Two Titans of the U.S. Stock Market: VTI vs. ITOT

by

  • Both ETFs mirror the U.S. stock market with nearly identical sector weights and top holdings

  • VTI looms larger in assets and liquidity, a colossus against ITOT’s modest scale

  • Costs and yields align, leaving the choice to the weight of legacy and infrastructure

In the quiet corners of the stock market, two titans stand-Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI +0.33%) and iShares Core S&P Total US Stock Market ETF (ITOT +0.34%). They offer the same broad exposure, yet VTI’s dominance is written in the numbers: a fortress of $2 trillion under management, while ITOT’s $78.6 billion hums a softer tune. For the common investor, this is a duel of giants, where the difference between a cathedral and a chapel matters more than it seems.

Both funds claim to own the entire U.S. equity market-large, mid, and small-cap stocks, stitched together with the same thread of low cost. Yet the gulf between them is not in what they hold, but in how they hold it. VTI, with its 3,598 stocks and 24.5-year track record, is a machine honed by time. ITOT, with 2,497 stocks, is a capable workhorse, but its wheels lack the grease of VTI’s scale. The question is not which is better, but which is more likely to outlast the next crisis.

Snapshot (cost & size)

Metric ITOT VTI
Issuer iShares Vanguard
Expense ratio 0.03% 0.03%
1-yr return (as of Nov. 14, 2025) 12.1% 12.2%
Dividend yield 1.1% 1.1%
Beta 1.04 (0.10)
AUM $78.6 billion $2.0 trillion

Beta measures price volatility relative to the S&P 500; beta is calculated from five-year weekly returns. The 1-yr return represents total return over the trailing 12 months.

The cost of entry is the same for both, a cruel symmetry for those who seek affordability. But the real power lies in scale. VTI’s AUM is not just a number-it is a force, a gravitational pull that stabilizes trades and swallows market noise. ITOT, meanwhile, is the underdog, efficient but lacking the heft to command respect in moments of panic.

Performance & risk comparison

Metric ITOT VTI
Max drawdown (5 y) (25.36%) (25.36%)
Growth of $1,000 over 5 years $1,778 $1,778

What’s inside

VTI, with its 3,598 stocks, is a mosaic of the market’s soul. Technology reigns supreme at 34%, followed by financial services (13%) and consumer cyclicals (11%). Its top holdings-NVIDIA, Microsoft, Apple-are not kings but serfs in a vast empire, each contributing less than 0.1%. There is no leverage, no ESG screens, no frills-just the raw, unvarnished market. It is a fund for those who believe in the system, not its ornaments.

ITOT mirrors this structure, but its 2,497 stocks feel like a smaller village in the same landscape. The sector weights are similar, the top holdings the same, but the scale is different. Both are passively managed, but VTI’s depth is a fortress, while ITOT is a sturdy cottage. For the investor who wants to sleep soundly, the difference is in the walls.

Foolish take

These funds are not just tools-they are legacies. VTI is the elder statesman, built on decades of trust and liquidity. ITOT is the ambitious newcomer, reliable but still proving itself. The choice between them is not a matter of right or wrong, but of philosophy. VTI appeals to those who see the market as a river to be dammed, while ITOT attracts those who prefer to float with the current.

For the working man, the gig worker, the frustrated end-user, VTI offers a fortress. Its size and liquidity are not just numbers but a promise of stability in a world that thrives on chaos. ITOT, though smaller, is no slouch. It is a viable path for those already aligned with iShares or who seek simplicity. Yet VTI’s resilience is its crown jewel. Over time, its broader reach and tax efficiency become a quiet advantage, like a well-worn plow in a farmer’s hands.

At first glance, the two look interchangeable. But the devil is in the details-liquidity, scale, and the ability to absorb shocks without flinching. VTI is the anchor for those who build their lives on the market’s tide. ITOT is the companion for those who want to ride the wave. Both are valid, but one is a lighthouse, the other a lantern.

Glossary

ETF: A beast of the stock exchange, cloaking a basket of securities in a single ticker.
Expense ratio: The price of admission, paid in percentages.
Assets under management (AUM): The weight of a fund’s presence, measured in billions.
Liquidity: The ease with which a trade can be made without ripples.
Dividend yield: The crumbs from the market’s table, expressed as a percentage.
Beta: A measure of how wildly a fund dances compared to the S&P 500.
Max drawdown: The deepest pit a fund has clawed its way out of.
Sector allocation: The distribution of bets across industries.
Leverage: Borrowed strength, often followed by borrowed trouble.
Hedge: A shield raised against the sword of volatility.
ESG screens: Filters that exclude companies based on morality or governance.
Passively managed: A fund that follows the herd, not the stars.

The market is a theater of giants, but the actors are ordinary. Choose your stage wisely. 🏛️

Read More

2025-11-20 02:53