The 10 Most Underrated Amanda Seyfried Movies, Ranked (From Least to Most Underrated)

Amanda Seyfried has starred in a diverse range of films, including thrillers, musicals, romantic comedies, and serious dramas. She’s worked with directors who have very specific and recognizable filmmaking styles. Whether she’s the lead or a supporting character, Seyfried consistently delivers performances that are both delicate and carefully crafted, making her well-suited for many different types of movies.

This list showcases ten films that represent the range of her work, including projects from major studios, movies based on books, and critically acclaimed independent films. For each film, you’ll find information about the characters and the people who made it, helping you understand its place in film history. The selection starts with more mainstream genres and gradually moves towards well-respected dramas, finishing with a touching story and a strong cast.

‘Red Riding Hood’ (2011)

Okay, so I just watched this fantasy thriller, and Amanda Seyfried is fantastic as Valerie – she’s this young woman caught in a really creepy situation with a werewolf terrorizing her village. Catherine Hardwicke directed it, and the cast is seriously good – Gary Oldman plays this determined investigator, and you’ve also got Shiloh Fernandez, Max Irons, and the always-amazing Julie Christie. Visually, it’s stunning. Think classic fairy tale vibes – lots of shadowy, moonlit forests and really striking colors. The director uses a lot of close-ups, which really puts you right *in* Valerie’s shoes and lets you see everything from her perspective. It’s a really immersive experience.

The movie unfolds like a classic mystery, keeping you guessing while also drawing on local legends. The story explores both the everyday conflicts within a small town and the growing sense of something supernatural happening. Amanda Seyfried’s character is at the heart of it all, dealing with both a troubled romance and family expectations. As the truth comes out, we learn how the characters’ pasts are connected to the central mystery and the dramatic climax.

‘Anon’ (2018)

I recently watched this really cool neo-noir thriller by Andrew Niccol, and Amanda Seyfried is fantastic as this mysterious hacker character, simply known as ‘The Girl.’ The story takes place in a future where everyone’s life is constantly recorded with augmented reality, which creates this incredibly tense atmosphere. Clive Owen plays the detective, and he’s trying to crack these murders where the victims seem to have vanished without a digital footprint. What’s really clever is how the film constantly jumps between what the characters are seeing and what they’re actively trying to conceal – it totally impacts the rhythm and visual style of every scene, making it a really unique experience.

The show creates a polished and visually restrained world, and the mystery unfolds through a tense back-and-forth between Seyfried and Owen’s characters. It delves into themes of privacy, being watched, and who we really are, with Seyfried delivering a captivating performance that embodies the struggle against a system that believes it has all the answers.

‘Lovelace’ (2013)

I just finished watching a really compelling biopic starring Amanda Seyfried as Linda Lovelace. It’s directed by Rob Epstein and Jeffrey Friedman, and the supporting cast is fantastic – Peter Sarsgaard, Sharon Stone, Chris Noth, Juno Temple, and even James Franco all deliver strong performances. The film doesn’t just show us the public image Lovelace was forced into; it really digs into the complicated, often heartbreaking, reality behind it. It’s a fascinating look at her journey, from initial fame to becoming an advocate later in life, and the filmmakers skillfully weave between the persona the industry created and the private struggles she endured.

The play skillfully blends glamorous performance scenes with realistic family moments to highlight how power shifts between characters. Seyfried’s acting powerfully shows the character’s transformation through changes in her voice, body language, and emotional state, moving from being taken advantage of to finally speaking out. The story unfolds through interviews and memories, revealing how a public image was built and then challenged.

‘A Mouthful of Air’ (2021)

Amanda Seyfried stars as Julie Davis, a writer and new mom, in a drama directed and written by Amy Koppelman, who adapted it from her own novel. The film explores Julie’s struggles with postpartum depression, and also features Finn Wittrock, Paul Giamatti, Amy Irving, and Britt Robertson. The movie focuses on everyday settings – homes, doctor’s offices, and quiet city scenes – to show how Julie’s feeling of security changes.

The movie creates a close, personal feel through gentle lighting and focused shots on characters’ voices and breathing, enhanced by a subtle musical score. Amanda Seyfried plays a parent who uses her imagination to soothe her child, all while secretly dealing with her own difficulties. The story unfolds through both therapy sessions and family moments, showing when the character finally feels able to express her true feelings.

‘Jennifer’s Body’ (2009)

Written by Diablo Cody and directed by Karyn Kusama, the horror film features Amanda Seyfried as Anita, a high school student who begins to believe her best friend, Jennifer (played by Megan Fox), is responsible for a series of deaths at school. The movie also stars Johnny Simmons, Adam Brody, and J. K. Simmons. It explores how the desire for popularity and a mysterious occult event contribute to the unraveling of a friendship, all set against the backdrop of typical teen life – classrooms, parties, and the familiar sights of a small town.

The film’s editing focuses on Seyfried’s emotional responses during important moments, and the story builds suspense using settings like notes, hallways, and nighttime car rides. It combines witty conversations with classic monster movie elements, and the climactic showdown depends on the established relationship between the main characters, using their past experiences to help them both survive and reveal the truth.

‘Letters to Juliet’ (2010)

Amanda Seyfried plays Sophie, a fact checker who travels to Verona and finds an old letter addressed to Juliet’s secretaries. She teams up with a young man, played by Christopher Egan, and his grandmother, played by Vanessa Redgrave, while Gael García Bernal plays Sophie’s fiancé. The movie centers around a journey through the Italian countryside, combining travel scenes with hints about a long-lost romance.

The film showcases beautiful settings like vineyards and town squares, including Verona’s iconic courtyard. The visuals emphasize warm lighting and spacious shots. Amanda Seyfried’s character diligently investigates names and locations, and the story is inspired by real letters written to Juliet. This adds a classic, literary feel to the contemporary romance, connecting it to a long-held tradition.

‘In Time’ (2011)

Amanda Seyfried appears alongside Justin Timberlake in a sci-fi action thriller directed and written by Andrew Niccol. The film is set in a world where time is literally money, and people stop getting older after a certain age. This creates a system where the wealthy can live for centuries, while the poor struggle with endless debt. Cillian Murphy plays the role of a timekeeper, and the film also features Olivia Wilde, Vincent Kartheiser, Matt Bomer, and Alex Pettyfer.

The film’s visual design clearly separates different areas of the city based on wealth, and these divisions become challenges during action scenes. As the story shifts into a robbery plot, Seyfried’s character evolves from a prisoner to a key player. The movie emphasizes what’s at stake in each exciting sequence by showcasing things like bank vaults, armored trucks, and constantly updating digital displays that track valuable items.

‘Mank’ (2020)

David Fincher’s new historical film stars Amanda Seyfried as Marion Davies and Gary Oldman as Herman J. Mankiewicz. The movie tells the story of how the screenplay for ‘Citizen Kane’ was written, showing the behind-the-scenes studio conflicts, radio programs, and social events that influenced its creation. The cast also includes Lily Collins, Arliss Howard, Tom Pelphrey, and Charles Dance.

Filmed in striking black and white, the movie meticulously recreated the era through its sets, locations, and costumes. The scenes between Seyfried and Oldman beautifully portray the dynamic between an actress and a writer. Her performance was critically acclaimed, earning her an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress and serving as a central point for discussions about fame and creative ownership.

‘First Reformed’ (2017)

I just finished watching this really compelling drama with Ethan Hawke and Amanda Seyfried. Seyfried plays Mary, a woman who approaches Hawke’s character, a Reverend, because she’s worried about her husband. He’s become totally consumed by despair over the environment, and it starts this whole ripple effect of choices. The movie has a really stripped-down feel – it’s mostly set in and around a small church, quiet streets, and simple homes – which I think really fits the characters and their everyday lives. It’s a very minimalist approach, and it works beautifully.

The movie’s square-shaped picture, minimal camera work, and quiet music all contribute to its thoughtful and inward-looking mood. Seyfried’s character offers a consistent support to Toller, and important scenes feature conversations about faith, loss, and duty, which ultimately shape the story’s climax and the choices made by the characters.

‘The Art of Racing in the Rain’ (2019)

Amanda Seyfried and Milo Ventimiglia star in this family drama, which is uniquely told from the perspective of a dog named Enzo, voiced by Kevin Costner. The film centers on a race car driver trying to manage his racing career and family life, with Enzo’s narration connecting seemingly ordinary moments to the driver’s important life choices. The story unfolds across various settings – race tracks, home kitchens, and hospital rooms – and touches on legal battles and issues surrounding child custody.

This movie is based on Garth Stein’s popular book and beautifully portrays the strong connection between a dog and his family. Amanda Seyfried’s character helps tell the story of the dog, Denny, and the film uses actual racing scenes and details to create a realistic backdrop. This realistic setting highlights the more intimate, emotional moments focused on family life.

Let us know your favorite Amanda Seyfried films in the comments, and tell us if there are any you think people should be watching more!

2025-09-23 18:09