea and excellent voice acting.

Please share your thoughts on these controversial game updates and DLCs in the comments.

Read More

2026-01-12 08:21