The 25 Best Hallmark Channel Actors, Ranked

Hallmark movies are known for their heartwarming stories and familiar faces. A handful of actors appear again and again, becoming beloved stars of the channel. They often lead ongoing series or star in multiple event movies each year, consistently delivering the charm viewers expect. Here’s a look at some of the most popular actors who frequently appear in Hallmark productions, and the projects that helped make them fan favorites.

25. Victor Webster

Victor Webster is a familiar face on Hallmark, starring in many mystery and romance movies. He’s best known for his role in the popular ‘MatchMaker Mysteries’ series, and has also appeared in holiday favorites like ‘A Christmas Cookie Catastrophe’. He often plays charming and relaxed characters in both modern romantic comedies and gentle mystery stories.

24. Aimee Teegarden

Aimee Teegarden is known for starring in contemporary Hallmark romance movies that focus on characters building careers and finding love again. She’s appeared in films like ‘My Christmas Family Tree’ and ‘Christmas Class Reunion’, often playing strong, working women who discover romance in surprising ways. Her movies emphasize genuine emotional connections and feel very realistic.

23. Marcus Rosner

Marcus Rosner is a familiar face in feel-good movies, often playing the romantic hero, especially in stories about love and weddings. He’s known for his roles in ‘The Love Club’ series and ‘Notes of Autumn’. Rosner typically portrays characters who are both successful and enjoy the outdoors, and his movies range from lighthearted spring romances to cozy holiday films.

22. Heather Hemmens

Heather Hemmens is a familiar face on Hallmark and Hallmark Movies and Mysteries, having recently appeared in several original movies, including ‘A Pinch of Portugal’ and ‘Christmas in Vienna’. She often plays driven characters, particularly those involved in creative fields like cooking. Plus, she frequently incorporates music and dance into her work.

21. Wes Brown

I just love Wes Brown in these Hallmark movies! He’s always playing these really charming guys in these cozy small towns – the scenery is always beautiful too. I’ve seen him in things like ‘Under the Autumn Moon’ and ‘Christmas in Mississippi’. He’s great at playing characters like ranchers, writers, or guys who come back home, and the movies always feel so warm and focus on the importance of family and community. He really knows how to make a heartwarming film!

20. Rachel Boston

Rachel Boston frequently stars in heartwarming fall and holiday movies, often featuring characters who are artists, business owners, or both. She’s known for films like ‘A Christmas Carousel’ and ‘The Last Bridesmaid’. Her movies commonly blend themes of romance with creative pursuits like art, event planning, or music, and she often works with the same actors in different seasonal films.

19. Holly Robinson Peete

Holly Robinson Peete is known for playing a TV chef who solves mysteries in the ‘Morning Show Mysteries’ series. She’s also a popular face in holiday movies, including the ‘Christmas in Evergreen’ films. Her work often focuses on themes of family, food, and giving back to the community, and she brings a friendly, approachable style to the mystery genre.

18. Chris McNally

Chris McNally is a main actor on the show ‘When Calls the Heart’, playing the character Lucas Bouchard. He also stars in Hallmark’s standalone romance movies, like ‘Sailing Into Love’. Many of his Hallmark roles involve sophisticated characters who discover love in rustic or seaside locations. He’s comfortable acting in both historical and modern stories.

17. Pascale Hutton

Pascale Hutton is known for her role as Rosemary Coulter in the series ‘When Calls the Heart.’ She also leads in contemporary romantic movies such as ‘You Had Me at Aloha.’ Throughout her career, she’s appeared in projects that blend humor and emotional stories, and she often works alongside her frequent co-star, Kavan Smith, in various films and shows.

16. Kevin McGarry

Kevin McGarry is known for playing Nathan Grant in ‘When Calls the Heart’ and starring in movies like ‘My Grown Up Christmas List’. He frequently takes on roles as people in helping professions – like first responders, teachers, or those who have served in the military – and consistently delivers a reliable and grounded performance in both long-running shows and standalone romantic films.

15. Alison Sweeney

I’ve been watching Alison Sweeney for years, and she’s become a Hallmark staple! She’s best known for playing Hannah Swensen, a baker who always seems to stumble into solving mysteries – it’s a really cozy series. But she’s not just about baking and sleuthing; she also shines in more traditional romance films like ‘The Wedding Veil Journey’. What’s interesting is that a lot of her Hallmark movies have this fun combination of food and investigation, and she’s increasingly getting involved behind the scenes as a producer, too. She clearly has a knack for bringing these charming stories to life, both in front of and behind the camera.

14. Kristoffer Polaha

Kristoffer Polaha is known for playing detectives in the ‘Mystery 101’ series, often paired with a criminology professor. He also stars in romantic movies, similar to ‘Dater’s Handbook’ and ‘A Winter’s Dream’, where his characters are usually both funny and genuine. You can often see him in new movies released during the fall and winter seasons.

13. Taylor Cole

Taylor Cole frequently stars in Hallmark’s travel and romance movies. You might recognize her from films like ‘One Winter Weekend’ and the ‘Ruby Herring Mysteries’ series. She often plays characters with interesting careers, such as journalists, photographers, and business owners. Her movies are known for showcasing beautiful locations like resorts, ski towns, and beach destinations.

12. Ryan Paevey

I absolutely love Ryan Paevey! He’s become my go-to actor for feel-good Christmas movies and fun summer films. I’ve watched him in things like ‘Two Tickets to Paradise’ and ‘Coyote Creek Christmas,’ and he always plays these charming guys – architects, writers, outdoor adventurers – who fall in love while on some kind of journey. What I really enjoy is that his movies are always filmed in beautiful places, like islands or mountains, and they always have that sweet ‘meet cute’ moment where the main characters first connect.

11. Autumn Reeser

Autumn Reeser is known for her roles in series of romantic films, especially those with a seasonal or heartwarming theme. She’s a lead in ‘The Wedding Veil’ trilogy, which blends art history with stories of strong female friendships. She also appears in movies like ‘Always Amore,’ often playing successful women who find a better life balance through love and relationships.

10. Kimberley Sustad

Kimberley Sustad is a talented actress known for her charming and imaginative romantic comedies, and her strong on-screen connection with her fellow actors. She’s starred in popular films like ‘Christmas by Starlight’ and ‘A Christmas Cookie Catastrophe,’ and often helps create projects from behind the scenes. Her characters are known for being both funny and heartwarming, often focusing on family relationships.

9. Brennan Elliott

As a big fan of Hallmark movies, I’ve really come to appreciate Brennan Elliott. He’s become a familiar face across both Hallmark channels, always popping up in those cozy mystery and romance plots. You probably know him from ‘Crossword Mysteries’ – he has great chemistry with Lacey Chabert, they work together a lot! What I like is how versatile he is; he’s played everything from doctors to reporters and even small business owners. But mostly, he just feels like a solid, dependable leading man – the kind you need to anchor those multi-movie series.

8. Paul Campbell

Paul Campbell is known for blending humor and genuine emotion in his popular movies. He’s a writer and actor, most notably co-creating ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby.’ He also appears in charming romantic comedies, often set in workplaces or during travel, like ‘The Santa Stakeout.’ He frequently works alongside Andrew Walker and Tyler Hynes.

7. Nikki DeLoach

Nikki DeLoach stars in heartfelt romance movies that often feature music and the importance of family. She’s known for films like ‘Two Turtle Doves’, ‘Five More Minutes’, and ‘The Perfect Catch’. She frequently collaborates with writers to bring touching, relatable stories to the screen, often exploring themes of loss, new beginnings, and the power of community.

6. Luke Macfarlane

Luke Macfarlane is a popular actor known for his many successful Hallmark holiday movies, including titles like ‘A Shoe Addict’s Christmas’, ‘Chateau Christmas’, and ‘Taking a Shot at Love’. He often brings his experience with music and sports to his characters, and has starred in both touching dramas and fun, romantic comedies.

5. Candace Cameron Bure

Candace Cameron Bure was the star of the popular ‘Aurora Teagarden Mysteries,’ where she played a librarian who solved crimes. She also became well-known for her many Christmas movies, which were frequently shown on television. Her films often focused on the importance of family and the cozy atmosphere of small towns. Over the years, she played a significant role in developing the channel’s approach to mystery and holiday programming.

4. Erin Krakow

Let me tell you, Erin Krakow just radiates warmth on screen. She’s become the absolute heart of ‘When Calls the Heart’ as Elizabeth Thatcher, and she’s fantastic in those sweet, seasonal Hallmark romances like ‘It Was Always You’. What I’ve noticed is, she consistently plays these incredibly grounded characters – often a teacher or someone who genuinely cares for others – and they’re always deeply involved in their communities. She’s a real anchor for these stories, whether they’re set way back on the frontier or in a more modern small town. She just brings a lovely, comforting presence to everything she does.

3. Tyler Hynes

I’m a huge fan of Tyler Hynes! He’s been in so many of the network’s most popular recent movies – I especially loved ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’, ‘Always Amore’, and ‘An Unexpected Christmas’. It’s fun to see him play these interesting characters, usually someone with a creative job like a marketing professional, chef, or writer, and I love how his stories often move between city life and charming small towns. Honestly, it feels like there’s always a new Tyler Hynes movie to look forward to, especially in the fall and during the holidays!

2. Andrew Walker

As a big Hallmark movie fan, I’ve noticed Andrew Walker is everywhere! He’s definitely one of their most frequent leading men, and he seems to play all sorts of roles. I’ve seen him in everything from heartwarming stories like ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ to cute romances centered around food, like ‘Maple Valley Christmas’. What I really like is that his characters are often entrepreneurs, running the family business or starting something new. Plus, it’s always fun to see him paired up with familiar faces – Hallmark really likes to bring back its popular co-stars, and he’s often one of them!

1. Lacey Chabert

Lacey Chabert is known as the queen of Hallmark romance, and she also helps produce many of the movies she stars in. She’s the lead in ‘The Wedding Veil’ series and popular holiday films like ‘Christmas Waltz’. Her movies often focus on themes like fashion, art, or baking, and she frequently works with the same creative teams. She consistently stars in Hallmark’s biggest and most anticipated premieres, whether they’re for the holidays or any other time of year.

Tell us who you would add to this list in the comments.

2025-10-30 17:18